49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 710 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.
"Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake"

Because that's why a 45 year old who has been following this team since he was about 8 years old wants right? He wants a QB for the 49ers to fail? YOU RIDICULOUS!
I don't want to be compared to the "b***h fight" that goes on in this room between 20 stupid years old. Don't include me into that garbage.
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.
i agree and the reasons why teams throw a lot is because they dont have consistent rbs like gore or even hunter.

exactly.

This passing trend will revert back to normal once these f**king morons realize that a balanced offense is superior to an all vertical game.


IMO
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.
"Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake"

Because that's why a 45 year old who has been following this team since he was about 8 years old wants right? He wants a QB for the 49ers to fail? YOU RIDICULOUS!
I don't want to be compared to the "b***h fight" that goes on in this room between 20 stupid years old. Don't include me into that garbage.

lol what ever you say man
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
exactly.

This passing trend will revert back to normal once these f**king morons realize that a balanced offense is superior to an all vertical game.


IMO

Exactly--on the balanced offense being superior part.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by WINiner:
Alex Smith IS playing much better, but I too agree with the thought that he's being hidden. That's good for him though. Alex Smith needs rebuilding, and Harbaugh is limiting the opportunity for mistake, while trying to put him in the best position to succeed on the plays he needs a pass. As the season has progressed Alex has been trusted with juust a little more each week. Harbaugh is rebuilding Alex the right way, but make no mistake, limiting Alex's attempts is 100% by design, and he's sitting near the bottom of the league in that statistic.


Well rebuilding him and building his confidence is not a bad thing. It's something SingleBrainCell and NoWin could never figure out. They will let him go more as the season progresses. Remeber they had no offseason, a new HC, new OC, and a new system. So everybody is not as far along as a team that played together for the last 5 years. It's to be expected. The bottom line is Alex is making plays and not turning it over. So when was the last time we saw that? People should be happy.

Oh I agree and am happier than I have been in a very long time mid NFL season. Harbaugh is an effin genius yet makes it look so easy.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has,
Really? Im trying to understand why some of you like this kid (not a kid anymore) so much. I don't get it. Alex Smith is not the future. If he was other teams would game plan for Alex. NOBODY GAME PLANS FOR ALEX SMITH.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.

That's true, but it's also true that our passing attack is below average when we do throw the football. 22nd in YPA, 28th in 1st down %. It's not just a lack of attempts.

I think every single person would take the Tampa or Philly game over 40 attempts 400 yards and 2 picks every day of the week. We just need to get our passing offense to be more consistent on a week to week basis.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Really? Im trying to understand why some of you like this kid (not a kid anymore) so much. I don't get it. Alex Smith is not the future. If he was other teams would game plan for Alex. NOBODY GAME PLANS FOR ALEX SMITH.


Don't hear teams game planning for QBs very often, mostly RBs, WRs and other skill positions. Not going to hear--let's move the corners closer to the line because Brady might break for the goal line. QBs with tendencies that can be planned against are called bad QBs. As in, they can't throw to their left, or they can't throw deep.

Smith has done everything asked of him with class and dignity. He has been seriously injured and tried to play through it, and he has had some of the worst situations of any QB in the NFL. Still turns up to work every day and with a good attitude.

At Utah Smith demonstrated that he could be a leader, be accurate, be a gamer, and win most of his games. He has demonstrated the same thing in the NFL but not consistently. What does good coaching help most? Consistency.

The fact that some people seem hell bent to see him fail is sad.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Really? Im trying to understand why some of you like this kid (not a kid anymore) so much. I don't get it. Alex Smith is not the future. If he was other teams would game plan for Alex. NOBODY GAME PLANS FOR ALEX SMITH.

sorry you feel that way, but if teams do gameplan against smith you won't know. stacking the box with 8-9 men to stop gore is also due to the fact that they dont trust smith to make any plays down the field. the fact that teams stopped stacking the box is a testament to alex's growth over the year.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.

That's true, but it's also true that our passing attack is below average when we do throw the football. 22nd in YPA, 28th in 1st down %. It's not just a lack of attempts.

I think every single person would take the Tampa or Philly game over 40 attempts 400 yards and 2 picks every day of the week. We just need to get our passing offense to be more consistent on a week to week basis.

True, reason being is playcalling, Morgan, Edwards being out, and so on. Some people think it's because of Smith, which I don't agree with. He's proven he can make the throws.
  • mike
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,827
I've been in a bit of a twitter discussion with this writer from Rotoworld that I typically respect for fantasy opinions, he has given up trying to argue with me but oh well lol. I guess the general media sentiment from these east coast guys is still skeptical.

The tweet I replied to:
@chriswesseling: @GregCosell for my boy @BruskiFB on Alex Smith: "They're scheming to minimize his impact on the game ... They're trying to hide him."

Me:
I'd say this isn't entirely true, they're confident in alex but they know whoever wins turnover battle wins game.

Him:
He's still a game manager. Against the Lions he was barely even that. He made one good throw ... when it counted.

Me:
whenever alex has absolutely needed to make a play, he's made it. Big emphasis on smarter decisionmaking with the ball.

Him:
His entire career is a testament to disappointment following any sign of improvement. Forgive me if expect a faceplant soon.

Me:
I just don't see a complete meltdown happening, most of the toughest games are out of the way in a very winnable division.

Him: His track record says he doesn't need a tough defense to have a meltdown.

Me: With such a big change to coaching I don't see how track record can really predict anything.Harbaugh has cleaned up his game

Him: You're fan. It's your job to believe that Harbaugh has turned him into a whole new player. But I don't believe that.

Me: He didn't need to turn him into a whole new player, just implement a style that gives alex quick options under pressure.

Then he finally gave up saying he doesn't care to try to change my mind lol.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has,
Really? Im trying to understand why some of you like this kid (not a kid anymore) so much. I don't get it. Alex Smith is not the future. If he was other teams would game plan for Alex. NOBODY GAME PLANS FOR ALEX SMITH.

Part of it, I think, is that we have heard prouncements made on him over the last years that write him off with such certitude. He is a "bust," he "couldn't start for any team in the NFL other than the Niners," he is a "coach-killer," he is not "tough (Alice)," he is "not clutch," he "cannot improvise," "he is not the future" and on and on. My feeling was Alex was being scapegoated for all the ills of the last ten years.

Finally, the organization is righting itself and heading in the right direction. In a big way. Alex gets with Harbaugh and his play has dramatically elevated. No OTA's and a new offense is being installed. The consensus was that it would take time for it all to click. On top of that we didn't have a full game where the Niners had Edwards, Crabtree and Morgan all playing together. Yet they are 5-1 and have played very well. They are no fluke.

The Eagles and the Bucs should have game planned for Alex if they didn't because he tore them up. None of us know exactly where this offense is going and how it will develop. But watching its evolution is very encouraging to say the least. Where will they be in week 16? Much further along then they are now is my guess. I don't know how you can say Alex is "not the future" anymore than I can say he is. Ultimately you may be right. But I have seen enough people be wrong on this "kid" to be kind of skeptical on anyone who thinks they can close the book on him right now.
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has,
Really? Im trying to understand why some of you like this kid (not a kid anymore) so much. I don't get it. Alex Smith is not the future. If he was other teams would game plan for Alex. NOBODY GAME PLANS FOR ALEX SMITH.

Part of it, I think, is that we have heard prouncements made on him over the last years that write him off with such certitude. He is a "bust," he "couldn't start for any team in the NFL other than the Niners," he is a "coach-killer," he is not "tough (Alice)," he is "not clutch," he "cannot improvise," "he is not the future" and on and on. My feeling was Alex was being scapegoated for all the ills of the last ten years.

Finally, the organization is righting itself and heading in the right direction. In a big way. Alex gets with Harbaugh and his play has dramatically elevated. No OTA's and a new offense is being installed. The consensus was that it would take time for it all to click. On top of that we didn't have a full game where the Niners had Edwards, Crabtree and Morgan all playing together. Yet they are 5-1 and have played very well. They are no fluke.

The Eagles and the Bucs should have game planned for Alex if they didn't because he tore them up. None of us know exactly where this offense is going and how it will develop. But watching its evolution is very encouraging to say the least. Where will they be in week 16? Much further along then they are now is my guess. I don't know how you can say Alex is "not the future" anymore than I can say he is. Ultimately you may be right. But I have seen enough people be wrong on this "kid" to be kind of skeptical on anyone who thinks they can close the book on him right now.

well said
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Really? Im trying to understand why some of you like this kid (not a kid anymore) so much. I don't get it. Alex Smith is not the future. If he was other teams would game plan for Alex. NOBODY GAME PLANS FOR ALEX SMITH.

sorry you feel that way, but if teams do gameplan against smith you won't know. stacking the box with 8-9 men to stop gore is also due to the fact that they dont trust smith to make any plays down the field. the fact that teams stopped stacking the box is a testament to alex's growth over the year.
Only on a 49er web site would anyone think Alex Smith is a threat.
[ Edited by 1stAndGoal49ers on Oct 20, 2011 at 8:05 PM ]
Other than VD and the emerging D.Walker, which receiver will other team game plan for... seriously, teams haven't game planing for Smith because Smith ain't got no one to throw the ball to after they double VD. And just recently VD had to stay in to block to help the offensive line. Smith and his receivers are not scaring any team right now. They were an effective unit when Morgan was playing. Maybe with Braylon back, they might be better.
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 20, 2011 at 8:03 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone