Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 1,019 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Alex is a good QB. He is doing what it takes to win. The 9ers don't pass as much as they run and when they do pass, we are actually moving the ball unlike years past.
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
Imo his game aganist the lions was bad, but he still made a few good/clutch throws when needed. Which in, and of itself is better than any previous version of Alex Smith.

Also remember to factor in all of the false start penalties.

It's difficult to make amazing plays when you start each series from 1st & 15, and the D knows you have to throw. Simply overcoming all of that negative inertia to be in a position to win is amazing in and of itself.
Originally posted by Byisgod:
I wish we would all just stop bickering. Alex is playing decent (even the haters have to agree) and we're 5-1. We need to face the facts--Alex is our starter right now, and therefore, we should be rooting for him to succeed.

For the ____th time, NO ONE Is rooting for him to fail. We are ALL Niner fans.

I wish you guys would stop with this nonsense.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Byisgod:
I wish we would all just stop bickering. Alex is playing decent (even the haters have to agree) and we're 5-1. We need to face the facts--Alex is our starter right now, and therefore, we should be rooting for him to succeed.

For the ____th time, NO ONE Is rooting for him to fail. We are ALL Niner fans.

I wish you guys would stop with this nonsense.
Some have openly admitted to rooting against him and wished injury upon the guy. Its true
Originally posted by valrod33:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Byisgod:
I wish we would all just stop bickering. Alex is playing decent (even the haters have to agree) and we're 5-1. We need to face the facts--Alex is our starter right now, and therefore, we should be rooting for him to succeed.

For the ____th time, NO ONE Is rooting for him to fail. We are ALL Niner fans.

I wish you guys would stop with this nonsense.
Some have openly admitted to rooting against him and wished injury upon the guy. Its true

Thats what happens when he has played like s*** for his whole career. This year is different. He is finally playing above average football. Which is all the people who were "openly rooting against him" wanted in the first place.

He is our QB and our team is winning. People arent rooting against him. In the past, maybe. Now, no.
Originally posted by Next9erDynasty:
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
Imo his game aganist the lions was bad, but he still made a few good/clutch throws when needed. Which in, and of itself is better than any previous version of Alex Smith.

Also remember to factor in all of the false start penalties.

It's difficult to make amazing plays when you start each series from 1st & 15, and the D knows you have to throw. Simply overcoming all of that negative inertia to be in a position to win is amazing in and of itself.

Yeah I can't believe that crap, all the false starts. Good stuff though from Smith overall, the video in the locker room after the game says it all. Harbs has faith in Smith, the team has faith in smith, and he was clutch.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Thats what happens when he has played like s*** for his whole career. This year is different. He is finally playing above average football. Which is all the people who were "openly rooting against him" wanted in the first place.

He is our QB and our team is winning. People arent rooting against him. In the past, maybe. Now, no.

So if I show you one example of someone rooting against him this year, will you stop with your delusions?
Alex smith thread is running out of Alex smith hate, bye week needs to go by faster.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Thats what happens when he has played like s*** for his whole career. This year is different. He is finally playing above average football. Which is all the people who were "openly rooting against him" wanted in the first place.

He is our QB and our team is winning. People arent rooting against him. In the past, maybe. Now, no.


When you speak for a whole group of posters it is wise not to be absolute. So, no one wishes Smith to fail? And you can state that with certainty because...? I read your post as your point of view and am happy you see it this way. Still disagree with your evaluation of Smith in the past as I still filter in bad coaching, inconistent and bad receiving, and terrible line.

When he has played well in the past it has been with the occassional good fortune of OLine blocking for more that a second, and receivers actually catching the ball on every opportunity. When he had bad days it was usually when he was being hit often and my observation is that most, if not all, QBs falter when this happens.

And remember, every single pro Smith poster agrees with every word I type, 100% or the time and you can bank on that!
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Godsleftsock:
I wanna see him do that over four quarters

Most NFL QBs dont' have 4 quarters of good football. Look at Tom Brady this year. He hasn't had a "complete" game yet. I'm not saying that it doesn't happen but more often than not most QBs will have an INT or some other stupid play(s) in a good or great game.

The issue with 9ers fans is that they either don't realize or convently forgot that Alex Smith doesn't have to play a perfect game or reach perfection. All we should want is 9er wins and good QB play. That is what he's been doing this year.

I thought everyone agreed he had 4 good quarters in the Bucs game... It was so good, Harbaugh had to put in Kaep to mop up. I know Smith doesn't have those type of games a lot of time, in part because the team have been bad for several years. But how quickly we forget and dismissed what little success he have had.

This. You can't have much of a better game than he did against the Bucs.
Originally posted by captveg:
This. You can't have much of a better game than he did against the Bucs.

The second half against Philly was right up there with the top performances of any QB this year.
I remember the dude got injured and we get threads like 'if Smith had played would we have lost this game?' or 'would he made the comeback' or 'would he had caught the ball if Smith was throwing the ball' or 'would he made the kick if Smith...', then the conjecture of hate would begin.

Then when he got a chance to play, the best qb is always the one sitting on the bench, Dilfer, Hill, Troy Smith, Davis... who am I missing
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 21, 2011 at 12:18 PM ]
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
I remember the dude got injured and we get threads like 'if Smith had played would we have lost this game?' or 'would he made the comeback' or 'would he had caught the ball if Smith was throwing the ball' or 'would he made the kick if Smith...', then the conjecture of hate would begin.

Then when he got a chance to play, the best qb is always the one sitting on the bench, Dilfer, Hill, Troy Smith, Davis... who am I missing


JT--is he playing in Chicago now?
  • jdean
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 165
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

Do yourself a favor and listen to Charlie Casserly talked about the Niners, Harbaugh and Alex Smith. Good stuff. And you may get a different perspective about our team. Front page. The dude was a NFL GM for a couple of teams so he knows football and teams personnel.

Where can I read/ listen to it.
Originally posted by jdean:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

Do yourself a favor and listen to Charlie Casserly talked about the Niners, Harbaugh and Alex Smith. Good stuff. And you may get a different perspective about our team. Front page. The dude was a NFL GM for a couple of teams so he knows football and teams personnel.

Where can I read/ listen to it.

casserly said that the 49ers are "hiding/protecting smith" and he said that equates to GOOD COACHING.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone