Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 583 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by gamechanger:
I hope Braylon cures some of the drop problems we've been having but his track record isn't too assuring. I think Crabtree is good but he and Alex need to get their chemistry/timing together. These 2 guys have consistently been inconsistent. So far with the job the coaches have done this issue with the passing game should go away. The one thing that remains to be true is that this team is getting better and better each day. If we don't see a dramatic improvement after the bye I will be very surprised.

Yeah, gotcha. Braylon's had his thing with the dropsies a couple years back, but I remember him having very few last year. Not too worried about him, unless we start to see those issues of old return.
Originally posted by Godsleftsock:
I wanna see him do that over four quarters

Most NFL QBs dont' have 4 quarters of good football. Look at Tom Brady this year. He hasn't had a "complete" game yet. I'm not saying that it doesn't happen but more often than not most QBs will have an INT or some other stupid play(s) in a good or great game.

The issue with 9ers fans is that they either don't realize or convently forgot that Alex Smith doesn't have to play a perfect game or reach perfection. All we should want is 9er wins and good QB play. That is what he's been doing this year.
Expecting Smith to play at a Tom Brady level is ridiculous. Alex is what is he is, and I'm happy with his performances so far. At the start of the season everyone figured the 9ers should suck-for-luck in part because of Smith. He's still not the long-term answer, but he's good enough for the moment. Can he make the next step and turn into top-flight QB? Doubt it. But at least I have a reason to watch 9er games again, and I'll take that.

It's also worth noting that his top 2 WR's are Crabtree and Tedd Ginn right now. Think about that for a moment.
[ Edited by bzborow1 on Oct 21, 2011 at 8:43 AM ]
Originally posted by susweel:
He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

Damn it, Sus. This is what I'm talking about.


Sea--124
Dal--179
Cin--201 Wrong!
Phi--291 Wrong!
TB--170
Det--125

Again, dude, you just won't give him an inch and he's your QB of our 5-1 team. For every positive out there, you HAVE to come back with a neg.

Whatever.

I still like you as a Bro, but damn, man, you can be such a pain. All you want to do is find fault. That's OK. 'Cause in the grand scheme of things, you're POV is really insignificant.

So is mine, but we won't go there.
To answer your post that got cut off...


Originally posted by CUZO49:
I believe in Alex, I think he's a good QB but I posted this for the haters. I'm seeing all this Alex smith negativity and it's mind boggling to me
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Takes a long time to get that tainted blood out of their system... might never happen. Best you're gonna get nowadays is the :

- "he's being hidden because Jim knows he is teh suxxorz and every other team aspect is great."

- "he's gone from worst QB ever to middle of the pack average at best."

They are not gonna admit full assessment fail... baby steps.



I just want Smith to take care of the football, make good decisions..he doesn't have to be Dan Marino out there...
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Godsleftsock:
I wanna see him do that over four quarters

Most NFL QBs dont' have 4 quarters of good football. Look at Tom Brady this year. He hasn't had a "complete" game yet. I'm not saying that it doesn't happen but more often than not most QBs will have an INT or some other stupid play(s) in a good or great game.

The issue with 9ers fans is that they either don't realize or convently forgot that Alex Smith doesn't have to play a perfect game or reach perfection. All we should want is 9er wins and good QB play. That is what he's been doing this year.

I thought everyone agreed he had 4 good quarters in the Bucs game... It was so good, Harbaugh had to put in Kaep to mop up. I know Smith doesn't have those type of games a lot of time, in part because the team have been bad for several years. But how quickly we forget and dismissed what little success he have had.
Originally posted by bzborow1:
Expecting Smith to play at a Tom Brady level is ridiculous. Alex is what is he is, and I'm happy with his performances so far. At the start of the season everyone figured the 9ers should suck-for-luck in part because of Smith. He's still not the long-term answer, but he's good enough for the moment. Can he make the next step and turn into top-flight QB? Doubt it. But at least I have a reason to watch 9er games again, and I'll take that.

It's also worth noting that his top 2 WR's are Crabtree and Tedd Ginn right now. Think about that for a moment.

why cant alex smith be the long term answer----he may be like one of mike vick's abused dogs, but some of them were rehabilitated ......Smith has gotten better every year, nothing to indicate that he has reached his plateau, and he is a better option than kaepernick right now, and next year
[ Edited by hofer36 on Oct 21, 2011 at 8:57 AM ]
It seems likely that Smith will continue developing under Harbaugh and become more fluid with his receivers toward the end of the year. A QB can't be built in a day but over this fall the coaching has made a radical difference in Smith's performance, so why not assume a continued learning/growth process?

I would like to see more from Smith as well. It would be nice to see him take advantage of every opportunity, not just in crunch time; and I think that will happen eventually if Harbaugh continues to bring him along in a way that will help build confidence. He also needs better WRs, or for these WRs to be better. Will Edwards motivate the rest to play with the same intensity he displays? Can't hurt having back! Really think Edwards, Crabtree and Morgan (with VD and Walker) can be something special if they can stay healthy and motivated. Dreams can come true!
Originally posted by oldman9er:

I'm not upset with his play...I just feel like at some point he's going to have to make more plays for us to win games

Don't even care who said it, but this? Give me a break. He has already had to put together drives to win games... and has.

He's making the throws... but what is he supposed to do? Catch the ball for the receivers also? Let's face it... sometimes our guys can make catches, but other times, they just look like they don't belong in the NFL. I mean, what kind of pro TE/WR are you when you (Walker) can't even turn your hands the proper way to catch a wide open TD pass? What good is 4.3 speed when you (Ginn) can't track and adjust to a deep ball? SF is without question in the top 10 for dropped passes this season. What happened to you (VD) that you're no longer breaking single tackles by DBs? So it's pretty clear that our playmakers need to improve their playmaking. This Jekyll and Hyde routine gets annoying.

. Worse than a broken record.
Originally posted by oldman9er:

I'm not upset with his play...I just feel like at some point he's going to have to make more plays for us to win games

Don't even care who said it, but this? Give me a break. He has already had to put together drives to win games... and has.

He's making the throws... but what is he supposed to do? Catch the ball for the receivers also? Let's face it... sometimes our guys can make catches, but other times, they just look like they don't belong in the NFL. I mean, what kind of pro TE/WR are you when you (Walker) can't even turn your hands the proper way to catch a wide open TD pass? What good is 4.3 speed when you (Ginn) can't track and adjust to a deep ball? SF is without question in the top 10 for dropped passes this season. What happened to you (VD) that you're no longer breaking single tackles by DBs? So it's pretty clear that our playmakers need to improve their playmaking. This Jekyll and Hyde routine gets annoying.

Best post on this page. I have been saying for the last 2-3 seasons, that even in games that smith does good the WR's don't help, or cause INT's (crabtree)
Originally posted by Leathaface:
. Worse than a broken record.

I understand that, but this record wouldn't keep skipping if peeps like yourself just turned the darn thing off, now would it?


Originally posted by unst4bl3:
Best post on this page. I have been saying for the last 2-3 seasons, that even in games that smith does good the WR's don't help, or cause INT's (crabtree)

... and thank you, sir. Go Niners AND the quarterback known as Alex Smith !!!
Guaranteed.

As soon as Alex has a bad game, all the crazies will be back in full voice waiting to say, "See, told ya so!" And at that moment, NT will be back to normal again.



OOps...Alex has had bad games...my bad.

NVM
[ Edited by ninertico on Oct 21, 2011 at 9:30 AM ]
Originally posted by ninertico:
Guaranteed.

As soon as Alex has a bad game, all the crazies will be back in full voice waiting to say, "See, told ya so!" And at that moment, NT will be back to normal again.



OOps...Alex has had bad games...my bad.

NVM

Imo his game aganist the lions was bad, but he still made a few good/clutch throws when needed. Which in, and of itself is better than any previous version of Alex Smith.
I wish we would all just stop bickering. Alex is playing decent (even the haters have to agree) and we're 5-1. We need to face the facts--Alex is our starter right now, and therefore, we should be rooting for him to succeed.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone