49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 658 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating
13 wins

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?
[ Edited by HessianDud on Oct 20, 2011 at 8:09 PM ]
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.

pretty much. and because he's not throwing 50 times a game, I guess.
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

Do yourself a favor and listen to Charlie Casserly talked about the Niners, Harbaugh and Alex Smith. Good stuff. And you may get a different perspective about our team. Front page. The dude was a NFL GM for a couple of teams so he knows football and teams personnel.
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 20, 2011 at 8:23 PM ]
Originally posted by HessianDud:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.

pretty much. and because he's not throwing 50 times a game, I guess.

I'm not upset with his play...I just feel like at some point he's going to have to make more plays for us to win games. Right now he's doing enough for us to not lose games save for the 2nd half @ Philly where he played great.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

if harbaugh didnt trust smith than they would have ran the ball on 4th and goal because they were red hot running that drive. I think we will start seeing them opening up the playbook after the bye esp since bray is coming back from injury.
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

if harbaugh didnt trust smith than they would have ran the ball on 4th and goal because they were red hot running that drive. I think we will start seeing them opening up the playbook after the bye esp since bray is coming back from injury.

Not saying Harbaugh doesn't trust Smith but you pick a terrible example...the ball was at the 6 yard line.
Originally posted by Leathaface:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.

pretty much. and because he's not throwing 50 times a game, I guess.

I'm not upset with his play...I just feel like at some point he's going to have to make more plays for us to win games. Right now he's doing enough for us to not lose games save for the 2nd half @ Philly where he played great.

i would love to see Smith play like he did @ Philly every game, but I think he has made plays in each and every game, even the loss, to help us win, or have a chance to win. I think he had his worst game against Detroit, for a number of reasons, one of them--the high throws under pressure in a tight game--troubling. The rest are understandable--drops, playing against a good defense, on the road in a loud stadium, etc--but those high throws, the inaccuracy, was a problem--but its a problem that can be fixed. Other than that, he's helped us win games. I don't buy the idea that Harbaugh is hiding Smith. Harbaugh runs a creative but conservative offense. Its always been all about the power running game. True to form, that's what we run. Harbaugh doesn't and never will run a spread style offense or anything close to it.

When we have needed Smith to make plays, he's made them. At this point, I'm happy to enjoy the present rather than try to project into the future about his or anyone's performance--besides, projecting into the future, at this point, using available evidence, shows that this team is full of awesomeness, including Smith.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

Do yourself a favor and listen to Charlie Casserly talked about the Niners, Harbaugh and Alex Smith. Good stuff. And you may get a different perspective about our team. Front page. The dude was a NFL GM for a couple of teams so he knows football and teams personnel.
I will give this a go Thank You!
Originally posted by Leathaface:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

if harbaugh didnt trust smith than they would have ran the ball on 4th and goal because they were red hot running that drive. I think we will start seeing them opening up the playbook after the bye esp since bray is coming back from injury.

Not saying Harbaugh doesn't trust Smith but you pick a terrible example...the ball was at the 6 yard line.

After the 2 minute warning, we had 2 shots at the end zone. The first one a defender came unblock on the left side. Smith tried to throw the ball as he was getting hit. The ball came in low and short at the corner of the end zone. Adding salt to injury, there were 2 of our guys in the same spot. Someone ran the wrong route either Kyle Williams ore Kendal Hunter. The second one, 4th and goal went to D. Walker. Those 2 plays is a bit of a culmination of our passing game right now. We are somehow getting it done with f*ckups right now.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I believe the 49er offense is hand-cuffed because of Alex Smith. Harbaugh does not trust Alex to explore the PLAY-BOOK. Harbaugh will turn off Alex once Keapernick or Tolzein is ready. STAY TUNED FOR 2012 !

and you know this how? It's what you want to believe, does not mean it is fact.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
People are bagging on Smith, but at this rate these will be his numbers:

3,000 yards
21 TDs
5 INTS
64% completion
7 YPA
95 rating

That would be a fantastic season. And, since that would be a fantastic season, why the hell do people have a problem with his performance thus far?

because he is not throwing for 400 yards a game.


He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.
Originally posted by susweel:
He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

I wonder what the team's record would be if he was?
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by susweel:
He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.

I wonder what the team's record would be if he was?


Probably the same.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone