Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 713 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by WildBill:
Keeping a player underwraps or not exposing him, minimizing him so that the team has a chance is nothing new. If the Eagles did that just a little, along with better schemeing in the red zone, they might have won more games and beaten us. Same can be said of the cowboys, if Romo wasn't exposed as much they may have 1 or 2 more wins.


I see the opposite. If Romo hadn't been given the green light against the 9ers Dallas would have lost the game. Romo has ADD or some other condition that causes him to be totally great one moment and out to lunch the next game. Dallas played conservative last game, trying to help Romo and they lost.

Vick's D let down the team after he did a very good job of putting them ahead.
Us shutting Vick down in the second half had a lot to do with it also.
Hiding-xcuses.


Wins = because of defense, special teams, Gore, other teams laying an egg, weather, santa clause, jesus, and the Republican party.


Losses = Alex Smith and Barack Hussein Obama.
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Hiding-xcuses.


Wins = because of defense, special teams, Gore, other teams laying an egg, weather, santa clause, jesus, and the Republican party.


Losses = Alex Smith and Barack Hussein Obama.

to be fair, he did promise to cover Miles Austin and then failed to do so.
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Hiding-xcuses.


Wins = because of defense, special teams, Gore, other teams laying an egg, weather, santa clause, jesus, and the Republican party.


Losses = Alex Smith and Barack Hussein Obama.

If it weren't for Alex making multiple plays on his feet and being clutch, I would easily arguing against him that he is having success only due to play design. However, we must give him props for using his instincts also.

Still needs to work on a couple of things but who doesn't.
Originally posted by HessianDud:
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Hiding-xcuses.


Wins = because of defense, special teams, Gore, other teams laying an egg, weather, santa clause, jesus, and the Republican party.


Losses = Alex Smith and Barack Hussein Obama.

to be fair, he did promise to cover Miles Austin and then failed to do so.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I see the opposite. If Romo hadn't been given the green light against the 9ers Dallas would have lost the game. Romo has ADD or some other condition that causes him to be totally great one moment and out to lunch the next game. Dallas played conservative last game, trying to help Romo and they lost.

Vick's D let down the team after he did a very good job of putting them ahead.

That is one game, I am talking about body of work. Romo had to against us, no choice, just like us against the eagles. In other games, he forced it. To be fare to Vick, the eagles are great between the hashes, but in the red zone, typically inside the 10, they clam up rather spreading out to cause space so that the opp don't crowd the box like we did when they were stopped by us.
Originally posted by WINiner:
Alex Smith IS playing much better, but I too agree with the thought that he's being hidden. That's good for him though. Alex Smith needs rebuilding, and Harbaugh is limiting the opportunity for mistake, while trying to put him in the best position to succeed on the plays he needs a pass. As the season has progressed Alex has been trusted with juust a little more each week. Harbaugh is rebuilding Alex the right way, but make no mistake, limiting Alex's attempts is 100% by design, and he's sitting near the bottom of the league in that statistic.

100% agree with this post ^^^
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Hiding-xcuses.


Wins = because of defense, special teams, Gore, other teams laying an egg, weather, santa clause.

Losses = Alex Smith.

Pretty much how the haters see it. They know who they are....
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Hiding-xcuses.


Wins = because of defense, special teams, Gore, other teams laying an egg, weather, santa clause, jesus, and the Republican party.


Losses = Alex Smith and Barack Hussein Obama.

If it weren't for Alex making multiple plays on his feet and being clutch, I would easily arguing against him that he is having success only due to play design. However, we must give him props for using his instincts also.

Still needs to work on a couple of things but who doesn't.



Joecool lukewarm and some positives for Alex Smith?
Originally posted by verb1der:
I still don't understand what "hiding a QB" really means.

i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.
i agree and the reasons why teams throw a lot is because they dont have consistent rbs like gore or even hunter.
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i think we definitely "hid" alex in the first game against seattle, but i think that was due to the lockout more than his talent

I hope Alex Smith can prove me wrong about him.

No you don't because he already has, you as well as people like yourself just refuse to see it. If he doesn't pass for 300+ yards every game he's a turd and we should get rid of him right?

so they can flood Ninertalk with crap about how they were right all along. It won't matter if we've won 10, 11, or 12 games by then, the ignorance will still fly.

One of the main reasons some of these qb's are throwing for so many yards is because they have 30, 40, or 50 pass attempts per game. That's not the kind of one-dimensional offense I want to see from the 49ers.
"Smith haters are just lying in wait for him to make some kind of crucial mistake"

Because that's why a 45 year old who has been following this team since he was about 8 years old wants right? He wants a QB for the 49ers to fail? YOU RIDICULOUS!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone