49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 949 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by LieutKaffee:
Originally posted by backontop:
Per NFL Network they are ranking Alex Smith as still being a top 5 QB

He's still missing the consistency in his throws that I want to see. However, the more I pay attention to other quarterbacks, the more inconsistency I see across the board. Stafford gets nothing but props, but the looked straight-up lost at times against us, and made inaccurate throws to boot. Once you realize that Brady, Brees, and Rodgers are pretty darn special, it gets easier to buy Alex as being in the next tier.

The league has gotten pass happy to a fault. QBs are bein allowed to play with way too many mistakes because their coaches are impatient and can't stand it if their offense doesn't score more than 17 or so points in a half.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by LieutKaffee:
Originally posted by backontop:
Per NFL Network they are ranking Alex Smith as still being a top 5 QB

He's still missing the consistency in his throws that I want to see. However, the more I pay attention to other quarterbacks, the more inconsistency I see across the board. Stafford gets nothing but props, but the looked straight-up lost at times against us, and made inaccurate throws to boot. Once you realize that Brady, Brees, and Rodgers are pretty darn special, it gets easier to buy Alex as being in the next tier.

The league has gotten pass happy to a fault. QBs are bein allowed to play with way too many mistakes because their coaches are impatient and can't stand it if their offense doesn't score more than 17 or so points in a half.

The NFL wants these games to be high scoring affairs. This is why they have always created rules that have sided with the offense. They think more points= more exciting=more viewrs=more money. This is why the defense pretty much has to let the QB and receiver play catch before they can even touch the receiver. Easy pitch and catch=moves the chains=scoring pts.
Member Milestone: This is post number 1,200 for Bryant4everYoung.
Originally posted by English:
Add another year with Harbaugh, and where will he be? This is the development that Rodgers was fortunate to get early. But early or late it looks as though Alex is still learning. And Harbaugh is the guy to teach him.

Top 3 qb in 2012!

Originally posted by LieutKaffee:
He's still missing the consistency in his throws that I want to see. However, the more I pay attention to other quarterbacks, the more inconsistency I see across the board. Stafford gets nothing but props, but the looked straight-up lost at times against us, and made inaccurate throws to boot. Once you realize that Brady, Brees, and Rodgers are pretty darn special, it gets easier to buy Alex as being in the next tier.

Bingo!

The thing with Alex is, he hasn't mixed in the huge, 350+ yard games to make fans overlook the occasional flaws. But all QBs have screwups each game that leave you going . I think the yardage and big plays will get bigger. It's not as if we have needed to chuck the ball much, and the times when we do? Guys like Ginn, VD, and Walker have been less than ideal on tracking/catching the ball. We also have gotten some big-yardage PI calls that gave us the field position but don't add to the QB stats.

Alex is far from perfect and has work to do, no question. But I do think at the end of the season, he will have earned that right to be accepted in the 2nd tier of QBs just beyond the elite 4-5.
We need better receivers. In the last 6-7 years Braylon Edwards is about the only one that came close to one. And I don't remember we ever drafted one in the first round until Crabtree. All of the receivers that came through here was very debatable whether they were top notch going on to elite type.
Originally posted by English:
Add another year with Harbaugh, and where will he be? This is the development that Rodgers was fortunate to get early. But early or late it looks as though Alex is still learning. And Harbaugh is the guy to teach him.

Top 3 qb in 2012!

this is what i'm curious to see. how much can Smith improve from what we're seeing? For the last couple of years I've been coming to the conclusion that his ceiling would look something like what we're seeing this season. But he's made big strides and is still gaining confidence, and you have to assume that he can keep getting better. But what is his ceiling? We still don't know, I think.

also, it will be really interesting to see what we do at the position after the season. I think Josh Johnson made it clear that he is not going to re-sign with Tampa and that he'd love to be reunited with Harbaugh. Can Smith play well enough to make the team not eve think about Johnson? If they brought Johnson in, could he beat him out? IDK.
I'd be ok with keeping Alex another year at this rate. If this is, in fact, his "ceiling" then so be it. It's a win win situation. We'll still do well next year while Kaep/Tolzien/Next years Drafted QB sits and learns. I still don't think Kaep will be ready until 2013.
Originally posted by HessianDud:
Originally posted by English:
Add another year with Harbaugh, and where will he be? This is the development that Rodgers was fortunate to get early. But early or late it looks as though Alex is still learning. And Harbaugh is the guy to teach him.

Top 3 qb in 2012!

this is what i'm curious to see. how much can Smith improve from what we're seeing? For the last couple of years I've been coming to the conclusion that his ceiling would look something like what we're seeing this season. But he's made big strides and is still gaining confidence, and you have to assume that he can keep getting better. But what is his ceiling? We still don't know, I think.

also, it will be really interesting to see what we do at the position after the season. I think Josh Johnson made it clear that he is not going to re-sign with Tampa and that he'd love to be reunited with Harbaugh. Can Smith play well enough to make the team not eve think about Johnson? If they brought Johnson in, could he beat him out? IDK.

I dont know either. But these qb questions are way better than the qb questions we faced for bl@@dy years!
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
I'd be ok with keeping Alex another year at this rate. If this is, in fact, his "ceiling" then so be it. It's a win win situation. We'll still do well next year while Kaep/Tolzien/Next years Drafted QB sits and learns. I still don't think Kaep will be ready until 2013.

At this rate I don't think the 49ers are going to be a position to say, "we'll keep you Alex for a one year contract." I believe his agent will get at least 3 years out of the 9ers. As for drafting a QB I dont' see it happening. Unless Luck falls to us in the mid to late 1st round there just is no point to wasting a pick on a QB when we have a 27 year old in Smith, 24 year old in Kaep and the same in Tolzien.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
We need better receivers. In the last 6-7 years Braylon Edwards is about the only one that came close to one. And I don't remember we ever drafted one in the first round until Crabtree. All of the receivers that came through here was very debatable whether they were top notch going on to elite type.


Agree and believe it could be a coaching issue as well. The 9ers developed two offensive players under Nolan and Singletary--Gore and VD. RBs are instinctive players and can be successful with a decent line, even when coaching and scheme are not great (and both concentrated on the run first offense). VD is a monster, and while he did succeed under these two coaches, he is still somewhat limited in his knowledge of adjusting to the D--a very key part of a TEs duty, particularly in the WCO.

So, could Lloyd or some of the other WRs who passed through have been helped by Harbaugh and company? I believe so. But you are absolutely correct about the low priority placed on the position by these two former HCs. My favorite of these ghosts is Antonio Bryant...baby TO. If he could have kept his head on straight he would have been quite a receiver.

We couldn't attract free agents as the OCs were changing every year and no one on the team could go out and talk to these guys and sell the team. They would have had to overpay as they did with Clements.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 20, 2011 at 10:43 AM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
We need better receivers. In the last 6-7 years Braylon Edwards is about the only one that came close to one. And I don't remember we ever drafted one in the first round until Crabtree. All of the receivers that came through here was very debatable whether they were top notch going on to elite type.


Agree and believe it could be a coaching issue as well. The 9ers developed two offensive players under Nolan and Singletary--Gore and VD. RBs are instinctive players and can be successful with a decent line, even when coaching and scheme are not great (and both concentrated on the run first offense). VD is a monster, and while he did succeed under these two coaches, he is still somewhat limited in his knowledge of adjusting to the D--a very key part of a TEs duty, particularly in the WCO.

So, could Lloyd or some of the other WRs who passed through have been helped by Harbaugh and company? I believe so. But you are absolutely correct about the low priority placed on the position by these two former HCs. My favorite of these ghosts is Antonio Bryant...baby TO. If he could have kept his head on straight he would have been quite a receiver.

We couldn't attract free agents as the OCs were changing every year and no one on the team could go out and talk to these guys and sell the team. They would have had to overpay as they did with Clements.

Losing OC every year affects our whole offense too. We were just too busy talking about Smith to realized the receivers are just as important. It's nice as a qb to see within 2-3 seconds that your first or second option is open, instead of staring them down all day waiting for one to be open or still trying to make his break. Very excited to see both Braylon and Crabtree on the field at the same time.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Greg Cosell says that we are trying to hide Alex Smith. Minimize his impact on the game.


Q: And that's the engine of the team, because they're really limiting Alex Smith's throws.

COSELL: Here's what they're doing with Alex Smith, and he's a great guy, so none of this is ever personal, but they're playing the games to minimize his impact on the game. And they're able to win games doing that, so more power to Harbaugh and the coaching staff. They're doing absolutely the right thing. I'm reading a lot of people talk about now Alex Smith is proving….Look. This is what they're doing. They're trying to hide him. They're trying to minimize his impact on the game. And that's great. Do you know what that's called? Coaching.
Originally posted by susweel:
Greg Cosell says that we are trying to hide Alex Smith. Minimize his impact on the game.


Q: And that's the engine of the team, because they're really limiting Alex Smith's throws.

COSELL: Here's what they're doing with Alex Smith, and he's a great guy, so none of this is ever personal, but they're playing the games to minimize his impact on the game. And they're able to win games doing that, so more power to Harbaugh and the coaching staff. They're doing absolutely the right thing. I'm reading a lot of people talk about now Alex Smith is proving….Look. This is what they're doing. They're trying to hide him. They're trying to minimize his impact on the game. And that's great. Do you know what that's called? Coaching.

That's true to a certain extent. Although I disagree with the idea that we are "hiding" him. If we were "hiding him" he wouldn't have 3 - 4th quarter comebacks THIS year. That argument made sense after the first couple games...but I'm sorry...you don't go 5-1 because you're "hiding" your QB.

I DO agree though that Alex isn't the focus of the offense. We don't need him to do much but that's just the way the chips fall. The kid has 8 TD and 2 INT nearly half way through the season. If that isn't "proving" something (compared to years past) I don't know what is. Seems like unless you're throwing for 300+ yards every game win or lose...you're being "hidden."

Again...not saying Cosell is an idiot or anything...just disagreeing with him about the idea that we are "hiding" Alex. If you watch all the games...that's just not the case. Plenty of good QBs on winning teams out there (in years past, this year, etc) who don't need to throw 50x/game to win. Does that mean they were all "hidden?"
  • lazy
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 5,687
Yeah "hide" is the wrong word...maybe "keeping Alex under control" or "keeping Alex smith out of his own way"...
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:

Again...not saying Cosell is an idiot or anything...just disagreeing with him about the idea that we are "hiding" Alex. If you watch all the games...that's just not the case. Plenty of good QBs on winning teams out there (in years past, this year, etc) who don't need to throw 50x/game to win. Does that mean they were all "hidden?"

Agree with this...as Smith has been instrumental, or clutch, in several wins. They are hiding him in the sense of not putting all the weight of the game on his shoulders and letting him sink or swin, because that would be the opposite of good coaching. He isn't ready to assume the full Brady/Manning-like responsibility for the offense, but they are building in that direction.

Harbaugh will be able to tell by the end of the year, especially if they make the playoffs, whether Smith's upside is enough to win a super bowl. If JH decides he is they will extend him at least three years and we can all hope for the 6th and 7th rings.

Cosell is just another pundit who wants to wait until all the votes are counted before he admits he is wrong...not a terrible thing to do in his position.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 20, 2011 at 11:56 AM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone