Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 781 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
If you were starting a team, which WRs from the 9ers would you pick? Edwards would be my only pick of the current group. Morgan is injured but I'm not sure he is more than a 3rd or 4th guy for most decent teams. Ginn should be doing just what he is doing for the 9ers--returning kicks and an occasional appearance at WR for speed. Walker is a very good utility guy but is not a full time WR.

More I think about it the draft was great except for R Johnson. Very disappointed they didn't get a receiver from the draft.

So pin your hopes on Edwards and Crabtree staying healthy all year, there's not much behind them yet until a young guy is brought along.

As for the QB list on the previous page...would take Smith over most, if not all. Brady and Rogers would be definate upgrades but for various reasons the rest would not.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 19, 2011 at 9:33 AM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
If you were starting a team, which WRs from the 9ers would you pick? Edwards would be my only pick of the current group. Morgan is injured but I'm not sure he is more than a 3rd or 4th guy for most decent teams. Ginn should be doing just what he is doing for the 9ers--returning kicks and an occasional appearance at WR for speed. Walker is a very good utility guy but is not a full time WR.

More I think about it the draft was great except for R Johnson. Very disappointed they didn't get a receiver from the draft.

So pin your hopes on Edwards and Crabtree staying healthy all year, there's not much behind them yet until a young guy is brought along.

As for the QB list on the previous page...would take Smith over most, if not all. Brady and Rogers would be definate upgrades but for various reasons the rest would not.

This is a good question. I wouldn't take any of our WRs, Braylon hasn't shown anything due to limited play (injury), Crabtree doesn't have the work ethic, Morgan like you said would probably be a 3rd or 4th on most teams, and Ginn is a return man. Now if we had a Calvin Johnson or Jennings, our offense would be way better. A game breaking WR could make this team so much more explosive.
Originally posted by gamechanger:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
If you were starting a team, which WRs from the 9ers would you pick? Edwards would be my only pick of the current group. Morgan is injured but I'm not sure he is more than a 3rd or 4th guy for most decent teams. Ginn should be doing just what he is doing for the 9ers--returning kicks and an occasional appearance at WR for speed. Walker is a very good utility guy but is not a full time WR.

More I think about it the draft was great except for R Johnson. Very disappointed they didn't get a receiver from the draft.

So pin your hopes on Edwards and Crabtree staying healthy all year, there's not much behind them yet until a young guy is brought along.

As for the QB list on the previous page...would take Smith over most, if not all. Brady and Rogers would be definate upgrades but for various reasons the rest would not.

This is a good question. I wouldn't take any of our WRs, Braylon hasn't shown anything due to limited play (injury), Crabtree doesn't have the work ethic, Morgan like you said would probably be a 3rd or 4th on most teams, and Ginn is a return man. Now if we had a Calvin Johnson or Jennings, our offense would be way better. A game breaking WR could make this team so much more explosive.

Morgan would be a #2 WR on most teams. He has both speed and size and he CAN out jump DB's for the ball along with YAC ability. How about this, if you were starting a team, out of the 32 QB's, which ones would you take Alex Smith ahead of?

One thing Alex is doing is throwing the ball to the first open receiver. HOWEVER, what has been noted by most analysts who watch game film is that he also misses or doesn't throw the big play more than most.

Joshua Morgan on GB would be getting 1000 yards as Rodgers would be able to allow Morgan to use his size and be squeezing balls in tight spots.
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,105
That fact that Alex Smith HIMSELF SAYS HE NEEDS TO USE THE BYE TO IMPROVE HIS GAME, gives me hope that he WILL PROVE to be a piece of the puzzle for our playoff return picture..
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by dj43:
"Accuracy" is a two-way street. The QB has to deliver a catchable ball in a place where the receiver can catch it. (stating the obvious) However, situations and circumstances move the blame around when a ball is not caught. Certainly when the QB does not put the ball in a catchable location he is guilty of being inaccurate on that throw. However, when a receiver lets a ball go through his extended hands, it is not the QB's fault. Receivers have to make plays on the ball.

One example; in the Green Bay game last Sunday, Aaron Rodgers underthrew a WIDE OPEN Jordy Nelson. Nelson had three steps on the defender with nothing but green between himself and the goal line. Did the pass fall incomplete? No. Nelson slowed down, waited to catch the ball, then juked the safety coming across the field and out ran everyone for an 87 yard TD completion. That is an example of what a good WR should do to not only help his QB but help his team as well. It is one big part of why Rodgers is having an MVP season - he has an entire group of receivers that are making plays on the ball like that. If Nelson had not been looking back and made the catch, Rodgers numbers would have been very mediocre 220 yards. Instead, he has another bonus day and more votes for MVP.

At the end of the day, I am more worried about the 49er receiving corp than about Alex Smith. Receivers (along with WR injuries) are the weak link on this team right now.

That example is a trivial context. MOST NFL receivers, including ours, make that type of adjustment as the receiver is so open that he doesn't need to worry about slowing down for the catch.

One aspect Alex has not been able to show that he is even marginally accurate is when he throws slightly off balance. He throws a terrible ball on the shortest routes when he is off balance.

Of balance: I don't include throwing while running being off balance as he is allowed to use the momentum of his movement to put strength into the throw. I mean when he's doing something Brady does all the time which is throw while taking a side step or like Rodgers who can make a throw while flat-footed due to a tight pocket. Alex has shown terrible accuracy that most QB's don't in these situations.

And our WR's do adjust well on the ball. Even GB receivers drop or misjudge balls here and there. Alex, for the most part, has been solid on his throws but has been far less than stellar when making throws that don't allow him to step into the throw. He has stepped into throws and immediately been hit but he still was able to step into it. It's when he doesn't get to step into it is when even a 5 yard throw becomes a terrible throw.

I think these are all legitimate points. I would only say that I don't think there are many QB's (other than the 4 or 5 most elite) who are good at throwing off balance. There are many who can do it at times, but at other times they throw horrible picks because of trying to do too much in those situations.

The only other thing that I take some issue with is that our WR's adjust well on the ball. first of all Crabtree adjusts well, and Braylon Adjusts well. Ginn does not adjust well at all, and Walker/Vernon don't do so great either. The others don't play enough to matter.

They all drop the ball too much. There is definitely a big difference between what Rodgers has, and what Smith is working with. Rodgers is the better QB by quite a ways regardless, but the WR's do factor in somewhat.
Great work by Alex Smith. Once the receivers learn and coordinate the timing better and stay healthy along with continued improvement in the offensive line, his performance will likely see even more advancement. At this junction, Smith is playing effective, clutch and yet very disciplined, with the way he makes decisions. Once the aforementioned aspects of the offense become more reliable, he may be able to take a few more risks and open up the big play passing game. It appears that the receivers and running backs have to improve their route patterns and timing by engaging in more practice with Smith. Josh Morgan seemed to be the most impressive of the bunch and regrettably he was lost for the season. Braylon Edwards was lost for several important games that could have helped further establish the rapport and chemistry that looked evident in the preseason. Hopefully, he will be back soon and pick up where he left off. The gelling of this offense is a process that may span into next season, but the initial receipts are promising. Alex Smith has been the most essential aspect in this offensive revitalization along with better blocking, running and improved overall fundamentals by the offense.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
If you were starting a team, which WRs from the 9ers would you pick? Edwards would be my only pick of the current group. Morgan is injured but I'm not sure he is more than a 3rd or 4th guy for most decent teams. Ginn should be doing just what he is doing for the 9ers--returning kicks and an occasional appearance at WR for speed. Walker is a very good utility guy but is not a full time WR.

More I think about it the draft was great except for R Johnson. Very disappointed they didn't get a receiver from the draft.

So pin your hopes on Edwards and Crabtree staying healthy all year, there's not much behind them yet until a young guy is brought along.

As for the QB list on the previous page...would take Smith over most, if not all. Brady and Rogers would be definate upgrades but for various reasons the rest would not.

This is a good question. I wouldn't take any of our WRs, Braylon hasn't shown anything due to limited play (injury), Crabtree doesn't have the work ethic, Morgan like you said would probably be a 3rd or 4th on most teams, and Ginn is a return man. Now if we had a Calvin Johnson or Jennings, our offense would be way better. A game breaking WR could make this team so much more explosive.

Morgan would be a #2 WR on most teams. He has both speed and size and he CAN out jump DB's for the ball along with YAC ability. How about this, if you were starting a team, out of the 32 QB's, which ones would you take Alex Smith ahead of?

One thing Alex is doing is throwing the ball to the first open receiver. HOWEVER, what has been noted by most analysts who watch game film is that he also misses or doesn't throw the big play more than most.

Joshua Morgan on GB would be getting 1000 yards as Rodgers would be able to allow Morgan to use his size and be squeezing balls in tight spots.

You have a point here, only because Rogers was groomed to be who he is today and we all know what happened to Alex. I really see what you're saying but it's not really a fair question on both the WR or QB. Because it takes more than just one person for them to be effective in their roles.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Morgan would be a #2 WR on most teams. He has both speed and size and he CAN out jump DB's for the ball along with YAC ability. How about this, if you were starting a team, out of the 32 QB's, which ones would you take Alex Smith ahead of?

One thing Alex is doing is throwing the ball to the first open receiver. HOWEVER, what has been noted by most analysts who watch game film is that he also misses or doesn't throw the big play more than most.

Joshua Morgan on GB would be getting 1000 yards as Rodgers would be able to allow Morgan to use his size and be squeezing balls in tight spots.


I would probably take four or five QBs before Smith if starting from scratch. Rogers and Brady are given, Brees and Rivers are among my favorites but there are some very good QBs I don't care for. Roethlisberger, E Manning and Romo are big play, big mistake kind of guys and are not suited for the WCO. I know they are playoff guys and two super bowl winners--still don't like them.

It is my belief that our starting QB is much better at his position than our starting WRs. Morgan was starting to blossom this year but he had been erratic in former years. He does fight for the ball though which is one of my keys to be a good WR.
– Quarterback Alex Smith's 95.2 passer rating ranks eighth, but his 109.2 fourth-quarter rating is the fourth best.


Link





CLUTCH!


This must be an improvement from years past. Can't ask for better play. Getting it done when it matters.


Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
– Quarterback Alex Smith's 95.2 passer rating ranks eighth, but his 109.2 fourth-quarter rating is the fourth best.


Link





CLUTCH!


This must be an improvement from years past. Can't ask for better play. Getting it done when it matters.



Interesting! Do you suppose that Harbaugh was actually expressing his true feelings when he said last winter that Alex was accurate, made good decisions and was very tough? When he said Alex is "Clutch...Clutch!" was he expressing his true feelings?

Smith is very good in the redzone, very good in 3rd and long, very good in the 4th quarter. Sounds lilke a good QB to me. But, if he isn't a championship caliber QB I will be fine with an upgrade. Just don't see him melting under pressure in the playoffs if he doesn't in other intense situations.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 19, 2011 at 11:54 AM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Interesting! Do you suppose that Harbaugh was actually expressing his true feelings when he said last winter that Alex was accurate, made good decisions and was very tough? When he said Alex is "Clutch...Clutch!" was he expressing his true feelings?

Smith may have problems between the 20s, but he has been very good in the redzone. Last Sunday was another showing of that.
I think the speed of the plays is helping him a lot, he seems to be recognizing and hitting the open receivers more often. I don't know, there is something different about him this year, and as I said before, I like it
Originally posted by King49er:
I think the speed of the plays is helping him a lot, he seems to be recognizing and hitting the open receivers more often. I don't know, there is something different about him this year, and as I said before, I like it

To me, I am noticing a pre-snap recognition from him. Like a receiver goes in motion, and suddenly Alex gives a subtle nod like, "okay, I know it's man D and I know who will be covering my SE, so I will look there first" type of thing. He's really reading defenses prior to the snap.

Only issue is, I have noticed that play-clock issues are rearing their ugly heads. Too many times last week were we lining up late and with little clock to allow for those pre-snap reads.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Here is the whole sentence: Alex played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league.

So let me get this straight. As long as a quarterback is playing in a loud stadium against a very good defense, having a 50% completion percentage for 120 yards, with one touchdown and two turnovers is considered "playing fine?" Its not. Period. It would be like the San Francisco Giants playing against Phillies in Philadelphia.....a game where the crowd is jacked up......Roy Halladay is on the mound.....we get 2 hits but we manage to win the game 1-0....and then saying our offense "played fine." See how silly that sounds?

And how does eliminating the rest of your sentence do anything to the context? I have the same opinion with it, or without it.

So I am guessing it is Smith's fault that two TD's were dropped along with the three other passes that were clearly dropped. Also he is responsible for all the penalties that started us off with first and 20? It is a team effort and you would have us believe that Smith didn't have a decent game? I say to you that throwing the game winning touchdown against an undefeated team on 4th and 6 in one of the loudest stadiums in the NFL is having a pretty decent game, if you disagree, then you have a really unrealistic way of measuring QB's. The only stat that matters is the win man, that throw was as clutch as any throw I have seen any Niners QB make in a regular season game. If you cannot be happy with a QB that has lead the team to three comeback wins against good teams on the road, I don't know what to tell you.
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Here is the whole sentence: Alex played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league.

So let me get this straight. As long as a quarterback is playing in a loud stadium against a very good defense, having a 50% completion percentage for 120 yards, with one touchdown and two turnovers is considered "playing fine?" Its not. Period. It would be like the San Francisco Giants playing against Phillies in Philadelphia.....a game where the crowd is jacked up......Roy Halladay is on the mound.....we get 2 hits but we manage to win the game 1-0....and then saying our offense "played fine." See how silly that sounds?

And how does eliminating the rest of your sentence do anything to the context? I have the same opinion with it, or without it.

So I am guessing it is Smith's fault that two TD's were dropped along with the three other passes that were clearly dropped. Also he is responsible for all the penalties that started us off with first and 20? It is a team effort and you would have us believe that Smith didn't have a decent game? I say to you that throwing the game winning touchdown against an undefeated team on 4th and 6 in one of the loudest stadiums in the NFL is having a pretty decent game, if you disagree, then you have a really unrealistic way of measuring QB's. The only stat that matters is the win man, that throw was as clutch as any throw I have seen any Niners QB make in a regular season game. If you cannot be happy with a QB that has lead the team to three comeback wins against good teams on the road, I don't know what to tell you.

What he said.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone