There are 744 users in the forums
Alex Smith Thread
Oct 19, 2011 at 1:09 PM
- g60nx
- Veteran
- Posts: 99
He is already a legend. One way or another
Oct 19, 2011 at 1:17 PM
- AZ9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 6,887
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by King49er:
I think the speed of the plays is helping him a lot, he seems to be recognizing and hitting the open receivers more often. I don't know, there is something different about him this year, and as I said before, I like it
To me, I am noticing a pre-snap recognition from him. Like a receiver goes in motion, and suddenly Alex gives a subtle nod like, "okay, I know it's man D and I know who will be covering my SE, so I will look there first" type of thing. He's really reading defenses prior to the snap.
Only issue is, I have noticed that play-clock issues are rearing their ugly heads. Too many times last week were we lining up late and with little clock to allow for those pre-snap reads.
Good take on what going on, on the field with Alex. I am sure they will get the play clock issue fixed in the bye week, am sure Harbaugh is going over all of the little hiccups from the first six games
Oct 19, 2011 at 1:53 PM
- DonnieDarko
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,102
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.
i have no problem with some throwing incomplete passes or an INT here and there, it happens. i'm just concerned that all of his high throws are to crabtree. yes crabtree deserves some blame for not running the correct route at times but it can't all be his fault. If Smith corrects his mechanics and hits Crabtree more accurately then that'll be a huge plus.
Oct 19, 2011 at 1:57 PM
- Nes49
- Veteran
- Posts: 6,105
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.
i have no problem with some throwing incomplete passes or an INT here and there, it happens. i'm just concerned that all of his high throws are to crabtree. yes crabtree deserves some blame for not running the correct route at times but it can't all be his fault. If Smith corrects his mechanics and hits Crabtree more accurately then that'll be a huge plus.
I just think that they just don't have a feel for one another due to Crabtree's inability to participate in practices due to his foot injury.
Oct 19, 2011 at 2:03 PM
- Jakemall
- Veteran
- Posts: 21,807
Originally posted by Nes49:Originally posted by DonnieDarko:Originally posted by WillistheWall:he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.
i have no problem with some throwing incomplete passes or an INT here and there, it happens. i'm just concerned that all of his high throws are to crabtree. yes crabtree deserves some blame for not running the correct route at times but it can't all be his fault. If Smith corrects his mechanics and hits Crabtree more accurately then that'll be a huge plus.
I just think that they just don't have a feel for one another due to Crabtree's inability to participate in practices due to his foot injury.
Several of us reviewed the game. There were only a few "bad" passes. The rest were all catchable or exactly where they need to be. Few meaning 3 . They are not in perfect sync, but they are doing better.
Oct 19, 2011 at 2:05 PM
- DonnieDarko
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,102
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by Nes49:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.
i have no problem with some throwing incomplete passes or an INT here and there, it happens. i'm just concerned that all of his high throws are to crabtree. yes crabtree deserves some blame for not running the correct route at times but it can't all be his fault. If Smith corrects his mechanics and hits Crabtree more accurately then that'll be a huge plus.
I just think that they just don't have a feel for one another due to Crabtree's inability to participate in practices due to his foot injury.
Several of us reviewed the game. There were only a few "bad" passes. The rest were all catchable or exactly where they need to be. Few meaning 3 . They are not in perfect sync, but they are doing better.
i'm talking about the whole season so far, it's been a trend. though i do hope it's getting better.
Oct 19, 2011 at 2:15 PM
- Jakemall
- Veteran
- Posts: 21,807
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by Nes49:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.
i have no problem with some throwing incomplete passes or an INT here and there, it happens. i'm just concerned that all of his high throws are to crabtree. yes crabtree deserves some blame for not running the correct route at times but it can't all be his fault. If Smith corrects his mechanics and hits Crabtree more accurately then that'll be a huge plus.
I just think that they just don't have a feel for one another due to Crabtree's inability to participate in practices due to his foot injury.
Several of us reviewed the game. There were only a few "bad" passes. The rest were all catchable or exactly where they need to be. Few meaning 3 . They are not in perfect sync, but they are doing better.
i'm talking about the whole season so far, it's been a trend. though i do hope it's getting better.
Well, Crabtree's injury not only plays with the Chemistry but also reduces Crabtree's ability. So as he gets healthier and they practise more together, I'm sure it'll be fine. I'm really happy that BE is coming back.
I'm pleased as punch with Alex's performance this season. He may not be throwing for 300 yards every game, but I like that he doesn't need to. I'd love to see the 9ers take this season by storm..it might bring a resurgance of the running game. Everyone had pretty much given up on running with all the new rules. If they can pull it off, they'll have an edge against defenses for a couple of years because teams are built to stop pass these days, not rush.
Oct 19, 2011 at 3:01 PM
- 80sbaby24
- Member
- Posts: 2,990
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Here is the whole sentence: Alex played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league.
So let me get this straight. As long as a quarterback is playing in a loud stadium against a very good defense, having a 50% completion percentage for 120 yards, with one touchdown and two turnovers is considered "playing fine?" Its not. Period. It would be like the San Francisco Giants playing against Phillies in Philadelphia.....a game where the crowd is jacked up......Roy Halladay is on the mound.....we get 2 hits but we manage to win the game 1-0....and then saying our offense "played fine." See how silly that sounds?
And how does eliminating the rest of your sentence do anything to the context? I have the same opinion with it, or without it.
So I am guessing it is Smith's fault that two TD's were dropped along with the three other passes that were clearly dropped. Also he is responsible for all the penalties that started us off with first and 20? It is a team effort and you would have us believe that Smith didn't have a decent game? I say to you that throwing the game winning touchdown against an undefeated team on 4th and 6 in one of the loudest stadiums in the NFL is having a pretty decent game, if you disagree, then you have a really unrealistic way of measuring QB's. The only stat that matters is the win man, that throw was as clutch as any throw I have seen any Niners QB make in a regular season game. If you cannot be happy with a QB that has lead the team to three comeback wins against good teams on the road, I don't know what to tell you.
In order of your points....
-Stop putting words in my mouth. I never said the drops were Alex's fault (although I dont know how you can possibly include Crabtree's almost touchdown as a "drop." He made a hell of an effort and almost scored on the play. Completely different than Delanie's drop)
-Again, did I say it was Alex's fault for the penalties? Of course not. Dont be silly.
-I have given Alex a TON of props for the game winning throw. Look for them if you think I am lying. But I just dont understand how you can evaluate an entire game's worth of play on one single throw. Did he make the best throw of his entire career on 4th and 6? Absolutely. It was great. Amazing. Clutch. I just cant let that one throw dictate how I feel Alex played in Detroit. If Ben Roethlisberger would have thrown a touchdown pass on the last drive of last year's SB, would you have said he had a good game? Of course not. He played like s*** the entire game.
-The only stat that matters is a win. I wholeheartedly agree with you. Been arguing that point for years when some people continued to condescendingly tell me that quarterbacks dont have winning percentages. I disagree with that. They do. Winning is all that mattered, and we got the win on Sunday.
-I never said I wasnt happy. I am thrilled with the way we have played, and I am THRILLED with how Alex has played this year. He isnt hurting this team like he did in the past. For the most part, he is playing very good football. Much better than expected. At times he is leading this team to wins. At times he is managing the game so other facets of our team can win the game. Both of those are things he has never done before. Of course I am happy with how he is playing.
I just cant get behind comments like "hes top 5" or similiar type comments. Im sorry if I am not a huge Alex fan. But I am behind him 100% and hope he leads us to a title. Its absolutely amazing how much Harbaugh has made a difference in Alex's game.
Oct 19, 2011 at 3:41 PM
- DonnieDarko
- Veteran
- Posts: 67,102
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Well, Crabtree's injury not only plays with the Chemistry but also reduces Crabtree's ability. So as he gets healthier and they practise more together, I'm sure it'll be fine. I'm really happy that BE is coming back.
I'm pleased as punch with Alex's performance this season. He may not be throwing for 300 yards every game, but I like that he doesn't need to. I'd love to see the 9ers take this season by storm..it might bring a resurgance of the running game. Everyone had pretty much given up on running with all the new rules. If they can pull it off, they'll have an edge against defenses for a couple of years because teams are built to stop pass these days, not rush.
yeah as long as we keep winning i could care less if smith only throws for 100 yards a game. he's been playing really well thus far. braylon should definitely help.
i actually love the fact that everyone now considers the NFL a "passing league" and how harbaugh is bucking that trend. if we can keep winning with a badass running game, great D and great special teams i see no point in trying to get smith 300 yards a game.
Oct 19, 2011 at 4:32 PM
- BHulman
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,338
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Here is the whole sentence: Alex played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league.
So let me get this straight. As long as a quarterback is playing in a loud stadium against a very good defense, having a 50% completion percentage for 120 yards, with one touchdown and two turnovers is considered "playing fine?" Its not. Period. It would be like the San Francisco Giants playing against Phillies in Philadelphia.....a game where the crowd is jacked up......Roy Halladay is on the mound.....we get 2 hits but we manage to win the game 1-0....and then saying our offense "played fine." See how silly that sounds?
And how does eliminating the rest of your sentence do anything to the context? I have the same opinion with it, or without it.
So I am guessing it is Smith's fault that two TD's were dropped along with the three other passes that were clearly dropped. Also he is responsible for all the penalties that started us off with first and 20? It is a team effort and you would have us believe that Smith didn't have a decent game? I say to you that throwing the game winning touchdown against an undefeated team on 4th and 6 in one of the loudest stadiums in the NFL is having a pretty decent game, if you disagree, then you have a really unrealistic way of measuring QB's. The only stat that matters is the win man, that throw was as clutch as any throw I have seen any Niners QB make in a regular season game. If you cannot be happy with a QB that has lead the team to three comeback wins against good teams on the road, I don't know what to tell you.
I just saw the numbers of what Alex has done the last 12 games: Niners have gone 8-4, 16 T.D.s to 3 interceptions (wow!) and a 95.2 passing rating. Also, as stated above, three comeback wins on the road. Will more time with Harbaugh and in this offense still yield better results? That is not out of the realm of possibility.
Oct 19, 2011 at 4:44 PM
- VA49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,863
We could not do better than finding out that Alex Smith has a higher ceiling and the ability to play better more consistently. I think if nothing else he has already played well enough to continue grooming Kaep. I wonder if Tolzien will get some snaps this season? It seems like he is the safety valve. I like the way they brought Kaep in on some of the sideline huddles. Sort of a way to expose him to those moments and watch, listen, and learn.
Oct 19, 2011 at 9:29 PM
- backontop
- Veteran
- Posts: 14,346
Per NFL Network they are ranking Alex Smith as still being a top 5 QB
Oct 19, 2011 at 11:09 PM
- LieutKaffee
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,988
Originally posted by backontop:
Per NFL Network they are ranking Alex Smith as still being a top 5 QB
He's still missing the consistency in his throws that I want to see. However, the more I pay attention to other quarterbacks, the more inconsistency I see across the board. Stafford gets nothing but props, but the looked straight-up lost at times against us, and made inaccurate throws to boot. Once you realize that Brady, Brees, and Rodgers are pretty darn special, it gets easier to buy Alex as being in the next tier.
Oct 20, 2011 at 12:01 AM
- BROWN
- Veteran
- Posts: 207
Kurt Warner got him #4 in the league right now. Kicked Brees off, and put E. Manning at 3.. and has Vick at 5.
Oct 20, 2011 at 12:07 AM
- English
- Moderator
- Posts: 41,473
Add another year with Harbaugh, and where will he be? This is the development that Rodgers was fortunate to get early. But early or late it looks as though Alex is still learning. And Harbaugh is the guy to teach him.
Top 3 qb in 2012!
Top 3 qb in 2012!
