Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 879 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by susweel:
Experts who say Smith is good = Geniuses

Experts who say Smith is mediocre = Idiots

They're all idiots. None of them said we had a chance this year.

None of them know what Alex can do...just what he's doing.

I'm happy with the way he's playing and if he keeps it up then it may turn out he was worth the first round pick afterall.
Originally posted by WildBill:
I myself agree with Susweel and Cossel-they are in a way hiding Alex. While it wasn't his fault, they want to prevent exposing him unecessarily to what happend in the first series (which was not his fault) and the second half int., this does two things, keep the niners in the game and keep his confidence high. Any QB can get rattled, some more than others though-which is Alex. He is not like Manning, Brees or Brady where he can have several bad games but shake it off. Basically when Cossel says he is hiding Alex- JH is not exposing him to minimize getting hit and making. JH is in his ear all the time, but doing it in a way doesn't across as (I don't trust you), but rather look out for this and etc. On that comeback btw, it was great, but credit goes to the running game though Alex finished it off, but in the previous drives he couldn't get it done in the 2nd half, he was floating balls, but that is okay because it setup the run as the lions couldn't take a chance that a pass might connect for a big one.


Two high throws, one intercepted. Smith opened up the run by hitting Ginn for a nice gain, Crabtree for a nice gain and was looking much sharper as he tends to be in the 4th quarter--clutch time. So, you are correct that Harbaugh is bringing Smith along slowly and is very aware of building his confidence back up after years of being beaten down.

The only time I've seen Smith get rattled is when the game is going down the toilet and Nolan/Singletary told him to make something happen. He looked out at receivers who couldn't catch and a great TE who couldn't read a blitz and tried too hard to "make something happen."

Harbaugh is showing me that he is a great coach. He is winning, while at the same time building a QB. Even Walsh did not do that, though he didn't have the horses that the 9ers currently have.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 20, 2011 at 12:25 PM ]
Keeping a player underwraps or not exposing him, minimizing him so that the team has a chance is nothing new. If the Eagles did that just a little, along with better schemeing in the red zone, they might have won more games and beaten us. Same can be said of the cowboys, if Romo wasn't exposed as much they may have 1 or 2 more wins.
Originally posted by susweel:
Dang Tico so much anger. Take it easy bro we are 5-1

Just tired of all the BS and not giving credit where credit is due even at 5-1. More and more, I really hope Alex does have a significant passing game to shut them all up. You know...+300yds, 3TDs, No Ints.

There's this underlying context, it seems, that some expect or even want Alex to fail. It's in the tone and the language. Cosell's POV is thick with it without even an acknowledgement of what Alex has accomplished in his three comebacks against the Bengals, Eagles and Lions. He led those drives. Made throws, great ones even. Ran. Showed and demonstrated grit.

"...but they're playing the games to minimize his (Alex's) impact on the game." He even mentions that it's nothing personal.

Yet, I can see why Cosell is saying it. It's on tape, Alex's historic epic failures. Hell, he was the poster boy of QB failure. Still, that was in the past. Now that we have a coach who can teach him properly and get the most out of him (Cosell does acknowledge this), we get this "Alex still sucks" or "they're containing him so that he doesn't harm the team".

Again, total and utter BS. Harbaugh wouldn't give Alex the reigns to the offense if he didn't believe in him. Wouldn't call the last play with a pass, if he didn't believe in his skill. That last play slap's Cosell's argument in the face

It's just those three initials again, Sus.

POV

Is he Brady, Brees or Rodgers? Oh hell, naw. Don't matter. Alex is gettin' it done his way at 5-1 and that's all that matters.

  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by susweel:
Dang Tico so much anger. Take it easy bro we are 5-1

Just tired of all the BS and not giving credit where credit is due even at 5-1. More and more, I really hope Alex does have a significant passing game to shut them all up. You know...+300yds, 3TDs, No Ints.

There's this underlying context, it seems, that some expect or even want Alex to fail. It's in the tone and the language. Cosell's POV is thick with it without even an acknowledgement of what Alex has accomplished in his three comebacks against the Bengals, Eagles and Lions. He led those drives. Made throws, great ones even. Ran. Showed and demonstrated grit.

"...but they're playing the games to minimize his (Alex's) impact on the game." He even mentions that it's nothing personal.

Yet, I can see why Cosell is saying it. It's on tape, Alex's historic epic failures. Hell, he was the poster boy of QB failure. Still, that was in the past. Now that we have a coach who can teach him properly and get the most out of him (Cosell does acknowledge this), we get this "Alex still sucks" or "they're containing him so that he doesn't harm the team".

Again, total and utter BS. Harbaugh wouldn't give Alex the reigns to the offense if he didn't believe in him. Wouldn't call the last play with a pass, if he didn't believe in his skill. That last play slap's Cosell's argument in the face

It's just those three initials again, Sus.

POV

Is he Brady, Brees or Rodgers? Oh hell, naw. Don't matter. Alex is gettin' it done his way at 5-1 and that's all that matters.


This is what I want also, it would be great to see.
Originally posted by Archie:
I am sorry but after looking at qbr ratings on espn, I think they're accurate for the most part. Alex Smith is rated the 28th best qb and I think that's right. The 49ers are minimizing Smith's impact but let me say this Smith has played very well at times, but Alex Smith is a mediocre quarterback, a Trent Dilfer reincarnation. There is not one guy in the bottom 16 of those ratings that needs to be in the top ten of those ratings. I don't like Eli Manning as a player because I think he gets too much credit but then Eli will several good-great games in a row before having a bad ballgame and he will have those by his own admission. Alex is not that good but the rest of the team is and when Alex plays well it lifts the entire team to another level such as in the Eagles game. As long as the 49ers win that's the most important thing but objectively Smith is a sorry qb.

Yeah man that 4th and 6 pass to win the game was the mark of a terrible sorry ass QB. Man you wanna base a QB's performance on that ESPN s**t go right ahead, but it is total trash.
  • Nuns
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,301
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by susweel:
Dang Tico so much anger. Take it easy bro we are 5-1

Just tired of all the BS and not giving credit where credit is due even at 5-1. More and more, I really hope Alex does have a significant passing game to shut them all up. You know...+300yds, 3TDs, No Ints.

There's this underlying context, it seems, that some expect or even want Alex to fail. It's in the tone and the language. Cosell's POV is thick with it without even an acknowledgement of what Alex has accomplished in his three comebacks against the Bengals, Eagles and Lions. He led those drives. Made throws, great ones even. Ran. Showed and demonstrated grit.

"...but they're playing the games to minimize his (Alex's) impact on the game." He even mentions that it's nothing personal.

Yet, I can see why Cosell is saying it. It's on tape, Alex's historic epic failures. Hell, he was the poster boy of QB failure. Still, that was in the past. Now that we have a coach who can teach him properly and get the most out of him (Cosell does acknowledge this), we get this "Alex still sucks" or "they're containing him so that he doesn't harm the team".

Again, total and utter BS. Harbaugh wouldn't give Alex the reigns to the offense if he didn't believe in him. Wouldn't call the last play with a pass, if he didn't believe in his skill. That last play slap's Cosell's argument in the face

It's just those three initials again, Sus.

POV

Is he Brady, Brees or Rodgers? Oh hell, naw. Don't matter. Alex is gettin' it done his way at 5-1 and that's all that matters.

t

Winning is all that matters. He has the tools, just needs the confidence and experience gained from winning. He might be getting that. I don't know if Harbaugh seems him as a stop gap, but if we beat Cleveland (as we should) Smith will have no reason to doubt himself or this team.

If we lose to Cleveland, this thread with light afire.
Originally posted by samoan49er:
If Cosell wants to see hiding, then he should watch the tape of the Cowboys' 4th quarter in their last game. The way they ended that game, that was the definition of "hiding" a quarterback. We're pretty much doing whatever it takes to win each game, and each game we won, didn't necessarily require Smith to light it up.

THIS!

damon bruce had someone on who basically said that you can read the type of confidence (in this case-lack of) garrett has for romo with that fourth quarter play calling against the pats.
Originally posted by susweel:
This is what I want also, it would be great to see.

I would too, but it's not that important to me.

Winning is.
Alex Smith IS playing much better, but I too agree with the thought that he's being hidden. That's good for him though. Alex Smith needs rebuilding, and Harbaugh is limiting the opportunity for mistake, while trying to put him in the best position to succeed on the plays he needs a pass. As the season has progressed Alex has been trusted with juust a little more each week. Harbaugh is rebuilding Alex the right way, but make no mistake, limiting Alex's attempts is 100% by design, and he's sitting near the bottom of the league in that statistic.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by susweel:
This is what I want also, it would be great to see.

I would too, but it's not that important to me.

Winning is.

Winning always is.
Originally posted by WINiner:
Alex Smith IS playing much better, but I too agree with the thought that he's being hidden. That's good for him though. Alex Smith needs rebuilding, and Harbaugh is limiting the opportunity for mistake, while trying to put him in the best position to succeed on the plays he needs a pass. As the season has progressed Alex has been trusted with juust a little more each week. Harbaugh is rebuilding Alex the right way, but make no mistake, limiting Alex's attempts is 100% by design, and he's sitting near the bottom of the league in that statistic.


Well rebuilding him and building his confidence is not a bad thing. It's something SingleBrainCell and NoWin could never figure out. They will let him go more as the season progresses. Remeber they had no offseason, a new HC, new OC, and a new system. So everybody is not as far along as a team that played together for the last 5 years. It's to be expected. The bottom line is Alex is making plays and not turning it over. So when was the last time we saw that? People should be happy.
This thread is 6 years in the making
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by susweel:
This is what I want also, it would be great to see.

I would too, but it's not that important to me.

Winning is.

Winning always is.

Noooo Waaayyysss... 400 yards, 3 picks and a loss is always better.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by susweel:
This is what I want also, it would be great to see.

I would too, but it's not that important to me.

Winning is.

Winning always is.

Noooo Waaayyysss... 400 yards, 3 picks and a loss is always better.

I know raider fans who think like that lol
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone