49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 891 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by lazy:
Yeah "hide" is the wrong word...maybe "keeping Alex under control" or "keeping Alex smith out of his own way"...

How about some words from the guy that knows him best -- 'managing the game', 'lights out', 'clutch' -- Jim Harbaugh.
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 20, 2011 at 11:57 AM ]
If Cosell wants to see hiding, then he should watch the tape of the Cowboys' 4th quarter in their last game. The way they ended that game, that was the definition of "hiding" a quarterback. We're pretty much doing whatever it takes to win each game, and each game we won, didn't necessarily require Smith to light it up.
I am sorry but after looking at qbr ratings on espn, I think they're accurate for the most part. Alex Smith is rated the 28th best qb and I think that's right. The 49ers are minimizing Smith's impact but let me say this Smith has played very well at times, but Alex Smith is a mediocre quarterback, a Trent Dilfer reincarnation. There is not one guy in the bottom 16 of those ratings that needs to be in the top ten of those ratings. I don't like Eli Manning as a player because I think he gets too much credit but then Eli will several good-great games in a row before having a bad ballgame and he will have those by his own admission. Alex is not that good but the rest of the team is and when Alex plays well it lifts the entire team to another level such as in the Eagles game. As long as the 49ers win that's the most important thing but objectively Smith is a sorry qb.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Again...not saying Cosell is an idiot or anything...just disagreeing with him about the idea that we are "hiding" Alex. If you watch all the games...that's just not the case. Plenty of good QBs on winning teams out there (in years past, this year, etc) who don't need to throw 50x/game to win. Does that mean they were all "hidden?"

Agree with this...as Smith has been instrumental, or clutch, in several wins. They are hiding him in the sense of not putting all the weight of the game on his shoulders and letting him sink or swin, because that would be the opposite of good coaching. He isn't ready to assume the full Brady/Manning-like responsibility for the offense, but they are building in that direction.

Harbaugh will be able to tell by the end of the year, especially if they make the playoffs, whether Smith's upside is enough to win a super bowl. If JH decides he is they will extend him at least three years and we can all hope for the 6th and 7th rings.

Cosell is just another pundit who wants to wait until all the votes are counted before he admits he is wrong...not a terrible thing to do in his position.

I was struggling with a response, but you did it so much better.
  • lazy
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 5,687
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
How about some words from the guy that knows him best -- 'managing the game', 'lights out', 'clutch' -- Jim Harbaugh.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Experts who say Smith is good = Geniuses

Experts who say Smith is mediocre = Idiots
Originally posted by dtg_9er:

hiding him in the sense of not putting all the weight of the game on his shoulders

THIS. If anything, who is to dare say that Jim isn't hiding the porous OL protection ?

... and are our receivers wonderful options deep down the field anyway? Look at Ginn from last week... Terrible body control and couldn't even reach out for the ball? Look at VD vs the Hawks. He has a pestering CB underneath and looks over at the SS coming in and he what... quit on the ball right to him. How bout Delanie Walker who spins in a circle lost and confused as the deep ball was placed perfectly. Our guys just don't seem to be much on play-making unless a ball gets drilled into their chests.

Did we "hide" Alex in the 2nd half of the Eagles game? Did we "hide" Alex in the first half of the TB game when he passed the ball well to later open up the run? There's just no point chucking the ball up when we have a terrible pass protecting OL and average, possession receivers. We're playing efficient football and winning... but that's still not enough for some.
Originally posted by Archie:
I am sorry but after looking at qbr ratings on espn, I think they're accurate for the most part. Alex Smith is rated the 28th best qb and I think that's right. The 49ers are minimizing Smith's impact but let me say this Smith has played very well at times, but Alex Smith is a mediocre quarterback, a Trent Dilfer reincarnation. There is not one guy in the bottom 16 of those ratings that needs to be in the top ten of those ratings. I don't like Eli Manning as a player because I think he gets too much credit but then Eli will several good-great games in a row before having a bad ballgame and he will have those by his own admission. Alex is not that good but the rest of the team is and when Alex plays well it lifts the entire team to another level such as in the Eagles game. As long as the 49ers win that's the most important thing but objectively Smith is a sorry qb.


Disagree with you here as I believe Smith has had good games in his limited passing roll and they have won 5 of 6 games, should be 6-0 but for a defensive collapse in the Dallas game.

If you analyze the offense of the 9ers you would have to say the backfield is the strength of the team. OLine? Mediocre but improving fast. WRs? Injured and inconsistent, near top of the NFL in drops, and just not as effective as need be. QB, RBs and FBs? Playing well and with Smith getting better this part of the offense is ahead of the rest. TE is usually either listed with the line or WRs but I will put them with the line because they have been more consistent as blockers than as receivers.

Listing the quality of offensive players:

Very good: Gore, VD
Good: Smith, Walker, Hunter, Iupati, Edwards, Morgan (until injured), Miller
OK: Staley, Goodwin, Snyder, Crabtree, Davis (currently), Ginn (Lions game he was good)
Not up to par: Rachal, Norris
Yea, that whole "Keep him under wraps" "playing him to minimize his game" is utter BS.

If that was the case, then why in the hell would Harbaugh trust Smith on 4th down with a pass without even a timeout to make sure he's got it down.

BS!!!!!

That play proves that when Harbaugh needs Alex to make a play, he trusts him.

I believe the words coming out of Harbaugh were, "CLUTCH!!!!"

Given how Alex played in this one, sure he wasn't given the keys to do what he wanted. Instead, he gave those key to Gore and the OL. However, you can't deny that last TD play.

That's totally on Alex. He made the play. He was clutch. Can't change history and it's in the books as such.

Hey Cosell, go watch that last play and tell me what ya think.

Nah, he's a good analyst and most of what he says is spot on.

It's just that this "keeping Alex under wraps" is BS, IMO.
Originally posted by Archie:
I am sorry but after looking at qbr ratings on espn, I think they're accurate for the most part. Alex Smith is rated the 28th best qb and I think that's right. The 49ers are minimizing Smith's impact but let me say this Smith has played very well at times, but Alex Smith is a mediocre quarterback, a Trent Dilfer reincarnation. There is not one guy in the bottom 16 of those ratings that needs to be in the top ten of those ratings. I don't like Eli Manning as a player because I think he gets too much credit but then Eli will several good-great games in a row before having a bad ballgame and he will have those by his own admission. Alex is not that good but the rest of the team is and when Alex plays well it lifts the entire team to another level such as in the Eagles game. As long as the 49ers win that's the most important thing but objectively Smith is a sorry qb.

Ur kidding right how are they accurate?
Against eagles where he had us comeback from 20 points he had 28.7 qbr

Same week romo threw 4 int in second half to lose the game against TE lions

Stafford brought then back

Romo had a higher qbr for the week

They are so many more examples the qbr is bs
People are just looking for a way to spice up the WZ. That's all.
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Originally posted by susweel:
Greg Cosell says that we are trying to hide Alex Smith. Minimize his impact on the game.


Q: And that's the engine of the team, because they're really limiting Alex Smith's throws.

COSELL: Here's what they're doing with Alex Smith, and he's a great guy, so none of this is ever personal, but they're playing the games to minimize his impact on the game. And they're able to win games doing that, so more power to Harbaugh and the coaching staff. They're doing absolutely the right thing. I'm reading a lot of people talk about now Alex Smith is proving….Look. This is what they're doing. They're trying to hide him. They're trying to minimize his impact on the game. And that's great. Do you know what that's called? Coaching.

That's true to a certain extent. Although I disagree with the idea that we are "hiding" him. If we were "hiding him" he wouldn't have 3 - 4th quarter comebacks THIS year. That argument made sense after the first couple games...but I'm sorry...you don't go 5-1 because you're "hiding" your QB.

I DO agree though that Alex isn't the focus of the offense. We don't need him to do much but that's just the way the chips fall. The kid has 8 TD and 2 INT nearly half way through the season. If that isn't "proving" something (compared to years past) I don't know what is. Seems like unless you're throwing for 300+ yards every game win or lose...you're being "hidden."

Again...not saying Cosell is an idiot or anything...just disagreeing with him about the idea that we are "hiding" Alex. If you watch all the games...that's just not the case. Plenty of good QBs on winning teams out there (in years past, this year, etc) who don't need to throw 50x/game to win. Does that mean they were all "hidden?"

I myself agree with Susweel and Cossel-they are in a way hiding Alex. While it wasn't his fault, they want to prevent exposing him unecessarily to what happend in the first series (which was not his fault) and the second half int., this does two things, keep the niners in the game and keep his confidence high. Any QB can get rattled, some more than others though-which is Alex. He is not like Manning, Brees or Brady where he can have several bad games but shake it off. Basically when Cossel says he is hiding Alex- JH is not exposing him to minimize getting hit and making. JH is in his ear all the time, but doing it in a way doesn't across as (I don't trust you), but rather look out for this and etc. On that comeback btw, it was great, but credit goes to the running game though Alex finished it off, but in the previous drives he couldn't get it done in the 2nd half, he was floating balls, but that is okay because it setup the run as the lions couldn't take a chance that a pass might connect for a big one.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by ninertico:
Yea, that whole "Keep him under wraps" "playing him to minimize his game" is utter BS.

If that was the case, then why in the hell would Harbaugh trust Smith on 4th down with a pass without even a timeout to make sure he's got it down.

BS!!!!!

That play proves that when Harbaugh needs Alex to make a play, he trusts him.

I believe the words coming out of Harbaugh were, "CLUTCH!!!!"

Given how Alex played in this one, sure he wasn't given the keys to do what he wanted. Instead, he gave those key to Gore and the OL. However, you can't deny that last TD play.

That's totally on Alex. He made the play. He was clutch. Can't change history and it's in the books as such.

Hey Cosell, go watch that last play and tell me what ya think.

Nah, he's a good analyst and most of what he says is spot on.

It's just that this "keeping Alex under wraps" is BS, IMO.


Dang Tico so much anger. Take it easy bro we are 5-1
Originally posted by susweel:
Dang Tico so much anger. Take it easy bro we are 5-1

That's what you live for... just admit it.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by susweel:
Dang Tico so much anger. Take it easy bro we are 5-1

That's what you live for... just admit it.

nice smiley but no thats not what I live for.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone