Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 1,000 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
"Accuracy" is a two-way street. The QB has to deliver a catchable ball in a place where the receiver can catch it. (stating the obvious) However, situations and circumstances move the blame around when a ball is not caught. Certainly when the QB does not put the ball in a catchable location he is guilty of being inaccurate on that throw. However, when a receiver lets a ball go through his extended hands, it is not the QB's fault. Receivers have to make plays on the ball.

One example; in the Green Bay game last Sunday, Aaron Rodgers underthrew a WIDE OPEN Jordy Nelson. Nelson had three steps on the defender with nothing but green between himself and the goal line. Did the pass fall incomplete? No. Nelson slowed down, waited to catch the ball, then juked the safety coming across the field and out ran everyone for an 87 yard TD completion. That is an example of what a good WR should do to not only help his QB but help his team as well. It is one big part of why Rodgers is having an MVP season - he has an entire group of receivers that are making plays on the ball like that. If Nelson had not been looking back and made the catch, Rodgers numbers would have been very mediocre 220 yards. Instead, he has another bonus day and more votes for MVP.

At the end of the day, I am more worried about the 49er receiving corp than about Alex Smith. Receivers (along with WR injuries) are the weak link on this team right now.
Tom Brady is the only QB on that list id rather have than Alex Smith
Originally posted by dj43:
"Accuracy" is a two-way street. The QB has to deliver a catchable ball in a place where the receiver can catch it. (stating the obvious) However, situations and circumstances move the blame around when a ball is not caught. Certainly when the QB does not put the ball in a catchable location he is guilty of being inaccurate on that throw. However, when a receiver lets a ball go through his extended hands, it is not the QB's fault. Receivers have to make plays on the ball.



I'll give you my example for now. First, note that I will not count this as a drop... but I could.. but I won't. Early in the Lions game, Alex threw a (roughly) 7 yard curl-type of route to Ginn towards the sideline. The ball glanced off of both fingers/finger-tips/upper palms of Ginn. I expect better vertical from Ginn, and I don't think he went up at the ideal moment, but whatever... All it takes is for Ginn to cut his route off half a yard short to see such a high pass.

Again, not gonna count it as a drop... but it doesn't take much for a pass to be "high" just like that one.
I respect the loyalty. How many do you think Harbaugh would prefer?
Originally posted by davidboutte:
Alex Smith is our QB. I support him 100%. But after the 48-3 win over Tampa, stories all over were calling him a top 10 even a top 5 QB. He is not making mistakes like he has in the past but I am realistic. He isn't our QB of the future and hopefully we all realize that. This is the best team and best coach he has ever had. i love being 5-1 but was trent Dilfer a top 10 QB when he managed Baltimore and that defense to a Superbowl? Dont forget they cut Dilfer that off-season.

I'm not posting this to deis-respect Alex Smith. This is his finest season and he will still improve. I hope he someday will be a top 10 or even 5 QB, but I doubt it. Here is a list of QB's better right now including 2 Rookies IMO

Rogers
Brady
Rivers
Brees
Ryan
Manning, Eli, Peyton doesn't count right now
Vick
Fitzpatrick
Cutler
Stafford
Newton
Dalton
Hasslebeck
Freeman

I would rather have our defense and any of those QB's coached by Harbaugh either short or longterm over Alex Smith. Your thoughts?


Cutler, Dalton, ...um Freeman, Newton and Ryan all need to NOT be on this list. Statistically speaking Alex is not a top 10 QB this I agree with...but as of RIGHT NOW I like going with the QB that gets us the W...stats are meaningless without the win
FINALLY. An Alex Smith thread...
cocaine farts smell really bad
Alex Smith is 4-0 this year against the QBs on that list
Originally posted by valrod33:
Tom Brady is the only QB on that list id rather have than Alex Smith

I'd go Rodgers but he didn't mention him...who is this Rogers character lol In all honesty every qb plays in different systems and under different circumstances, Rodgers and Brady and Stafford throw 30-50 times EVERY GAME they don't have a running game on every given sunday so they throw it, Ryan and Dalton etc rely on the running game to open up the passing game and so forth. What Rodgers is doing in Green Bay might not happen if he was in a 49er jersey and vise versa so it's hard to judge because every situation is different ?
Shocking........
Originally posted by dj43:

At the end of the day, I am more worried about the 49er receiving corp than about Alex Smith. Receivers (along with WR injuries) are the weak link on this team right now.

I agree completely but for Edwards, if he can stay healthy.

Bogan--nonentity so far

Crabtree--coming along, needs to develop better chemistry with Smith and I think he will

Edwards--best of the group when healthy, fights for the ball

Ginn--better last week with the runs, still not reliable enough down field

Morgan--out for year

Swain--nonentity so far

Williams--nonentity so far

Walker--Mr. Versatility, and will be needed, too many drops

Will the young guys kick in? Or are they getting few touches for a reason? Most likely the latter.

Edit: Compare WRs these QBs work with and see if SF is toward the bottom of your list.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 19, 2011 at 9:23 AM ]
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by Thrash88:
Originally posted by valrod33:
Tom Brady is the only QB on that list id rather have than Alex Smith

I'd go Rodgers but he didn't mention him...who is this Rogers character lol In all honesty every qb plays in different systems and under different circumstances, Rodgers and Brady and Stafford throw 30-50 times EVERY GAME they don't have a running game on every given sunday so they throw it, Ryan and Dalton etc rely on the running game to open up the passing game and so forth. What Rodgers is doing in Green Bay might not happen if he was in a 49er jersey and vise versa so it's hard to judge because every situation is different ?

Rodgers is having a great year but if you watch any of the Green Bay games it is clear that his receivers are helping him a lot. Their adjustments to the ball are terrific and they drop VERY few balls that they can touch. Based on what I have seen from the receiving corp of both teams this year, Rodgers would not be anywhere close to the numbers he has so far if he were playing for the 49ers with the receiving corp of the past 5 weeks. Not even close.
Originally posted by MertonHanksneck:
Originally posted by davidboutte:
Alex Smith is our QB. I support him 100%. But after the 48-3 win over Tampa, stories all over were calling him a top 10 even a top 5 QB. He is not making mistakes like he has in the past but I am realistic. He isn't our QB of the future and hopefully we all realize that. This is the best team and best coach he has ever had. i love being 5-1 but was trent Dilfer a top 10 QB when he managed Baltimore and that defense to a Superbowl? Dont forget they cut Dilfer that off-season.

I'm not posting this to deis-respect Alex Smith. This is his finest season and he will still improve. I hope he someday will be a top 10 or even 5 QB, but I doubt it. Here is a list of QB's better right now including 2 Rookies IMO

Rogers
Brady
Rivers
Brees
Ryan
Manning, Eli, Peyton doesn't count right now
Vick
Fitzpatrick
Cutler
Stafford
Newton
Dalton
Hasslebeck
Freeman

I would rather have our defense and any of those QB's coached by Harbaugh either short or longterm over Alex Smith. Your thoughts?


Cutler, Dalton, ...um Freeman, Newton and Ryan all need to NOT be on this list. Statistically speaking Alex is not a top 10 QB this I agree with...but as of RIGHT NOW I like going with the QB that gets us the W...stats are meaningless without the win

Stafford is only on that list because of Calvin Johnson. What happens if you put Alex on a team like GB and NE where they actually give the QB time to throw and have a healthy receiving corps. Alex has had to deal with the growing pains of our OL and not having his starting WRs (one missing camp is huge too). I'm not trying to make excuses but just saying that I'm surprised that he's even healthy and most of all able to win games in such dire straits.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by dj43:
"Accuracy" is a two-way street. The QB has to deliver a catchable ball in a place where the receiver can catch it. (stating the obvious) However, situations and circumstances move the blame around when a ball is not caught. Certainly when the QB does not put the ball in a catchable location he is guilty of being inaccurate on that throw. However, when a receiver lets a ball go through his extended hands, it is not the QB's fault. Receivers have to make plays on the ball.


I'll give you my example for now. First, note that I will not count this as a drop... but I could.. but I won't. Early in the Lions game, Alex threw a (roughly) 7 yard curl-type of route to Ginn towards the sideline. The ball glanced off of both fingers/finger-tips/upper palms of Ginn. I expect better vertical from Ginn, and I don't think he went up at the ideal moment, but whatever... All it takes is for Ginn to cut his route off half a yard short to see such a high pass.

Again, not gonna count it as a drop... but it doesn't take much for a pass to be "high" just like that one.
This has been Ginn's problem his entire career - he does not adjust well to the ball. With a healthy Edwards and Morgan, Ginn isn't on the field for an offensive snap. He is the #4 WR.
Originally posted by dj43:
"Accuracy" is a two-way street. The QB has to deliver a catchable ball in a place where the receiver can catch it. (stating the obvious) However, situations and circumstances move the blame around when a ball is not caught. Certainly when the QB does not put the ball in a catchable location he is guilty of being inaccurate on that throw. However, when a receiver lets a ball go through his extended hands, it is not the QB's fault. Receivers have to make plays on the ball.

One example; in the Green Bay game last Sunday, Aaron Rodgers underthrew a WIDE OPEN Jordy Nelson. Nelson had three steps on the defender with nothing but green between himself and the goal line. Did the pass fall incomplete? No. Nelson slowed down, waited to catch the ball, then juked the safety coming across the field and out ran everyone for an 87 yard TD completion. That is an example of what a good WR should do to not only help his QB but help his team as well. It is one big part of why Rodgers is having an MVP season - he has an entire group of receivers that are making plays on the ball like that. If Nelson had not been looking back and made the catch, Rodgers numbers would have been very mediocre 220 yards. Instead, he has another bonus day and more votes for MVP.

At the end of the day, I am more worried about the 49er receiving corp than about Alex Smith. Receivers (along with WR injuries) are the weak link on this team right now.

That example is a trivial context. MOST NFL receivers, including ours, make that type of adjustment as the receiver is so open that he doesn't need to worry about slowing down for the catch.

One aspect Alex has not been able to show that he is even marginally accurate is when he throws slightly off balance. He throws a terrible ball on the shortest routes when he is off balance.

Of balance: I don't include throwing while running being off balance as he is allowed to use the momentum of his movement to put strength into the throw. I mean when he's doing something Brady does all the time which is throw while taking a side step or like Rodgers who can make a throw while flat-footed due to a tight pocket. Alex has shown terrible accuracy that most QB's don't in these situations.

And our WR's do adjust well on the ball. Even GB receivers drop or misjudge balls here and there. Alex, for the most part, has been solid on his throws but has been far less than stellar when making throws that don't allow him to step into the throw. He has stepped into throws and immediately been hit but he still was able to step into it. It's when he doesn't get to step into it is when even a 5 yard throw becomes a terrible throw.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone