Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 923 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
There should be a thread for all the whining about our starting QB. Face it he's the starter and Harbaugh knows better than you guys. 80sbaby 8to80 sus go make a thread on how you hate Alex and won't ever say anything good about him. All this negativity is pointless because only Harbaugh and his staff decides who are QB is.

I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.

He also blamed a miscommunication for the INT
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
There should be a thread for all the whining about our starting QB. Face it he's the starter and Harbaugh knows better than you guys. 80sbaby 8to80 sus go make a thread on how you hate Alex and won't ever say anything good about him. All this negativity is pointless because only Harbaugh and his staff decides who are QB is.

I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.

He also blamed a miscommunication for the INT

Link?
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by gamechanger:
There should be a thread for all the whining about our starting QB. Face it he's the starter and Harbaugh knows better than you guys. 80sbaby 8to80 sus go make a thread on how you hate Alex and won't ever say anything good about him. All this negativity is pointless because only Harbaugh and his staff decides who are QB is.

I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.

He also blamed a miscommunication for the INT

Link?

It's from one of the news stories on the home page.
Originally posted by backontop:
It's from one of the news stories on the home page.

It was during his post-game press conference. From the comment, I knew that Crabs was supposed to run a post but instead ran an in. The blame for the play does go on Crabs for not running the correct route, but also on Smith for not seeing that Crabs was wide open in the middle of the field so there was no need to continue the route. I think that both players are at fault, but Crabtree moreso because he never puts in the work in the offseason that would help Smith instinctively know exactly where crabs would cut that route off.
He looks different this year, I like what I see
His constant high throws to Crabtree are inexcusable IMO, but there definitely is something different about him this year. He looks more poised...plus, he is playing smart football which is definitely helping us win games.

I like it, but he and Tree better be working NON STOP during the bye week.
his completion % is dropping as the year goes on but that is going to happen given that we are opening up the offense a bit more.

he is still inconsistent on a throw-to-throw basis. overall he has been good this year but if he wants to be great he can't miss some of these throws as high as he does. i know he is getting pressured at times but he needs to stand and deliver.... olmos style!
Just watched the first half again (and the 2nd earlier this evening) and am mystified as to all these high throws people are seeing. There were three passes I saw that were high, one to Ginn, and two to Crabtree--the Int and one other incomplete pass in the middle of the field. The rest of his passes were fine--might have missed one other high pass but didn't see it in the replay...just remembered wrong from Sunday I guess.

Anyway, Smith moved really well in the pocket and threw under duress numerous times with very few miscues. Hit while throwing a number of times and he mentioned in one of his post game interviews that he was making an effort to get rid of the ball rather than taking a sack--vast improvement though it impacts his QBR.

Boy do I like the NFLN game replays. Quick way to see every play. Just can't believe how good the 9er defense played. Running to the ball all game long and very sound tackling...great tackling!

Edit: On the TD to Walker to win the game, Crabtree was open but the ball was already out of Smith's hand when Crabtree looks back. So, yes he might have caught a ball lofted over the D, but the quick slant was there...don't see how any fair minded person would say he made an incorrect decision.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 19, 2011 at 12:18 AM ]
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.

i don't think we're are allowed to criticize smith on his high throws now, even if harbaugh does it.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.

i don't think we're are allowed to criticize smith on his high throws now, even if harbaugh does it.

he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
he had some high balls from messed up mechanics but at the same time I think people are blowing it out of proportion. There were 6 or 7 very catchable balls dropped too, 1 a TD. He is just like a pitcher, sometimes you lose your command a bit because your mechanics are off. But for the most part they've been very good and he's been accurate so I think he'll work on it over the bye and be okay.

Good point, and I can see that I over reacted until I rewatched the game.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.

i don't think we're are allowed to criticize smith on his high throws now, even if harbaugh does it.


Somewhat surprised by this over reaction Donnie. Not criticizing reasonable comments about an overthrown pass, just the posts indicating a pattern in the game of these passes. I was unhappy with the two overthrown passes down the middle, one intercepted the other not, but that was it. I rewatched the game and only saw these two and a sideline pass to Ginn that was through his hands but could have been lower. All other incompletions were either thrown away or low and away from the defender where it could not be picked off.

Believe me, I was surprised that my initial reaction of a bad game on Smith's part was incorrect. He actually played well under much pressure. The stat line may have influenced me too much as Smith stated after the game that he made an effort to eliminate sacks by throwing the ball away.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 19, 2011 at 8:02 AM ]
Delanie should have had that touchdown catch. Alex has my support this year, but to have it next year he will have to win a playoff game. I think Harbaugh can coach up lots of QBs with similar success. Not to say he is not doing well, I'm rollin with Smith but I'm not gonna stroke the shaft and tweek the balls just yet.
Originally posted by Youngone:
Delanie should have had that touchdown catch. Alex has my support this year, but to have it next year he will have to win a playoff game. I think Harbaugh can coach up lots of QBs with similar success. Not to say he is not doing well, I'm rollin with Smith but I'm not gonna stroke the shaft and tweek the balls just yet.

Just kiss the tip at least. Show a little love.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Good point, and I can see that I over reacted until I rewatched the game.


Somewhat surprised by this over reaction Donnie. Not criticizing reasonable comments about an overthrown pass, just the posts indicating a pattern in the game of these passes. I was unhappy with the two overthrown passes down the middle, one intercepted the other not, but that was it. I rewatched the game and only saw these two and a sideline pass to Ginn that was through his hands but could have been lower. All other incompletions were either thrown away or low and away from the defender where it could not be picked off.

Believe me, I was surprised that my initial reaction of a bad game on Smith's part was incorrect. He actually played well under much pressure. The stat line may have influenced me too much as Smith stated after the game that he made an effort to eliminate sacks by throwing the ball away.

Wow, this... exactly this. When watching live, I was also expressing unhappiness over Alex's throws... but going back over the game time and again, I see that live action can really distort perceptions.

Just finished the Bucs game on drops. (only 1) ... Plan to update after the Lions game I watch again today or tomorrow.
Alex Smith is our QB. I support him 100%. But after the 48-3 win over Tampa, stories all over were calling him a top 10 even a top 5 QB. He is not making mistakes like he has in the past but I am realistic. He isn't our QB of the future and hopefully we all realize that. This is the best team and best coach he has ever had. i love being 5-1 but was trent Dilfer a top 10 QB when he managed Baltimore and that defense to a Superbowl? Dont forget they cut Dilfer that off-season.

I'm not posting this to deis-respect Alex Smith. This is his finest season and he will still improve. I hope he someday will be a top 10 or even 5 QB, but I doubt it. Here is a list of QB's better right now including 2 Rookies IMO

Rogers
Brady
Rivers
Brees
Ryan
Manning, Eli, Peyton doesn't count right now
Vick
Fitzpatrick
Cutler
Stafford
Newton
Dalton
Hasslebeck
Freeman

I would rather have our defense and any of those QB's coached by Harbaugh either short or longterm over Alex Smith. Your thoughts?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone