49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 739 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Apone:
Oh the irony.

The hell? Show me where I misinterpreted something.

You guys are arguing over the words within context. The irony is you are also arguing over Smith's bad play within the context of the opposition. In other words, if he struggled, and pulled out a winning TD it's OK against Lions' defense in a hostile dome. But it's not OK if he does the same thing against the Browns.
So I am in the process of re watching the game. In the first half all but one off alex's passes are spot on. That onw pass was to Ginn and Ginn needed to raise his arms to catch it, but he didn't have to jump. Everything else was aces and perfectly lead where appropriate. 2 incomplete passes and both were on the WR IMO. I know the 2nd half won't be as good.
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Apone:
Oh the irony.

The hell? Show me where I misinterpreted something.

Dude. Niners are 5-1. Take a deep breath and just enjoy it for a moment.

*woosahhh*

Im calm. Have been the whole time. Been enjoying it the whole time too. Have had season tickets for 18 years man. Im stoked for how the season has gone. Its been a long time since I have had this feeling about one of our teams. I just dont consider Alex's play during week 6 (by itself, not counting other games), playing fine. Thats the only thing I have been trying to say.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
WTF are you ranting about bro? Yes I know Aaron Rodgers has bad games. Everyone does. I wasnt talking about expectations of a quarterback. I was talking about expectations of what is considered "playing fine" like the dude said Alex did. I dont care if Aaron Rodgers, Alex Smith, Peyton Manning or Joe Montana himself was the quarterback. What we saw in Detroit was a bad game. And when the dude said Alex "played fine," I was saying how his expectations are low if he considers THAT "playing fine."

Jesus bro. Step your reading comprehension game up. I have no clue how you could have possibly taken away what you did from what I wrote.

My bad, damn.

Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i definitely think that sometimes it is on crabtree. but to say it's 100% crabtree's fault is absurd. I just don't understand why Alex has this problem, i really hope Harbaugh can work his magic and come up with a solution

don't think anyone's saying 100% ...

well go back and check out all of sandiego's responses lol it's as though alex has no accountability

Read it again... and I have to say that you draw that conclusion all on your own, and with little to support coming to it.

LOL ok then explain to me how he's being reasonable. i admit that crabtree can be at fault for some of the routes but not all. he just makes excuses for smith on every example. i pointed out how harbaugh was critical of smith on a pass and he never addressed it.
He was a huge part of winning the game with one stinking option at wr. Get over it.
HATERS GONNA HATE!

Originally posted by Jakemall:
So I am in the process of re watching the game. In the first half all but one off alex's passes are spot on. That onw pass was to Ginn and Ginn needed to raise his arms to catch it, but he didn't have to jump. Everything else was aces and perfectly lead where appropriate. 2 incomplete passes and both were on the WR IMO. I know the 2nd half won't be as good.

Btw there were 15 passes in the first half. One bad throw.
Was able to watch the 2nd half on NFLN and counted two overthrown balls, both to Crabtree, that could have been a matter of Crabtree being redirected by the D. Smith was hit on two incompletions as he was throwing, one causing one of the high throws.

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

I was critical of Smith because it wasn't his best game by far but the Detroit D, drops, routes...too many variables to be overly critical. That said, I hope the rest of his games are better. Those saying his play is fine get a pass from me as he won the game when he had the chance...clutch!
2nd have the edited version of the replay actually edited out some of the game...some one else will have to pick up.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Was able to watch the 2nd half on NFLN and counted two overthrown balls, both to Crabtree, that could have been a matter of Crabtree being redirected by the D. Smith was hit on two incompletions as he was throwing, one causing one of the high throws.

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

I was critical of Smith because it wasn't his best game by far but the Detroit D, drops, routes...too many variables to be overly critical. That said, I hope the rest of his games are better. Those saying his play is fine get a pass from me as he won the game when he had the chance...clutch!

That seems reasonable.
I counted 1 bad pass so far in the 2 half, up to the Delanie Walker drop wide open in the left side of the endzone. I couldn't get past that one
There should be a thread for all the whining about our starting QB. Face it he's the starter and Harbaugh knows better than you guys. 80sbaby 8to80 sus go make a thread on how you hate Alex and won't ever say anything good about him. All this negativity is pointless because only Harbaugh and his staff decides who are QB is.
[ Edited by gamechanger on Oct 18, 2011 at 9:07 PM ]
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
I counted 1 bad pass so far in the 2 half, up to the Delanie Walker drop wide open in the left side of the endzone. I couldn't get past that one

Difficult to watch over again but enjoyed hearing, again, that DW needs to turn his hands around. Seems he has done that before. I would like to see him work hard on those little technical aspects of the game--hand placement, ball security, etc. because he is a really good player and may become great. He's 27 years old, still young enough to improve.

Note: all born in 1984--Alex Smith, Delanie Walker, Vernon Davis, Ahmad Brooks, Joe Staley, Blake Costanzo, Parys Haralson, Dashon Goldson, Tavares Gooden, and Will Tukuafu. Nice group of just maturing guys!
Originally posted by gamechanger:
There should be a thread for all the whining about our starting QB. Face it he's the starter and Harbaugh knows better than you guys. 80sbaby 8to80 sus go make a thread on how you hate Alex and won't ever say anything good about him. All this negativity is pointless because only Harbaugh and his staff decides who are QB is.

I have been very complimentary of Alex this season. He has far exceeded expectations. Its just that I can make comments both ways. Some have a hard time doing that.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

So the fact that some are defending Smith because we don't know how the route should have been run seems reasonable. To then bring up a throw in another game that Harbaugh said could have been better...seems like someone trying to be negative for the sake of negativity.

Alex himself blamed his mechanics on his high throws.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone