Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 795 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Maybe he is already finished in the WRONG SPOT and the play calls for Alex to throw to a SPOT!.....

so i guess harbaugh is wrong as well..got it

But still the question lingers: Why does this problem seem to primarily center on Crabtree? I am not saying it is all on Crabtree. I like Crabtree. But since Alex does not seem to have the same problem consistently with any other receiver it has to be more than just Alex. But I agree with an earlier post you made: they have to get it ironed out. My guess is that with Harbaugh in charge they will.

i definitely think that sometimes it is on crabtree. but to say it's 100% crabtree's fault is absurd. I just don't understand why Alex has this problem, i really hope Harbaugh can work his magic and come up with a solution
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
It's not like A. Smith struggled against a 1-5 team last Sunday. Pretty sure coming into Sunday everyone realized the Lions have one hella defense, more specifically the defensive line. We expected the offense and Smith will struggled. Now if he struggled like he did against the Browns...now that's something to worry about. Regression

The Browns are going to get snuffed out. We might be favored by 10 points.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i definitely think that sometimes it is on crabtree. but to say it's 100% crabtree's fault is absurd. I just don't understand why Alex has this problem, i really hope Harbaugh can work his magic and come up with a solution

don't think anyone's saying 100% ...
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i definitely think that sometimes it is on crabtree. but to say it's 100% crabtree's fault is absurd. I just don't understand why Alex has this problem, i really hope Harbaugh can work his magic and come up with a solution

don't think anyone's saying 100% ...

well go back and check out all of sandiego's responses lol it's as though alex has no accountability
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
i definitely think that sometimes it is on crabtree. but to say it's 100% crabtree's fault is absurd. I just don't understand why Alex has this problem, i really hope Harbaugh can work his magic and come up with a solution

don't think anyone's saying 100% ...

well go back and check out all of sandiego's responses lol it's as though alex has no accountability

Read it again... and I have to say that you draw that conclusion all on your own, and with little to support coming to it.
  • Apone
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,739
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
If you think that throwing for 120 yards, with barely a 50% completion percentage, with two turnovers and one touchdown is "fine," then your expectations of a good QB performance is REALLY low.

Originally posted by Apone:
It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game.

Considering he has done that three times in 6 years, I agree with you. But there isnt a poster on this board who expects him to do that every time, so I dont even know the point of bringing that up.

Originally posted by Apone:
He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

Agreed.

Instead of doing things like focusing on one word, maybe try reading the whole sentence next time and consider the other points made. That would really help instead of taking it way out of context and assuming things like you know what my expectations of a good QB are. And Yes, some people have outlandish and crazy expectations of Smith, and some have gone as far as even stating they would rather see the guy get hurt than wear a 49er jersey. He is that divisive.
[ Edited by Apone on Oct 18, 2011 at 7:26 PM ]
Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Apone:
Smith played fine.

If you think that throwing for 120 yards, with barely a 50% completion percentage, with two turnovers and one touchdown is "fine," then your expectations of a good QB performance is REALLY low.

Originally posted by Apone:
It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game.

Considering he has done that three times in 6 years, I agree with you. But there isnt a poster on this board who expects him to do that every time, so I dont even know the point of bringing that up.

Originally posted by Apone:
He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

Agreed.

Aaron Rodgers had a couple games like this last year, I think he's a good quarterback. Are my expectations too low?

QBs who have a bad game are not worth a damn I'm guessing? Or maybe you're trying to say only Alex Smith should have to be perfect all the time because he was a number 1 pick and its been 7 years yada yada yada...

He's had a high completion percentage in all games but one this year, give the guy a break. He aint Joe Montana but some here would have you think Ken Dorsey is our QB, or Tim Rattay. Alex Smith is a well above average starting QB in the NFL, get over it, not all good QBs have to throw for 400 yards a game.

WTF are you ranting about bro? Yes I know Aaron Rodgers has bad games. Everyone does. I wasnt talking about expectations of a quarterback. I was talking about expectations of what is considered "playing fine" like the dude said Alex did. I dont care if Aaron Rodgers, Alex Smith, Peyton Manning or Joe Montana himself was the quarterback. What we saw in Detroit was a bad game. And when the dude said Alex "played fine," I was saying how his expectations are low if he considers THAT "playing fine."

Jesus bro. Step your reading comprehension game up. I have no clue how you could have possibly taken away what you did from what I wrote.
I looked at that INT in the Lions game again more closely. The pass rush affected that whole sequence. Smith had to side step Goodwin being pushed back by #99, this affected the timing, because the window to throw to Crabtree was closing fast. He had to throw the ball quick before the safety gets there. In doing so he didn't step into the throw. Thus the ball sailed. If he had took his time to step into the throw, it would have been accurately thrown to Crabtree but there's a very good chance either Crabtree would get blow up by the safety on top or picked off by the same.

Watch the play again and you will appreciate what NFL qb goes through on every pass play and the pressure to make a good decision within a tick tock.

Edit : That wasn't a safety, it was a LB dropping back in coverage.
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 18, 2011 at 7:36 PM ]
  • Apone
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,739
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
WTF are you ranting about bro? Yes I know Aaron Rodgers has bad games. Everyone does. I wasnt talking about expectations of a quarterback. I was talking about expectations of what is considered "playing fine" like the dude said Alex did. I dont care if Aaron Rodgers, Alex Smith, Peyton Manning or Joe Montana himself was the quarterback. What we saw in Detroit was a bad game. And when the dude said Alex "played fine," I was saying how his expectations are low if he considers THAT "playing fine."

Jesus bro. Step your reading comprehension game up. I have no clue how you could have possibly taken away what you did from what I wrote.

Oh the irony.
Originally posted by Apone:
Oh the irony.


LOL!
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,105
I thought "WINNING" would cure all the hate?
Originally posted by Apone:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
If you think that throwing for 120 yards, with barely a 50% completion percentage, with two turnovers and one touchdown is "fine," then your expectations of a good QB performance is REALLY low.

Originally posted by Apone:
It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110 QB rating every game.

Considering he has done that three times in 6 years, I agree with you. But there isnt a poster on this board who expects him to do that every time, so I dont even know the point of bringing that up.

Originally posted by Apone:
He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

Agreed.

Instead of focusing on one word, maybe try reading the whole sentence next time and consider the other points made. That would really help instead of taking it way out of context and assuming things like you know what my expectations of a good QB are.

Here is the whole sentence: Alex played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league.

So let me get this straight. As long as a quarterback is playing in a loud stadium against a very good defense, having a 50% completion percentage for 120 yards, with one touchdown and two turnovers is considered "playing fine?" Its not. Period. It would be like the San Francisco Giants playing against Phillies in Philadelphia.....a game where the crowd is jacked up......Roy Halladay is on the mound.....we get 2 hits but we manage to win the game 1-0....and then saying our offense "played fine." See how silly that sounds?

And how does eliminating the rest of your sentence do anything to the context? I have the same opinion with it, or without it.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Maybe he is already finished in the WRONG SPOT and the play calls for Alex to throw to a SPOT!.....

so i guess harbaugh is wrong as well..got it

But still the question lingers: Why does this problem seem to primarily center on Crabtree? I am not saying it is all on Crabtree. I like Crabtree. But since Alex does not seem to have the same problem consistently with any other receiver it has to be more than just Alex. But I agree with an earlier post you made: they have to get it ironed out. My guess is that with Harbaugh in charge they will.

It is just my observation but when I look at Crabtree's routes and compare them to Morgan, it appears as though Crabtree runs certain routes flatter than did Morgan. While Morgan would be angling more upfield, Crabtree tends to run the same or similar routes a bit flatter across the field. If this is the case, it might explain why some of Smith's passes are high. However, Smith was high with more throws against the Lions than anyone else this season.
Originally posted by Apone:
Oh the irony.

The hell? Show me where I misinterpreted something.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Apone:
Oh the irony.

The hell? Show me where I misinterpreted something.

Dude. Niners are 5-1. Take a deep breath and just enjoy it for a moment.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone