Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 1,230 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by hateroids84:
Alex did not play well against the Lions Sunday, but he was clutch. He is doing enough for us to win, so can't hate on him.

Of course he didn't play well but he didn't play poorly like some people on this board are saying. Yes, he did what it took to win with the throw to Walker at the end. He could have done more than that if Crabs got his feet in for the TD or Walker would have caught the TD pass instead of dropping it.

Smith struggled along with the team. Not sure why he is singled out suddenly. Not like he was singled out as bad the last 6 years


My criticism is a result of knowing that Smith is creating a new image this year that may be very important to the team. Do not want to see him struggle, but am aware that he will from time to time. He made plays when he needed to do so and considering the DLine of Detroit all is good.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
My criticism is a result of knowing that Smith is creating a new image this year that may be very important to the team. Do not want to see him struggle, but am aware that he will from time to time. He made plays when he needed to do so and considering the DLine of Detroit all is good.

All QBs struggle from time to time. I remember the crap games Joe Montana and Steve Young had. Heck, remember the horrible season P. Manning had a few years ago? We can go on and on about QBs, good, great, and average, having really bad or blah games.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

Not bizarre when you consider that just maybe the WR running routes more shallow than they should be can result in what appears to be high passes.

Don't get me wrong, I am not fully excusing or blaming anyone. Just saying, it's something to think about.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

I have seen it suggested in the past that Crabtree might, at times, not be where he is suppose to be. I can't say if that is true or not but it does seem weird that this problem is primarily associated with one receiver and does seem to suggest that Smith might not be the only one at fault here.
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

I have seen it suggested in the past that Crabtree might, at times, not be where he is suppose to be. I can't say if that is true or not but it does seem weird that this problem is primarily associated with one receiver and does seem to suggest that Smith might not be the only one at fault here.

i agree that it's possible crabtree might not be in the right spot, but more times than not it just seems like a complete overthrow. i think the tv commentators have touched on him air mailing his passes quite a bit
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

I have seen it suggested in the past that Crabtree might, at times, not be where he is suppose to be. I can't say if that is true or not but it does seem weird that this problem is primarily associated with one receiver and does seem to suggest that Smith might not be the only one at fault here.

That is a keen observation. It just doesn't make sense for him to generally have his throws in the right place to other receivers. As a QB, if you don't know where the WR is going, it's VERY difficult to put the ball where it needs to be.
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Not bizarre when you consider that just maybe the WR running routes more shallow than they should be can result in what appears to be high passes.

Don't get me wrong, I am not fully excusing or blaming anyone. Just saying, it's something to think about.

I said this during the Lions game day thread. All of Smith's high throws against the Lions seemed to be when he threw to Crabs.

Crabs needs to come to camp and play during the preason. How many days of practice has Crabs had? I question Crabs work ethic even if I see the team say all the right things about him.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

I have seen it suggested in the past that Crabtree might, at times, not be where he is suppose to be. I can't say if that is true or not but it does seem weird that this problem is primarily associated with one receiver and does seem to suggest that Smith might not be the only one at fault here.

i agree that it's possible crabtree might not be in the right spot, but more times than not it just seems like a complete overthrow. i think the tv commentators have touched on him air mailing his passes quite a bit


Crabtree doesn't practice EVER. So why wouldn't his be the most inaccurate throws. He doesn't probably even know where to be on the field.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

I have seen it suggested in the past that Crabtree might, at times, not be where he is suppose to be. I can't say if that is true or not but it does seem weird that this problem is primarily associated with one receiver and does seem to suggest that Smith might not be the only one at fault here.

i agree that it's possible crabtree might not be in the right spot, but more times than not it just seems like a complete overthrow. i think the tv commentators have touched on him air mailing his passes quite a bit


Crabtree doesn't practice EVER. So why wouldn't his be the most inaccurate throws. He doesn't probably even know where to be on the field.

you guys keep harping on crabtree not running the correct routes...but what i'm talking about is that 90% of the time his route is already finished and he's at the sideline waiting for a pass and smith air mails it.

jim harbaugh also mentioned after the bucs game that crabtree made a great leaping catch on that slant, that alex needed to have better accuracy. so it's clearly not all on crabtree.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.

I have seen it suggested in the past that Crabtree might, at times, not be where he is suppose to be. I can't say if that is true or not but it does seem weird that this problem is primarily associated with one receiver and does seem to suggest that Smith might not be the only one at fault here.

i agree that it's possible crabtree might not be in the right spot, but more times than not it just seems like a complete overthrow. i think the tv commentators have touched on him air mailing his passes quite a bit


Crabtree doesn't practice EVER. So why wouldn't his be the most inaccurate throws. He doesn't probably even know where to be on the field.

you guys keep harping on crabtree not running the correct routes...but what i'm talking about is that 90% of the time his route is already finished and he's at the sideline waiting for a pass and smith air mails it.

jim harbaugh also mentioned after the bucs game that crabtree made a great leaping catch on that slant, that alex needed to have better accuracy. so it's clearly not all on crabtree.


Maybe he is already finished in the WRONG SPOT and the play calls for Alex to throw to a SPOT!.....
It's not like A. Smith struggled against a 1-5 team last Sunday. Pretty sure coming into Sunday everyone realized the Lions have one hella defense, more specifically the defensive line. We expected the offense and Smith will struggled. Now if he struggled like he did against the Browns...now that's something to worry about. Regression
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Maybe he is already finished in the WRONG SPOT and the play calls for Alex to throw to a SPOT!.....

so i guess harbaugh is wrong as well..got it
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
you guys keep harping on crabtree not running the correct routes...but what i'm talking about is that 90% of the time his route is already finished and he's at the sideline waiting for a pass and smith air mails it.

jim harbaugh also mentioned after the bucs game that crabtree made a great leaping catch on that slant, that alex needed to have better accuracy. so it's clearly not all on crabtree.

90% of teh time? What the heck are you talking about?
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Apone:
Smith played fine.

If you think that throwing for 120 yards, with barely a 50% completion percentage, with two turnovers and one touchdown is "fine," then your expectations of a good QB performance is REALLY low.

Originally posted by Apone:
It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game.

Considering he has done that three times in 6 years, I agree with you. But there isnt a poster on this board who expects him to do that every time, so I dont even know the point of bringing that up.

Originally posted by Apone:
He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

Agreed.

Aaron Rodgers had a couple games like this last year, I think he's a good quarterback. Are my expectations too low?

QBs who have a bad game are not worth a damn I'm guessing? Or maybe you're trying to say only Alex Smith should have to be perfect all the time because he was a number 1 pick and its been 7 years yada yada yada...

He's had a high completion percentage in all games but one this year, give the guy a break. He aint Joe Montana but some here would have you think Ken Dorsey is our QB, or Tim Rattay. Alex Smith is a well above average starting QB in the NFL, get over it, not all good QBs have to throw for 400 yards a game.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Maybe he is already finished in the WRONG SPOT and the play calls for Alex to throw to a SPOT!.....

so i guess harbaugh is wrong as well..got it

But still the question lingers: Why does this problem seem to primarily center on Crabtree? I am not saying it is all on Crabtree. I like Crabtree. But since Alex does not seem to have the same problem consistently with any other receiver it has to be more than just Alex. But I agree with an earlier post you made: they have to get it ironed out. My guess is that with Harbaugh in charge they will.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone