Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 781 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Alex did not play well against the Lions Sunday, but he was clutch. He is doing enough for us to win, so can't hate on him.
[ Edited by hateroids84 on Oct 18, 2011 at 5:03 PM ]
Originally posted by hateroids84:
Alex did not play well against the Lions Sunday, but he was clutch. He is doing enough for us to win, so can't hate on him.

Of course he didn't play well but he didn't play poorly like some people on this board are saying. Yes, he did what it took to win with the throw to Walker at the end. He could have done more than that if Crabs got his feet in for the TD or Walker would have caught the TD pass instead of dropping it.
Originally posted by THEB:
You guys saying that alex was bad sunday are retards. He had a couple high passes and one unfortunately ended up an INT.

You guys arent talking about the 7 GREAT passes that were dropped. GTFO with that "he played bad" BS. he played just fine.

And you calling the mass "retards" is... well... warnable.

- 98
  • THEB
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,760
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
And you calling the mass "retards" is... well... warnable.

- 98

Its it ok if i call them band wagoners that probably didnt watch the game if they though he played bad?

Didnt know the members were that sensitive.
Originally posted by THEB:
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
And you calling the mass "retards" is... well... warnable.

- 98

Its it ok if i call them band wagoners that probably didnt watch the game if they though he played bad?

Didnt know the members were that sensitive.

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/components/agreement.php

Read Rule #1. Rules that you agreed with when you signed up for this board.

And as for your question, why not just ask them if they watched the game instead of name calling?


- 98
Originally posted by THEB:
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
And you calling the mass "retards" is... well... warnable.

- 98

Its it ok if i call them band wagoners that probably didnt watch the game if they though he played bad?

Didnt know the members were that sensitive.

Yeah, very sensitive. Will be on you like Schwartz on Harbaugh
  • Apone
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,739
Smith played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league. It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game. Was there some bad throws? Sure. But there were also some bad drops too. He came through at the end and made a perfect clutch throw. I expect him to even play better once Edwards is back. He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.
Originally posted by Apone:
Smith played fine, in a hostile (loud) environment against a top defense and arguably the best front 4 in the league. It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game. Was there some bad throws? Sure. But there were also some bad drops too. He came through at the end and made a perfect clutch throw. I expect him to even play better once Edwards is back. He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

He nearly had 3 TDs if not for the Walker drop and Crabs not getting his feet down.
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by hateroids84:
Alex did not play well against the Lions Sunday, but he was clutch. He is doing enough for us to win, so can't hate on him.

Of course he didn't play well but he didn't play poorly like some people on this board are saying. Yes, he did what it took to win with the throw to Walker at the end. He could have done more than that if Crabs got his feet in for the TD or Walker would have caught the TD pass instead of dropping it.

Smith struggled along with the team. Not sure why he is singled out suddenly. Not like he was singled out as bad the last 6 years
  • THEB
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,760
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/components/agreement.php

Read Rule #1. Rules that you agreed with when you signed up for this board.

And as for your question, why not just ask them if they watched the game instead of name calling?


- 98

Is there a report button somewhere cause if i got warned for that i know a few people that need a good warning as well. there are a loooot of jerks on this board.
Originally posted by THEB:
Is there a report button somewhere cause if i got warned for that i know a few people that need a good warning as well. there are a loooot of jerks on this board.

Moderators are usually good at catching stuff. The only time that doesn't happen is during the game forums during Sundays. There are just too many people posting too quickly.
Originally posted by THEB:
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/components/agreement.php

Read Rule #1. Rules that you agreed with when you signed up for this board.

And as for your question, why not just ask them if they watched the game instead of name calling?


- 98

Is there a report button somewhere cause if i got warned for that i know a few people that need a good warning as well. there are a loooot of jerks on this board.

Feel free to PM any or all the Mods, through your profile page, or here: http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/members/pm.php?action=compose&contactform=1&origin=L2ZvcnVtL21lbWJlcnMv

and indicate where the infraction occurred (Forum/Thread/Post #).

- 98
Originally posted by Apone:
Smith played fine.

If you think that throwing for 120 yards, with barely a 50% completion percentage, with two turnovers and one touchdown is "fine," then your expectations of a good QB performance is REALLY low.

Originally posted by Apone:
It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game.

Considering he has done that three times in 6 years, I agree with you. But there isnt a poster on this board who expects him to do that every time, so I dont even know the point of bringing that up.

Originally posted by Apone:
He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

Agreed.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Originally posted by Apone:
Smith played fine.

If you think that throwing for 120 yards, with barely a 50% completion percentage, with two turnovers and one touchdown is "fine," then your expectations of a good QB performance is REALLY low.

Originally posted by Apone:
It's asinine to expect him to always throw for 3 TD's and have 110+ QB rating every game.

Considering he has done that three times in 6 years, I agree with you. But there isnt a poster on this board who expects him to do that every time, so I dont even know the point of bringing that up.

Originally posted by Apone:
He is having a good season, and much better than most of us expected.

Agreed.

I assume full well that you know that the fumble was on Staley. We can get into the compleition percentage but no Smith support said he had a good game but it wasn't bad or horrible. As for his play time let's not repeat the 6 years nonsense. He has played a bit more than 3 and half seasons worth of games.
the most amazing thing about alex is that all of his overthrows

ARE ALL TO MICHAEL CRABTREE!!!!!

i swear it's the most bizarre thing ever, whether he's wide open or covered, deep pass or short pass, alex CONSISTENTLY overthrows crabtree. for the life of me i just don't understand it. it's something alex really needs to fix, badly.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone