Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 753 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by aTx49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

No way Smith's agents allows him to sign for anything less than 3 years or possibility even 4.

Please don't say "no way" unless you yourself is making the deal. And please lets not get ahead of ourselves, even the Detroit Lions started out 6-2 at one point, before finishing the season under .500.

If he stays consistent this year he'll finish somewhere in the top 10 of QBs. If all his agent can he him is a 1-2 year contract then he should fire him and find someone who knows what he's doing. Matt Cassel got 6 yrs/63 million for one decent season.

Will it also does depend on how he plays out the season and what his stats look like. If he goes into a slump and we still manage to squeak into the playoffs and lose in the first round, I'd still say 1-2 years. But judging by all the good things that's been happening around him, its really hard to see his play fall off from here till the playoffs. Either way I still wouldn't mind keeping him around till Tolzien is ready.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I have no problem with him being extended at this point. 4-5 years 50 to 60 million dollars. If he regresses Kaepernick takes over.

Alot of you guys will think that's way too much well unfortunately that's the price for a competent quarterback.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


You want to give up the #3 rated passer in the NFL for a guy who doesn't know what to do in the pocket? For a long term project who may or may not work out?

Yes. Alex has been mediocre at best. He's had a career of disappointment. His last 6 quarters of football have been great. Kaep stepped in and the offense didn't miss a beat. I'm just not ready to accept Alex as a quality starting QB in the NFL.

Mostly though, I attribute Smith's success to Harbaugh. I believe that he could get the same production with Kaepernick or Tolzein. Those guys haveas much talent as Smith, if not more.

At best, if Smith continues to play good this season, extend him for 2 years. He's played well, but his rating is overrated. He didn't take any chances in the first few weeks, which limited his mistakes. It's like Garrard and Pennington. They're uber conservative and finish with high ratings, but never lead solid passing attacks. There's a reason no one jumped onboard when Garrard was cut.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
Originally posted by strickac:
Yes. Alex has been mediocre at best. He's had a career of disappointment. His last 6 quarters of football have been great. Kaep stepped in and the offense didn't miss a beat. I'm just not ready to accept Alex as a quality starting QB in the NFL.

Mostly though, I attribute Smith's success to Harbaugh. I believe that he could get the same production with Kaepernick or Tolzein. Those guys haveas much talent as Smith, if not more.

At best, if Smith continues to play good this season, extend him for 2 years. He's played well, but his rating is overrated. He didn't take any chances in the first few weeks, which limited his mistakes. It's like Garrard and Pennington. They're uber conservative and finish with high ratings, but never lead solid passing attacks. There's a reason no one jumped onboard when Garrard was cut.


It's for the Championship, coach.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
I'd lock him up to 3 yrs. or max 5 yrs. Lock him up while he's still in he's prime.
Originally posted by strickac:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I have no problem with him being extended at this point. 4-5 years 50 to 60 million dollars. If he regresses Kaepernick takes over.

Alot of you guys will think that's way too much well unfortunately that's the price for a competent quarterback.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


You want to give up the #3 rated passer in the NFL for a guy who doesn't know what to do in the pocket? For a long term project who may or may not work out?

Yes. Alex has been mediocre at best. He's had a career of disappointment. His last 6 quarters of football have been great. Kaep stepped in and the offense didn't miss a beat. I'm just not ready to accept Alex as a quality starting QB in the NFL.

Mostly though, I attribute Smith's success to Harbaugh. I believe that he could get the same production with Kaepernick or Tolzein. Those guys haveas much talent as Smith, if not more.

At best, if Smith continues to play good this season, extend him for 2 years. He's played well, but his rating is overrated. He didn't take any chances in the first few weeks, which limited his mistakes. It's like Garrard and Pennington. They're uber conservative and finish with high ratings, but never lead solid passing attacks. There's a reason no one jumped onboard when Garrard was cut.

When Alex succeeds it's because of the coach. When he fails it's because of Alex. Don't you Alex haters see the hypocricy and inconsistency in that argument?....
I've been a Smith supporter since day one but I feel that we should wait before we try and resign him. If and when the front office decides to resign him hopefully it is the form of an extension rather then letting him sit in free agency.
If the season would end that way, IMO Alex deserves what ever deal he ask for. Its win/win because he would be the QB the 9ers want him to be and Kap would have the time to develop. IMO If his performance is consistant through the rest of the season and he wins 1 playoff game he deserves a new deal. He earned it.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by strickac:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I have no problem with him being extended at this point. 4-5 years 50 to 60 million dollars. If he regresses Kaepernick takes over.

Alot of you guys will think that's way too much well unfortunately that's the price for a competent quarterback.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:


You want to give up the #3 rated passer in the NFL for a guy who doesn't know what to do in the pocket? For a long term project who may or may not work out?

Yes. Alex has been mediocre at best. He's had a career of disappointment. His last 6 quarters of football have been great. Kaep stepped in and the offense didn't miss a beat. I'm just not ready to accept Alex as a quality starting QB in the NFL.

Mostly though, I attribute Smith's success to Harbaugh. I believe that he could get the same production with Kaepernick or Tolzein. Those guys haveas much talent as Smith, if not more.

At best, if Smith continues to play good this season, extend him for 2 years. He's played well, but his rating is overrated. He didn't take any chances in the first few weeks, which limited his mistakes. It's like Garrard and Pennington. They're uber conservative and finish with high ratings, but never lead solid passing attacks. There's a reason no one jumped onboard when Garrard was cut.

When Alex succeeds it's because of the coach. When he fails it's because of Alex. Don't you Alex haters see the hypocricy and inconsistency in that argument?....
I think there's plenty of hypocrisy on both sides SD.

I'm not ready to sign Alex to a long term deal yet. Agreed, he has played the best of his career so far this year. Maybe it's coaching, maybe he's turned a corner, I don't really know. Either way, I need to see him play at this level for a lot more games considering his first 6 years or so. It will take me at least this year of consistent play to make any judgement.

LB
As the games get more meaningful Alex will be put into situations where it will be up to him to win the game. If he produces-sign him.
Originally posted by strickac:
Yes. Alex has been mediocre at best. He's had a career of disappointment. His last 6 quarters of football have been great. Kaep stepped in and the offense didn't miss a beat. I'm just not ready to accept Alex as a quality starting QB in the NFL.

Mostly though, I attribute Smith's success to Harbaugh. I believe that he could get the same production with Kaepernick or Tolzein. Those guys haveas much talent as Smith, if not more.

At best, if Smith continues to play good this season, extend him for 2 years. He's played well, but his rating is overrated. He didn't take any chances in the first few weeks, which limited his mistakes. It's like Garrard and Pennington. They're uber conservative and finish with high ratings, but never lead solid passing attacks. There's a reason no one jumped onboard when Garrard was cut.

Watch the game again, he was having trouble on handoffs and all his passes were designed to make one read and throw it.
Originally posted by backontop:
I've been a Smith supporter since day one but I feel that we should wait before we try and resign him. If and when the front office decides to resign him hopefully it is the form of an extension rather then letting him sit in free agency.

Can you extend a one year contract? I vaguely recall that you can't.

And lol to all of the posters laying down the law as to what Smith will have to take etc. If he carries on this season as he has played so far, at the end of the season he has all the high trumps in his hand. All we have is the hope that he wants to stay with Harbaugh. If we let our starting qb walk out after all we have been through, we will be the laughing stock of the NFL. And rightly.

And to those of you who have him keeping the seat warm for one or other youngster, has the period since Garcia taught you nothing? Good starting NFL qb's are hard to find (and expensive). And there is absolutely no guarantee that either of the youngsters has it. Odds are, they are probably back-up standard at best. You hope for better, but you dont bet your franchise on it.

Remember the mantra of the NFL. What have you done for me today?
Today.

Here is a prediction. Brees gets locked up and Alex signs a five year contract. This is one shot Baalke simply cannot afford to miss.
[ Edited by English on Oct 12, 2011 at 4:37 AM ]
We are only 5 games in... how about we wait till near the end of the season before we sign anyone to long term deals... this is a week-to-week league... Who knows what will happen in the next 11 games?
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by aTx49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

No way Smith's agents allows him to sign for anything less than 3 years or possibility even 4.

Please don't say "no way" unless you yourself is making the deal. And please lets not get ahead of ourselves, even the Detroit Lions started out 6-2 at one point, before finishing the season under .500.

If he stays consistent this year he'll finish somewhere in the top 10 of QBs. If all his agent can he him is a 1-2 year contract then he should fire him and find someone who knows what he's doing. Matt Cassel got 6 yrs/63 million for one decent season.

Will it also does depend on how he plays out the season and what his stats look like. If he goes into a slump and we still manage to squeak into the playoffs and lose in the first round, I'd still say 1-2 years. But judging by all the good things that's been happening around him, its really hard to see his play fall off from here till the playoffs. Either way I still wouldn't mind keeping him around till Tolzien is ready.

Yeah, sorry for being so short. I should have said if Smith plays well and is the top 10 of QBs for the rest of the year I don't believe there is a way he only signs a 2 year contract.
Originally posted by RedWaltz24:
We are only 5 games in... how about we wait till near the end of the season before we sign anyone to long term deals... this is a week-to-week league... Who knows what will happen in the next 11 games?

I think that is what most people are saying. I know I'm doing that. Wait till the end of the season and see how things go.

BUT, we are fans so let's have the conversation.
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by RedWaltz24:
We are only 5 games in... how about we wait till near the end of the season before we sign anyone to long term deals... this is a week-to-week league... Who knows what will happen in the next 11 games?

I think that is what most people are saying. I know I'm doing that. Wait till the end of the season and see how things go.

BUT, we are fans so let's have the conversation.

The guys saying let's leave it to the end of the season need to come back to the real world. This is just a fanzone and we are just chatting. It makes no difference to what will actually happen. So why not speculate.

And judging from some of the responses, just as well!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone