There are 1,004 users in the forums
Alex Smith Thread
Oct 12, 2011 at 4:55 AM
- DKPthe49erfan
- Veteran
- Posts: 44
Long term deal Vernon said Alex wants to retire a 49er
Oct 12, 2011 at 5:17 AM
- adembroski
- Veteran
- Posts: 128
I was REALLY happy to see Kaepernick throw well in mop up time. I still go back to the preseason and I see a kid with extremely poor footwork, unreliable accuracy, and a tendency to fire bullets when touch is needed. I'm REALLY not sold on Kaepernick, and it's tough to find a QB that's as good as Smith's playing right now.
Additionally, Smith's performance isn't a fluke. Teams have thrown the kitchen sink at this kid this season looking to throw him off, and he keeps on beating them. That throw to Walker for the first TD of the Bucs game... that's an elite NFL throw. I say you lock him up and no longer consider that #1 pick wasted.
Additionally, Smith's performance isn't a fluke. Teams have thrown the kitchen sink at this kid this season looking to throw him off, and he keeps on beating them. That throw to Walker for the first TD of the Bucs game... that's an elite NFL throw. I say you lock him up and no longer consider that #1 pick wasted.
Oct 12, 2011 at 6:55 AM
- Mr.Mcgibblets
- Veteran
- Posts: 15,079
I think the question that needs to be asked to really answer this original question is... how likely is it that Alex will somehow regress?
We know we are keeping Harbaugh a while... we know Alex's mentality will be to constantly keep him working hard to get better and better... we know that Alex has already had everything the NFL has to offer thrown at him in the form of adversity... and he's still on his feet and fighting well.
So while we have to know that he WILL have a bad game here and there... have an off day as all QBs are capable of... Do we really think he's gonna fall apart and be a liability? I sure don't... and if you don't either, then why wouldn't you give the nod of approval on a new contract?
Is it because you may think Kaepernick or Tolzien can be better? Based on what? and would you really let a top 10-12 quarterback walk when you have no idea of the young backups? We'r likely not gonna be picking in the draft until the 20's... so who would be a better starting QB then?
We know we are keeping Harbaugh a while... we know Alex's mentality will be to constantly keep him working hard to get better and better... we know that Alex has already had everything the NFL has to offer thrown at him in the form of adversity... and he's still on his feet and fighting well.
So while we have to know that he WILL have a bad game here and there... have an off day as all QBs are capable of... Do we really think he's gonna fall apart and be a liability? I sure don't... and if you don't either, then why wouldn't you give the nod of approval on a new contract?
Is it because you may think Kaepernick or Tolzien can be better? Based on what? and would you really let a top 10-12 quarterback walk when you have no idea of the young backups? We'r likely not gonna be picking in the draft until the 20's... so who would be a better starting QB then?
Oct 12, 2011 at 7:00 AM
- 49ersfansince90
- Veteran
- Posts: 144
Where is the option of signing him to a short, incentive-driven deal? Regardless, the front office needs to take the wait and see approach. Just as people were sending him packing due to inconsistant play, we can't break the back or even mortgage the near future for 5 solid games in a row.
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
Oct 12, 2011 at 7:14 AM
- Mr.Mcgibblets
- Veteran
- Posts: 15,079
Originally posted by 49ersfansince90:
Where is the option of signing him to a short, incentive-driven deal? Regardless, the front office needs to take the wait and see approach. Just as people were sending him packing due to inconsistant play, we can't break the back or even mortgage the near future for 5 solid games in a row.
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
Just don't know that the bolded would be reasonable. I think Alex will take less to stay, sure... but he nor is agent is gonna totally bend over on this. Whatever the contract will be, I think it would have to be at least 3 years and at least 8 or mil a year... and that's being generous considering what QBs are making these days.
Oct 12, 2011 at 7:36 AM
- tjd808185
- Veteran
- Posts: 26,075
Originally posted by strickac:I somewhat agree with what you're saying but at same time market conditions come into play. If Smith's agent has a brain in his head he'll be asking for Kolb or Cassel type money.
Yes. Alex has been mediocre at best. He's had a career of disappointment. His last 6 quarters of football have been great. Kaep stepped in and the offense didn't miss a beat. I'm just not ready to accept Alex as a quality starting QB in the NFL.
Mostly though, I attribute Smith's success to Harbaugh. I believe that he could get the same production with Kaepernick or Tolzein. Those guys haveas much talent as Smith, if not more.
At best, if Smith continues to play good this season, extend him for 2 years. He's played well, but his rating is overrated. He didn't take any chances in the first few weeks, which limited his mistakes. It's like Garrard and Pennington. They're uber conservative and finish with high ratings, but never lead solid passing attacks. There's a reason no one jumped onboard when Garrard was cut.
I wouldn't blame the organization for resigning Alex for that type of amount. Just word the contract the right way that we can escape if we have to.
Oct 12, 2011 at 7:45 AM
- superniner
- Veteran
- Posts: 34
I would say sign him to a 3 or 4 year deal if he keeps playing the way he is playing. He will only get better with a full off season. If kap shows anything I would rather have two good quarterbacks. Look what San Diego did with brees and rivers. I don't care about the money. It cost money to win.
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:00 AM
- taney71
- Veteran
- Posts: 18,642
Originally posted by 49ersfansince90:
Where is the option of signing him to a short, incentive-driven deal? Regardless, the front office needs to take the wait and see approach. Just as people were sending him packing due to inconsistant play, we can't break the back or even mortgage the near future for 5 solid games in a row.
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
Going back to last season Smith has played 10 or 11 good games in a row.
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:02 AM
- valrod33
- Hall of Small
- Posts: 138,122
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersfansince90:
Where is the option of signing him to a short, incentive-driven deal? Regardless, the front office needs to take the wait and see approach. Just as people were sending him packing due to inconsistant play, we can't break the back or even mortgage the near future for 5 solid games in a row.
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
Going back to last season Smith has played 10 or 11 good games in a row.
Smith now has 15 touchdown passes with only two interceptions in his last 10 regular-season starts. The 49ers are 7-3 in those games.
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:14 AM
- cgida
- Veteran
- Posts: 372
I sometimes wonder why I even take the time to read these threads.
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:17 AM
- Memphis9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 12,768
Originally posted by cgida:I sometimes wonder why I even take the time to read these threads.
Entertainment?
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:32 AM
- TheRickestRick
- Veteran
- Posts: 10,450
If he does remain consistent and lead us to the playoffs, Give him a 3 yr deal for average starting money.
Harbaugh gave him his what? 5th chance? Smith feels loyalty to this franchise and most likely will want to stay for less money with the direction we are headed. CK & Tolzien can keep developing on the bench. Smith continues to progress, awesome we have our franchise QB (7yrs later) and maybe some trade bait if CK or Tolzien light up preseasons. Smith struggles, 3 years isnt a big hit on the cap and one of the backups step in and prove their worth.
Harbaugh gave him his what? 5th chance? Smith feels loyalty to this franchise and most likely will want to stay for less money with the direction we are headed. CK & Tolzien can keep developing on the bench. Smith continues to progress, awesome we have our franchise QB (7yrs later) and maybe some trade bait if CK or Tolzien light up preseasons. Smith struggles, 3 years isnt a big hit on the cap and one of the backups step in and prove their worth.
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:32 AM
- 49ersfansince90
- Veteran
- Posts: 144
Originally posted by valrod33:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersfansince90:
Where is the option of signing him to a short, incentive-driven deal? Regardless, the front office needs to take the wait and see approach. Just as people were sending him packing due to inconsistant play, we can't break the back or even mortgage the near future for 5 solid games in a row.
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
Going back to last season Smith has played 10 or 11 good games in a row.
Smith now has 15 touchdown passes with only two interceptions in his last 10 regular-season starts. The 49ers are 7-3 in those games.
Very true. I have always been a supporter of Alex and I am happy to see him play well. I just feel that we really need to let him play out the season and go from there....Unless he wins the MVP, I wouldn't go more than a 3 year deal.
http://njsportsaddict.blogspot.com/
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:41 AM
- rk1642
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,324
The team will have no choice but to give Alex at least a 4 year deal at somehere around average of top 10 qb money, if he continues on his current progression. By playing this well for an entire season and getting us to the playoffs, Alex will have demonstrated that he still has potential to be an elite qb in the NFL. Coaching and scheme will have shown to be a huge difference to show what he really has to offer. Also, the team around him will get nothing but better in the years ahead and no ownership / gm in their right minds would mess with an up and coming team just off reaching the playoffs for the 1st time in forever.
Oct 12, 2011 at 8:42 AM
- LieutKaffee
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,988
.
[ Edited by LieutKaffee on Oct 12, 2011 at 8:48 AM ]