Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 742 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

No way Smith's agents allows him to sign for anything less than 3 years or possibility even 4.

Please don't say "no way" unless you yourself is making the deal. And please lets not get ahead of ourselves, even the Detroit Lions started out 6-2 at one point, before finishing the season under .500.

If he stays consistent this year he'll finish somewhere in the top 10 of QBs. If all his agent can he him is a 1-2 year contract then he should fire him and find someone who knows what he's doing. Matt Cassel got 6 yrs/63 million for one decent season.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I have no problem with him being extended at this point. 4-5 years 50 to 60 million dollars. If he regresses Kaepernick takes over.

Alot of you guys will think that's way too much well unfortunately that's the price for a competent quarterback.

Exactly. In business school, they usually put the question this way: if you let an employee go, how much it'd cost you to get a person that can do the job at the same level of performance? Before this year, it's relatively easy to find a guy to do Smith's job. At the current level of performance, it's much harder. The only better bet is Drew Brees who is in the final year of his contract. If the Saints are dumb enough to let him go, Brees will want a gold mine from any team that's going to sign him - a big reason why the extension deal is at the stand-still at this point.
Originally posted by aTx49er:
If he stays consistent this year he'll finish somewhere in the top 10 of QBs. If all his agent can he him is a 1-2 year contract then he should fire him and find someone who knows what he's doing. Matt Cassel got 6 yrs/63 million for one decent season.

Tom Condon represents Smith. He's the same guy that represents Peyton Manning, Eli Manning, Drew Brees. I think Smith just has to worry about performing well on the field. Condon will take care of him at the negotiating table.
IF and that is a giant "IF", he finishes in the top 10 across most QB categories I'd give him 3-4 years at around what Schaub/Ryan type guys are making. Even if finishes top 10 in most categories he is still not worth Brady/Brees/Manning money simply because he has no track record of success.
If he plays this well all season, I don't see why not. He will have to show a lot the next few weeks as we hit the hard part of our schedule. I like Colin down the road, but if Smith can have a few good seasons now, I don't mind letting Colin sit and learn for a while
colin is going to be a force later on.
If this happened the Niners would have to take the risk and sign him to a long term deal, It's not worth the risk of letting him walk and being stuck in the same hole they've been in since Garcia left. The faithful know how hard is to find a QB and if you had one on the roster that took you to the NFC title game and then let him walk, that would be dumb! If he played for another team and had similar results, NT would burn to the ground.
[ Edited by Boomer49 on Oct 11, 2011 at 8:28 PM ]
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by SoCal9ers:
Offensive Coordinator will get a HC position with the Dolphins or Rams. Alex Smith falls back to the losing years. we create more Alex Smith threads.
that sounds more realistic

Is the sky blue in your world????
Maybe if he plays well for a whole season, and not just most of 5 games.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Maybe if he plays well for a whole season, and not just most of 5 games.

This. Why the hell is this question even being asked RIGHT NOW? I will agree that Smith as played exceptional this year, but why the f**k are we talking about extending a QB with an iffy past history after 5 good games? Lets wait till he finishes the entire season before making any guesses on what type of deal he gets.
If Keap is ready let him walk just as the Bolts did Brees. Harbaugh does a good job of hiding him and keeping them out of bad situation. Right now Alex is trying to do his (Brees last year in SD impression).. Im not a hater b4 that starts and I also believe thats why Keap gets snaps. Plus I hate to say it but the last times I remember alex having a good game or two he got hurt,God forbid but seemingly true.
Originally posted by fastforward:
Exactly. In business school, they usually put the question this way: if you let an employee go, how much it'd cost you to get a person that can do the job at the same level of performance? Before this year, it's relatively easy to find a guy to do Smith's job. At the current level of performance, it's much harder. The only better bet is Drew Brees who is in the final year of his contract. If the Saints are dumb enough to let him go, Brees will want a gold mine from any team that's going to sign him - a big reason why the extension deal is at the stand-still at this point.

Hell Naw not that much money. Make him earn that first 50 Mil contract he signed. lol
Originally posted by D-NOTTE:
Hell Naw not that much money. Make him earn that first 50 Mil contract he signed. lol

After this year, Smith will be an unrestricted free agent. It'll be very difficult to make him "earn" his $50 million contract after the season (he only got slightly more than half of that sum according to some reports, BTW.)
[ Edited by fastforward on Oct 12, 2011 at 12:16 AM ]
Originally posted by smashmouth51:
Yeah, like Alex wants to leave JH and go learn a new system with all new coaches. Get real. He has enough money to be set for life so that isn't an issue. At this point in Alex's career he is looking for a place to feel comfortable and have sucess. A 3 yr deal for 18-20 mil at the end of a successful season would make him happy and everyone else too..

Anyone have a count of how many professional athletes that had "enough money to be set for life" and are now broke....?
Believe me.. He will not want 2 leave harbaugh if he continues playin great
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone