Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 723 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by blake6905:
If he can get us to the 2nd-3rd round of the playoffs I say resign him for 2-3 years.
"IF" we got a #2 seed and a bye would that count? or are we talking 1 or 2+ post-season wins? just wondering
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

No way Smith's agents allows him to sign for anything less than 3 years or possibility even 4.

Please don't say "no way" unless you yourself is making the deal. And please lets not get ahead of ourselves, even the Detroit Lions started out 6-2 at one point, before finishing the season under .500.
can we just wait until the offseason?
Wait till the end of the season, the season is barely at the 1/3 point. Why? Because he will want to keep playing for JH, also teams know that his success is tied to Harbaugh so unless he is going to a coach that is similar he will more than likely fail so his market vvalue won't be as good as he thinks-just like the other former 49ers players and Dashon experienced, and anything can happen between now and the end of the season. If the niners get to the playoffs and win at least one game then sign him to a two year deal- that way he will alway be there till Colin or Tolz is ready, but if Colin or Tolz is ready by year three-trade him and least you got your moneys worth.
Originally posted by WildBill:
Wait till the end of the season, the season is barely at the 1/3 point. Why? Because he will want to keep playing for JH, also teams know that his success is tied to Harbaugh so unless he is going to a coach that is similar he will more than likely fail so his market vvalue won't be as good as he thinks-just like the other former 49ers players and Dashon experienced, and anything can happen between now and the end of the season. If the niners get to the playoffs and win at least one game then sign him to a two year deal- that way he will alway be there till Colin or Tolz is ready, but if Colin or Tolz is ready by year three-trade him and least you got your moneys worth.

Why would you trade the #3 rated passer in the NFL?.... If he can play like this you stick with him.
Alex isn't going anywhere. He likes SF, the coaches, his success etc. Wait until the end of the season and sign him for 3 yrs if he keeps being successful.. If Kap develops nicely in OTAs & TC next year then he will be ready to challenage by year 3. If Kap is slow in developing then we have Alex until they figure it out. I like the 3 qbs we have now and over the next 3 yrs the order of starting qb can change but we would still have 3 solid qbs.
Yeah, like Alex wants to leave JH and go learn a new system with all new coaches. Get real. He has enough money to be set for life so that isn't an issue. At this point in Alex's career he is looking for a place to feel comfortable and have sucess. A 3 yr deal for 18-20 mil at the end of a successful season would make him happy and everyone else too..
Originally posted by smashmouth51:
Yeah, like Alex wants to leave JH and go learn a new system with all new coaches. Get real. He has enough money to be set for life so that isn't an issue. At this point in Alex's career he is looking for a place to feel comfortable and have sucess. A 3 yr deal for 18-20 mil at the end of a successful season would make him happy and everyone else too..

It's pretty likely he will want to stay. And IMO that's in his best interests. But we have to be somewhat reasonable on the amount.
It depends how he does on February 5th.
Not yet. We'll see how he plays through the season and possibly the playoffs, then come up with an amount.
  • Antix
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,984
Not an issue.

If Smith continues to do well then he's not gonna wanna bounce to another coach and another OC. Might as well stay here, get a raise and continue to shine.
Even tho I am and always has been a Alex supporter I think its too early for that. This Detroit game with the amount of pressure he is going to recieve will be a tell, tell sign of Alex current ability. Its going to be loud in Detroit and they are going to come after him with vengenace.
Originally posted by smashmouth51:
Yeah, like Alex wants to leave JH and go learn a new system with all new coaches. Get real. He has enough money to be set for life so that isn't an issue. At this point in Alex's career he is looking for a place to feel comfortable and have sucess. A 3 yr deal for 18-20 mil at the end of a successful season would make him happy and everyone else too..
That's a $6 million/year deal, barely up from this year. It doesn't matter if he's got enough money to last this lifetime of his. If that's the case Peyton Manning wouldn't have sought the extension over last season. Humans have something called ego (even if you ignore greed.) Let's not forget that the average pay for the top 16 QB salaries right now is north of $11 million/year. There is no reason for any QB not to seek extra money when he can.

The fact that Smith managed to be successful so far with barely 3 months of practicing/playing means that he can adapt to another WCO. There will be more than a couple of WCO teams looking for a starting QB at the end of this season if the 49ers let Smith walk after a good season.
[ Edited by fastforward on Oct 11, 2011 at 7:08 PM ]
Originally posted by overthemiddle:
Even tho I am and always has been a Alex supporter I think its too early for that. This Detroit game with the amount of pressure he is going to recieve will be a tell, tell sign of Alex current ability. Its going to be loud in Detroit and they are going to come after him with vengenace.

The premise given by the OP is good performance + playoff appearance. In that scenario, the long-term discussion is logical. In reality given that the team is only 5 games into the season, I agree that this isn't the right time to discuss long-term deal. After 12 games, perhaps it's time for the FO to think seriously about making the decision.
I have no problem with him being extended at this point. 4-5 years 50 to 60 million dollars. If he regresses Kaepernick takes over.

Alot of you guys will think that's way too much well unfortunately that's the price for a competent quarterback.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Oct 11, 2011 at 7:14 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone