Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 859 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,393
A lot of posters here are failing reading comprehension. (: The question is not do you sign Alex to a long term deal after 5 games, it is do you sign him to a long term deal if he accomplishes the following:
1. Leads the team to a 11-5 record
2. Wins a divisional playoff game
3. Loses in a NFC Championship game where he plays "okay"

For all of those that say to sign him to a 3 year contract with lots of incentives, Alex will reject your offer and instead test the free agency market. Alex is still young and has won a playoff game. He also has a lot of experience in various offensive systems, allowing him to pick them up faster than most QB. Teams will overpay for him (average of top 10 QB salaries sounds about right).

For Alex to sign with the 49ers he will want the following:
1. Money close to what he could get in the free agent market.
2. A long term deal to ensure that he won't be looking over his shoulder at Colin Kaep
[ Edited by fryet on Oct 12, 2011 at 9:12 AM ]
I say give it to him.

As for Colin, I think we're in a good spot with him. He was drafted in the second round more as Harbaugh's plaything rather than as a true "heir apparent." It's not like we drafted a guy in the top 10 where every game that goes by with him on the bench gets more and more awkward. If Smith continues his progression as a legit starter, Colin could develop into a very nice backup QB with upside.
Im just curious where you guys think Alex would have options to go if he walks away from us. Obviously if he has a good season, there will be some teams interested....but I just dont see there being teams lining up to sign him.

Lets break it down for a minute....

Ravens - Flacco
Bengals - Andy Dalton
Browns - potential landing spot if ownership sours on McCoy
Steelers - Big Ben
Texans - Schaub
Colts - Peyton Manning, Andrew Luck or both
Jaguars - Just spent a high pick on Gabbert
Titans - Hasselbeck has been great this year
Bills - Fitzpatrick looks to be locked in as starter
Dolphins - really bad team, would probably prefer Luck or Barkley over Alex, but I guess this is a maybe
Patriots - LOL
Jets - Might be an upgrade, but would never happen
Broncos - doubtful with Tebow and Orton
Chiefs - Cassel is locked up
Raiders - Alex might be an upgrade, but I dont see them getting rid of Campbell if the team continues to improve
Chargers - Rivers
Bears - Cutler
Lions - Stafford
Green Bay - Best QB in the league
Vikings - McNabb wont be around long, but they already have their QB waiting in the wings in Ponder
Falcons - Matt Ryan doesnt look great this season, but hes their guy
Panthers - Killa Cam
Saints - Brees
Tampa Bay - Freeman had a great rookie season but hasnt been great so far. Dont see them giving up on him.
Cowboys - Some are sour on Romo, but Alex isnt a definitive upgrade.
Giants - Eli locked
Eagles - Vick
Redskins - Grossman isnt consistent, but if they keep winning, he wont be replaced
Cardinals - locked up Kolb
Seahawks - potential landing spot, but Tavaras hasnt been awful this season
Rams - Bradford

So again, I ask you what options do you think Alex realistically would have? The only teams I see as potential realistic possibilities are the Dolphins, Seahawks and Browns....two of which will probably have high to very high draft picks next year.

Even if Alex has an incredible season, I dont think it would be smart to give him a huge money deal, seeing as we wouldnt really have many teams clamoring for his services.
[ Edited by 80sbaby24 on Oct 12, 2011 at 11:45 AM ]
The 9ers can wait until the end of the year and see how this plays out because it doesn't make sense for Alex to go anywhere else. He's going to go to a new team and learn a new system? No way.
Here's the thing, IF Alex keeps playing well and winning games in this scenario, I think he can command a 5 year contract that averages out to $10M-$14M/year. I think that salary median is for mid-upper half of starting QB's, and I think the Niners would be wise to pick up that offer. A 5 year contract could probably be easily set up to cut him at year 4 or 5, making it a 3 year contract with an additional 2 year window dressing. Under this scenario, I think it is an easier decision to live with.

Real question would be if we have a good season with 9-10 wins and losing our first playoff game, would you sign Alex to that type of long term contract?

Either way, it's a question that needs to visited later. He wouldn't be able to sign a contract this year after signing a 1 year contract. Plus, his agent would want to see what the market dictates in the off-season.
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Im just curious where you guys think Alex would have options to go if he walks away from us. Obviously if he has a good season, there will be some teams interested....but I just dont see there being teams lining up to sign him.

Lets break it down for a minute....

Ravens - Flacco
Bengals - Andy Dalton
Browns - potential landing spot if ownership sours on McCoy
Steelers - Big Ben
Texans - Schaub
Colts - Peyton Manning, Andrew Luck or both-They might want him to be the bridge in between the two.
Jaguars - Just spent a high pick on Gabbert
Titans - Hasselbeck has been great this year-He is getting close to retirement and is easily broken.
Bills - Fitzpatrick looks to be locked in as starter
Dolphins - really bad team, would probably prefer Luck or Barkley over Alex, but I guess this is a maybe
Patriots - LOL
Jets - Might be an upgrade, but would never happen
Broncos - doubtful with Tebow and Orton...Really..I mean really?
Chiefs - Cassel is locked up
Raiders - Alex might be an upgrade, but I dont see them getting rid of Campbell if the team continues to improve
Chargers - Rivers
Bears - Cutler
Lions - Stafford
Green Bay - Best QB in the league
Vikings - McNabb wont be around long, but they already have their QB waiting in the wings in Ponder
Falcons - Matt Ryan doesnt look great this season, but hes their guy- This is a headscratcher , I am surprised he dropped off, thought he was a sure thing.
Panthers - Killa Cam
Saints - Brees
Tampa Bay - Freeman had a great rookie season but hasnt been great so far. Dont see them giving up on him.
Cowboys - Some are sour on Romo, but Alex isnt a definitive upgrade.-Debatable,I guarantee you they'd trade Romos turnovers for Smiths.
Giants - Eli locked
Eagles - Vick
Redskins - Grossman isnt consistent, but if they keep winning, he wont be replaced-See Cowboys...
Cardinals - locked up Kolb
Seahawks - potential landing spot, but Tavaras hasnt been awful this season -Whitehurst might actually be better than TJ.
Rams - Bradford -Poor kid

So again, I ask you what options do you think Alex realistically would have? The only teams I see as potential realistic possibilities are the Dolphins, Seahawks and Browns....two of which will probably have high to very high draft picks next year.

Even if Alex has an incredible season, I dont think it would be smart to give him a huge money deal, seeing as we wouldnt really have many teams clamoring for his services.

I don't think that we have to worry about any of this though. Smith seems to like being a Niner, I do not think he would go anywhere else for cash. This team has formed some great chemistry and I think we will have an easy time resigning most everyone that we want to.
Broncos
Dolphins
Raiders
Pats to backup Brady
Seattle
Alex Smith can do everything Rodgers does. Lets wait until the season gets to that point.
You do realize that Harbaugh's plan this entire time was to make Alex spectacularly good, then trade him away as part of a package to draft Luck, right?
Yes, resign him, even if he doesn't finish at as high of a level as he is playing now. HE would be an awesome backup. We already know he plays good for a game or two when he comes off the bench.
3 Years with an option - everyone walks away happy. Guarantee 12 of it put incentives so it can climb to 17. Everyone is happy.

Anyone who thinks Kaep is ready is smoking a 2nd year QB will seriously set this team back. This team wins a playoff game and finishes 11-5 or better everyone needs to admit the level of horrific coaching in this franchise was so severely underestimated that it couldn't be seen until now - we thought it was bad but folks it was horrific - and it cost players parts of the careers.

Ironic to think could actually Nowin and Simpletary never get jobs based on what Alex is doing now and their failure is SO glaring - how is that for sweet revenge.
Originally posted by zillabeast:
You do realize that Harbaugh's plan this entire time was to make Alex spectacularly good, then trade him away as part of a package to draft Luck, right?

I like it...only one problem though. How do you trade away a one-year contract player? Are you talking about after he re-signs long term? If so, now we're talking about Niners eating guaranteed money, etc.

I like the idea though. Hope we get Lucky!
Originally posted by mcbaes72:
Originally posted by zillabeast:
You do realize that Harbaugh's plan this entire time was to make Alex spectacularly good, then trade him away as part of a package to draft Luck, right?

I like it...only one problem though. How do you trade away a one-year contract player? Are you talking about after he re-signs long term? If so, now we're talking about Niners eating guaranteed money, etc.

I like the idea though. Hope we get Lucky!



Yeah yeah, new contract lol
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,393
It only takes one team trying to outbid the 49ers to drive up the price. I would expect Miami to be in the mix, plus maybe some teams with strong defenses but weak QBs, like Baltimore and the Jets. Remember how much Chicago gave up for Jay Cutler? I can't even imagine the bidding war for a player on the free market that has won a playoff game, is young, and requires nothing but money to sign.
I would give him like a 2 year deal with a club option for a 3rd. By then the quarterback of the future should be on the roster, if he isn't already
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone