49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 751 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by jimmy49erfan:
No but the coaching makes them good. Id rather see what we have in the guy JH n Baalke traded up for than to see us sign Smith to a LTD. Now if Smith gets us a 6th ring ill eat some crow and wash it down with a tall glass of shut the f**k up. Anything less he is not worth it.

I think it depends on the contract Smith would sign and that is based on him having a good year which looks likely after 5 games.

If we can sign Smith to a 3-5 year deal at 7-10 mil a year I'm thinking that is a smart move especially if a bunch of that is incentive based. What do the 9ers lose with doing that?

Good post and the right way to go. Understand that the people most disliking of Alex will be far more reluctant to retain him.

No offense to anyone here... it's just the way it is.
Sign Alex to a long term big contract?






















YES! 3 year deal at least
Originally posted by jimmy49erfan:
Unless he leads us to a Super Bowl and looks like a franchise QB all season long f**k no. Let Condon rape some other team. We got 2 young QBs who will know the offense in 2012 and we should go with 1 of them.



We have 2 guys who are completely unproven. Kaep looks like he has no clue in the pocket. You want to give up the #3 rated passer in the NFL for that?...

I do like Tolzien though... He's not better than Alex at this point though.
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Sign Alex to a long term big contract?























Lol. I love you man! Take the hate with you wherever you go!@!
Offensive Coordinator will get a HC position with the Dolphins or Rams. Alex Smith falls back to the losing years. we create more Alex Smith threads.
that sounds more realistic
Originally posted by taney71:
Lol. I love you man! Take the hate with you wherever you go!@!

haha...but, I really really do like how he is playing right now.

especially the last game. It seemed like that was the first time where he played will in all 4qtrs.

but yeah, all this long term contract scares the b'jesus out of me. Every time I think it was finally time to move on from Alex, someone has brought him back. But hey, at least to his credit, this time he is playing well.

what I just don't want it...it is obvious Harbaugh is game planning to his best interest. I'm sure it is still a process with Alex, so I'm willing to wait alittle longer. I'm just not ready for the thought of giving him a huge contract again, and then next year teams exploiting his weakness he might still have...than Harbaugh can't really fix......then we are stuck again with alot of money tied to Alex.

so I just want to see how he plays the rest of the season....We are for sure going to make the playoffs. So I want to see how he plays in some tough games. If he plays good and bad..then I can deal with it, because that is his first playoff experience......BUT if plays like the Alex we were used to all these years, then I would hope we would not blindly sign him to a huge contract just because some other garbage team thinks he might play well for them. We have too many stars on offense, we shouldn't be desperate to the point of giving him a big long contract if he doesn't really deserve it.
2 more years after this one would be all I would want from him. I like everything that Smith is doing this year except for his downfield arm strength and accuracy. Not talking about the 20 - 30 yarders im talking about the 40 - 50 yarders and I know we dont use those downfield passes too much but we are going to need them eventually. Because of injury his arm is just not as strong as use to be.
Hell no. I've seen enough Alex to know he's not a special QB. Harbaugh is just putting him in great situations. He's just holding the keys until Kap is ready to drive.
Originally posted by Afrikan:
haha...but, I really really do like how he is playing right now.

especially the last game. It seemed like that was the first time where he played will in all 4qtrs.

but yeah, all this long term contract scares the b'jesus out of me. Every time I think it was finally time to move on from Alex, someone has brought him back. But hey, at least to his credit, this time he is playing well.

what I just don't want it...it is obvious Harbaugh is game planning to his best interest. I'm sure it is still a process with Alex, so I'm willing to wait alittle longer. I'm just not ready for the thought of giving him a huge contract again, and then next year teams exploiting his weakness he might still have...than Harbaugh can't really fix......then we are stuck again with alot of money tied to Alex.

so I just want to see how he plays the rest of the season....We are for sure going to make the playoffs. So I want to see how he plays in some tough games. If he plays good and bad..then I can deal with it, because that is his first playoff experience......BUT if plays like the Alex we were used to all these years, then I would hope we would not blindly sign him to a huge contract just because some other garbage team thinks he might play well for them. We have too many stars on offense, we shouldn't be desperate to the point of giving him a big long contract if he doesn't really deserve it.

I understand completely. That's why I think giving him a responible contract over 3-5 years that is very much incentive based isn't as silly. I don't think any Smith supporter wants a 10 year 100 mil contract for him.
No doubt, sign him up!
Originally posted by strickac:
Hell no. I've seen enough Alex to know he's not a special QB. Harbaugh is just putting him in great situations. He's just holding the keys until Kap is ready to drive.



You want to give up the #3 rated passer in the NFL for a guy who doesn't know what to do in the pocket? For a long term project who may or may not work out?
If he can get us to the 2nd-3rd round of the playoffs I say resign him for 2-3 years.
If he keeps playing the way he does, I would give him another 2 years until Kaepernick is ready. If he plays great in those 2 years, we can maybe pull an Eagles and trade Kaepernick to another team for picks/players
Originally posted by 9ersnation:
If he keeps playing the way he does, I would give him another 2 years until Kaepernick is ready. If he plays great in those 2 years, we can maybe pull an Eagles and trade Kaepernick to another team for picks/players

not sure if kap will be sought out like kolb was though. but yeah, anytime you can get picks its always good.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone