Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 589 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Unless he leads us to a Super Bowl and looks like a franchise QB all season long f**k no. Let Condon rape some other team. We got 2 young QBs who will know the offense in 2012 and we should go with 1 of them.
3 years and draft the next up and comer with Kaep, have them duke it out in a couple more yrs...
[ Edited by Magzarillious on Oct 11, 2011 at 3:08 PM ]
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

If he ends up having a very good year the Niners will have to sign him to a multi-year deal. I have to imagine that he would be the hottest QB free-agent on the market. I think, like others, that Alex will stay with the Niners but they will have to offer more than a one-year deal.


THIS.
Originally posted by Magzarillious:
3 years and draft the next up and comer with Kaep, have them duke it out in a couple more yrs...

This.

If he keeps playing at the level he's playing at right now, we would look like the dumbest organization in the league to let him walk. We let him have all of those horrible seasons and growing pains with us to let him walk when everything finally clicks? GTFOH
I unno I say sign him for a longterm deal. Let the young rook Kaep sit on that bench and soak up some sun like Rodgers did under Brett.
Originally posted by GIMMEa6thSHIP:
Originally posted by Magzarillious:
3 years and draft the next up and comer with Kaep, have them duke it out in a couple more yrs...

This.

If he keeps playing at the level he's playing at right now, we would look like the dumbest organization in the league to let him walk. We let him have all of those horrible seasons and growing pains with us to let him walk when everything finally clicks? GTFOH

Yeah we would definitely look stupid to finally let Alex go after he shows that hes actually a decent QB.
10 years 200 MIL.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

No way Smith's agents allows him to sign for anything less than 3 years or possibility even 4.
Originally posted by jimmy49erfan:
Unless he leads us to a Super Bowl and looks like a franchise QB all season long f**k no. Let Condon rape some other team. We got 2 young QBs who will know the offense in 2012 and we should go with 1 of them.

Being young doesn't make you good. Remember Nate Davis or any of the other backup 9er QBs who NinerTalk made into all-pros.
This is a tough one. It would be ideal for him to sign a 1-2 year deal just in case its a fluke season. If he refuses a one or two year deal I want to say let him walk but how long will it take for CK to get up to the standard of a starting NFL QB? I would hate to go back to being crappy at QB.
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by jimmy49erfan:
Unless he leads us to a Super Bowl and looks like a franchise QB all season long f**k no. Let Condon rape some other team. We got 2 young QBs who will know the offense in 2012 and we should go with 1 of them.

Being young doesn't make you good. Remember Nate Davis or any of the other backup 9er QBs who NinerTalk made into all-pros.

No but the coaching makes them good. Id rather see what we have in the guy JH n Baalke traded up for than to see us sign Smith to a LTD. Now if Smith gets us a 6th ring ill eat some crow and wash it down with a tall glass of shut the f**k up. Anything less he is not worth it.
If he plays like he has been through week 9, extend him for 3-4 years, at 10-11 Mil a year.
Originally posted by jimmy49erfan:
No but the coaching makes them good. Id rather see what we have in the guy JH n Baalke traded up for than to see us sign Smith to a LTD. Now if Smith gets us a 6th ring ill eat some crow and wash it down with a tall glass of shut the f**k up. Anything less he is not worth it.

I think it depends on the contract Smith would sign and that is based on him having a good year which looks likely after 5 games.

If we can sign Smith to a 3-5 year deal at 7-10 mil a year I'm thinking that is a smart move especially if a bunch of that is incentive based. What do the 9ers lose with doing that?
lol wow this place is funny.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Sign him to another 1-2 year contract to see if this year wasn't a fluke.

It's not a fluke. With a guy like Alex he has the temperment and personality that needs some feedback, coaching and support. It's the first good HC he has had. What do NoWin and SingleBrainCell know about QB development?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone