The worst grade I can find outside of our own haters is...another hater (everything else is at least a B-) and some dude from NY.
Paul Gutierrez of ESPN Thumbs Down A curious draft for a rebuilding team, to be sure. The Niners drafted three cornerbacks but no inside linebackers. They traded up to select a player at a position that was already addressed in free agency. And they fortified the right side of the offensive line with late picks and Anthony Davis making noise about returning from retirement. Oh, and they drafted a QB in the sixth round. Curious? More like strange.
Bart Hubbuch of the New York Post Grade: C+ A Chip Kelly-coached team went for an Oregon player — big shock — with its top pick, though DeForest Buckner looks like a rare Duck defender with staying power. But they traded up for a guard, then loaded up on injury and character concerns. - See more at: http://www.49erswebzone.com/news/93883-draft-grades-san-francisco-49ers-2016/#sthash.NbSEfMax.dpuf
There are 705 users in the forums
Grade The Draft
Grade The Draft
May 1, 2016 at 6:07 AM
- NCommand
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 123,365
May 1, 2016 at 6:27 AM
- Big_Daddy
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,808
12 picks and I'm really only excited about 2 of them, one of which fell in their laps at 7.
I'm off the Trent wagon his board is often different and he doesn't seem to know when to pull away from his methods to actually get someone to come in and compete. Too many corners. We're just throwing numbers at our secondary now. Sure we might hit but not because I actually felt he made a good pick.
Incomplete grade until I see them on the field but I really want to say C minus. There was supposed to be lots of good players from 32-100 and we got one that only started 7 games in college and of course tore his acl. Not very impressive when we have 12 picks
I'm off the Trent wagon his board is often different and he doesn't seem to know when to pull away from his methods to actually get someone to come in and compete. Too many corners. We're just throwing numbers at our secondary now. Sure we might hit but not because I actually felt he made a good pick.
Incomplete grade until I see them on the field but I really want to say C minus. There was supposed to be lots of good players from 32-100 and we got one that only started 7 games in college and of course tore his acl. Not very impressive when we have 12 picks
[ Edited by Big_Daddy on May 1, 2016 at 6:31 AM ]
May 1, 2016 at 6:50 AM
- 94949er
- Member
- Posts: 737
Well at least we know Trent is getting fired
May 1, 2016 at 7:00 AM
- English
- Moderator
- Posts: 41,473
Originally posted by 94949er:Well at least we know Trent is getting fired
No, we don't. Actually the way he drafted, ie still looking long-term, indicates that he has no fears on that count.
May 1, 2016 at 7:05 AM
- TheXFactor
- Veteran
- Posts: 25,990
B- draft.
Excited to see the competition with our G's this year. Thomas, Martin, Silberman will be in a fight for like 1 spot.
Excited to see the competition with our G's this year. Thomas, Martin, Silberman will be in a fight for like 1 spot.
May 1, 2016 at 7:08 AM
- eastcoast49ersfan
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,112
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:12 picks and I'm really only excited about 2 of them, one of which fell in their laps at 7.
I'm off the Trent wagon his board is often different and he doesn't seem to know when to pull away from his methods to actually get someone to come in and compete. Too many corners. We're just throwing numbers at our secondary now. Sure we might hit but not because I actually felt he made a good pick.
Incomplete grade until I see them on the field but I really want to say C minus. There was supposed to be lots of good players from 32-100 and we got one that only started 7 games in college and of course tore his acl. Not very impressive when we have 12 picks
We only had 3 picks in the first 3 rounds and typically 4th round and later picks don't excite people because they don't amount to anything. If you think we hit on 2 of our first 3 picks, that's not bad.
I would have liked to see us draft an inside linebacker or acquire a future pick or 2, but we knew we weren't going to be able to address every need this offseason.
I really liked the Buckner and Driscoll picks and am fine with the Garnett pick even though I didn't think we should've traded up there. B draft for me.
May 1, 2016 at 7:19 AM
- SanFranFanfrmVa
- Veteran
- Posts: 3,351
If Jeff Driskel hadn't played in that BS offense for Will Muschamp and played in a pro style offense he would've been a much higher pick. This kid has all the tools to be a NFL QB. I like Driskel in the 6th round much better then Hackenberg 2nd round or Connor Cook 3rd round. I truly believe the 49ers targeted Driskel the entire time.
May 1, 2016 at 7:19 AM
- ninerville
- Veteran
- Posts: 277
Originally posted by dj43:Considering this was the first of two rebuilding years, I give it a B+.
Baalke got a bunch of guys for the trenches that will protect the rest of the team while they develop. Some of those guys will still be here in 10 years. Line gets A.
Not disappointed or surprised with all the CBs. Though we already had some young guys in the secondary, there no real standout back there. Redmond and Robinson could be better than any of the current crew. B-
It will take another good draft to put this team back in the playoffs, in the meantime, this draft provides a great foundation.
I am just fine with no skill players on offense. We haven't had a real offensive coach here since Turner left. We may have more than enough offense to compete once Kelly gets a chance to work with them. Our problem is that the previous coaches never used any of the young guys so we have no idea what they can do.
Exactly, perfect call on the offense.. i think he is more than happy at wr...a real offensive coach..he knows what he wants..we have alot of wr...they need a chance
May 1, 2016 at 7:22 AM
- ninerville
- Veteran
- Posts: 277
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:Originally posted by Hangman_52:UDFAs Grades
A+
Devon Cajuste
He has signed a 3 year deal with the 49ers. He has the best hands for a TE we have had since Jones. He is fast and tall and runs great routes. Runs block well for a WR, but needs to gain strength to be an in line TE. The only reason why he wasn't a 3rd round pick is he has a concussion history. I think 3 in the past 2 years. He is a goal line target for sure at 6'4" and has the leaping and box out ability to get the ball. I think he will compete with McDonald for the 3rd TE spot. I would wager That McDonald and now TE Bruce Miller are traded to a run first teams and we will go with Celek, Bell, and Cajuste with Anderson on the PS another year. If I had to compare him to a player I would say he is a Witten type TE.
You think there's a chance Cajuste plays at WR?
Man Bell needs his shot, im indifferent on mcdonalf...he can go...if cajuste pans out....concussions may make him a liability to depend on with the early retirement
May 1, 2016 at 7:28 AM
- ninerville
- Veteran
- Posts: 277
Originally posted by Niners99:Originally posted by SanDiego49er:Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.
Based on what? What you read? If they think Garnett is a Pro Bowl caliber G, it was perfectly fine. We gave up a 4th and a 6th, which are usually stabs in the dark anyways. Low risk move.
And it was seattles guy, hence them picking thr far worse of the best two guards! They had yo fo what they had to do to get a 2 time all american out of the pac 12.....im saying all we gave up was a 4th....great trade when u are building the foundation our GURU OFFENSIVE MINDED coach wants and needs to be successful
[ Edited by ninerville on May 1, 2016 at 7:28 AM ]
May 1, 2016 at 7:36 AM
- harryj
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,002
Originally posted by ninerville:And it was seattles guy, hence them picking thr far worse of the best two guards! They had yo fo what they had to do to get a 2 time all american out of the pac 12.....im saying all we gave up was a 4th....great trade when u are building the foundation our GURU OFFENSIVE MINDED coach wants and needs to be successful
I don't think it was Seattle's guy I think they were going OT all along
We traded up I think because we get the 5th year option
May 1, 2016 at 7:46 AM
- Paul_Hofer
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,090
Originally posted by TheFunkyChicken:
Originally posted by susweel:
Buckner - A, easy pick top 10 pick but probably wanted stanley so had to take the next best option
Garnett - C+, was originally higher on this pick but he is a supbar pass blocker and probably wasn't necessary to trade up. Could have had Whitehair in the 2nd even if Garnett was gone.
ACL CB - F
STICK FIGURE CB - F
Burbury WR - B
the rest of the guys were all F's
Still didn't address OT, RB, WR, ILB with good prospects.
overall grade = F as in F baalke
I gave him a D
I agree with most of what you said, but I think I'm a little more into the 6th round guys than you are.
Driskel I am willing to give Chip the benefit of the doubt on. Until he proves me wrong, I'm going to assume he knows what kind of QB he wants (even if his time in Philly points to the contrary)
Burbridge I kinda like. He seems like he could be an okay 3rd string guy down the road. But it feels too much like Patton to me. We waited and took a just okay guy when we really needed to target a guy that could potentially start. There were some pretty good guys that went in the mid rounds we could have used. Or even just a round earlier we could have gotten Listenbee or the other Mike Thomas.... Another year, another ho hum warm body at WR.....
Kelvin Taylor could be good. But again, there were other guys I liked more. Kenneth Dixon was one of my favorite RBs in the draft, especially for Chip's system. And he went SO LATE... And Perkins.... Even at that spot I would have preferred Lasco...
Am I the only one that feels like we really needed some play makers on offense and didn't even try to get any?
You're not the only one. I think sometimes that I must have dreamt last season's offensive debacle. 14 avg. OMG, we're going to run, run, run, punt. NFL defenses can stop run-only teams.
May 1, 2016 at 7:55 AM
- Paul_Hofer
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,090
Originally posted by pdizo916:
We drafted 3 corners, which we didn't need any of them. 2 of them have MAJOR red flags: one coming off an ACL injury while the other one didn't play at all in 2015 because of behavior issues. (aldon smith) Yet, we spent high draft picks on these players. And on top of that, we didn't address MLB and NT. If we didn't trade up to get Garnett, we would have had the chance to draft Billings. Instead of Kenneth Dixon, we picked the before mentioned CB. Instead of Scooby Wright, we drafted another CB. Baalke deserves to be let go.
However, I will say that I do like the Garnett pick (even though we traded up to get him), Buckner pick, Blair pick, and Burbridge pick. So overall, I give this draft a D+
Agreed. Those defending the 3 CBs picks must then be criticizing Baalke's earlier picks of Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Ward, etc.
May 1, 2016 at 8:00 AM
- Derelict
- Veteran
- Posts: 58
The posts below pretty much summed up all that I was gonna say or was thinking. I cut some of the posts at the end so that the theme remained the same.
Get some young competition for Trent Brown so that he has someone pushing him.
Loser of the battle becomes hopefully a swing tackle. Cooper would make a large guard.
Would love a ILB for competition, but no point one if they couldn't beat out Hodges as a developmental ILB and would cause us to miss out on a higher ceiling prospect who could knock a lesser player off the team.
Would love to see what we have at WR now that there will be more targets available.
Would love to evaluate Mike Davis running behind an offensive line that blocks at average/above average level.
Originally posted by BoldRedandGold:
Our WR's are impossible to evaluate because of the piss poor oline play, the piss poor qb play, the lack of any running game after hyde was hurt and the inability of our coaches to force feed anyone other than boldin the ball. Not to knock boldin who was a great player but he needed significantly less targets and we needed to force the ball to faster shiftier playmakers and ditch the veteran first philosophy we have always embraced.
We will improve the oline with these picks. The dline should be better. The slot corner should also be better. The only glaring need on this team now is a partner in crime for bowman and maybe another pass rusher depending on how our guys develop. The qb play should improve just as a factor of chips scheme and improve even more if kap is gone and not limiting the playbook.
Originally posted by dj43:
What is curious is this assessment.
Yes, the OL was addressed in FA but there were still all kinds of question marks. If Beadles can play back to his former form and Garnett plays like everyone expects him to do, the center of the line, with Kilgore coming back, will set up nicely for Kelly's inside power game. Having Tiller available as a backup is a plus. I don't believe Anthony Davis can be trusted and that is reflected in the way Baalke drafted. The rest of the group are unproven/untested and may or may not prove to be starter grade. So...
As to the cornerbacks, none of the 49er cornerbacks graded very well last season:
Ward #35 overall in the league but may wind up at safety
Brock #36 starter grade but not special
Johnson #55 - showed promise in the late games but, again, not special
Acker #70 - not starter grade
Reaser and Cromartie in limited time graded at the same level as Acker.
So tell me again why it was not wise to try to improve the cornerback situation?
ILB would be nice but it would have been a reach to take anybody much better than what we have and then pass on a better player somewhere else.
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Eh? Hard to understand that assessment tbh...it is coming from a Raider fan..sooo......
Zane Beadles hardly addresses the G position. He's 30 years old and is coming off a down year. Hope he rebounds and has a good year, but him on the roster doesn't stop you from grabbing the best run blocker in the draft at a position of need. Kelly's run game depends on it.
Outside of the first 2 rounds, there wasn't a ILB I would have taken until late in the draft. The CBs taken were more talented and better value.
The mid-round OL picks were for depth and development, not to replace Anthony Davis. We've already done that with Trent Brown, who was an excellent find in the 7th rd last year.
Driskel was well worth a 6th rd pick based on his Senior performance and athletic traits. Don't see why that's a curious pick, I'm pretty sure everyone here expected us to take a late-round QB to develop if Kap wasn't traded.
Originally posted by dj43:
Considering this was the first of two rebuilding years, I give it a B .
Baalke got a bunch of guys for the trenches that will protect the rest of the team while they develop. Some of those guys will still be here in 10 years. Line gets A.
Not disappointed or surprised with all the CBs. Though we already had some young guys in the secondary, there no real standout back there. Redmond and Robinson could be better than any of the current crew. B-
It will take another good draft to put this team back in the playoffs, in the meantime, this draft provides a great foundation.
I am just fine with no skill players on offense. We haven't had a real offensive coach here since Turner left. We may have more than enough offense to compete once Kelly gets a chance to work with them. Our problem is that the previous coaches never used any of the young guys so we have no idea what they can do.
Get some young competition for Trent Brown so that he has someone pushing him.
Loser of the battle becomes hopefully a swing tackle. Cooper would make a large guard.
Would love a ILB for competition, but no point one if they couldn't beat out Hodges as a developmental ILB and would cause us to miss out on a higher ceiling prospect who could knock a lesser player off the team.
Would love to see what we have at WR now that there will be more targets available.
Would love to evaluate Mike Davis running behind an offensive line that blocks at average/above average level.
May 1, 2016 at 8:30 AM
- Big_Daddy
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,808
Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:We only had 3 picks in the first 3 rounds and typically 4th round and later picks don't excite people because they don't amount to anything. If you think we hit on 2 of our first 3 picks, that's not bad.
I would have liked to see us draft an inside linebacker or acquire a future pick or 2, but we knew we weren't going to be able to address every need this offseason.
I really liked the Buckner and Driscoll picks and am fine with the Garnett pick even though I didn't think we should've traded up there. B draft for me.
I liked those picks for sure. I'm just not giving baalke credit for Buckner when he fell in our laps