-
NinerSickness
- Member
-
- Posts: 8,897
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by NinerSickness:

It's gonna be a long decade.
Better pick another team. Theres still time.
Am I only allowed to stick w/ my team if I'm a rose-coloured-glasses homer?
The picks they made were actually pretty good, but unless
Jeff Driskel shocks the world, they're still in the toilet from a QB standpoint.
-
lamontb
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 33,652
I gave it a C
-
DonnieDarko
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 67,096
Originally posted by Hangman_52:
UDFAs Grades
A+
Devon Cajuste
He has signed a 3 year deal with the 49ers. He has the best hands for a TE we have had since Jones. He is fast and tall and runs great routes. Runs block well for a WR, but needs to gain strength to be an in line TE. The only reason why he wasn't a 3rd round pick is he has a concussion history. I think 3 in the past 2 years. He is a goal line target for sure at 6'4" and has the leaping and box out ability to get the ball. I think he will compete with McDonald for the 3rd TE spot. I would wager That McDonald and now TE Bruce Miller are traded to a run first teams and we will go with Celek, Bell, and Cajuste with Anderson on the PS another year. If I had to compare him to a player I would say he is a Witten type TE.
You think there's a chance Cajuste plays at WR?
-
SanDiego49er
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 52,536
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by NinerSickness:

It's gonna be a long decade.
Better pick another team. Theres still time.
Am I only allowed to stick w/ my team if I'm a rose-coloured-glasses homer?
The picks they made were actually pretty good, but unless Jeff Driskel shocks the world, they're still in the toilet from a QB standpoint.
Baalke and York suck.....

It is what it is. Yeah I still like the team but I know what we are with these 2 clowns.
-
KID9R
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 3,131
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by NinerSickness:

It's gonna be a long decade.
Better pick another team. Theres still time.
Am I only allowed to stick w/ my team if I'm a rose-coloured-glasses homer?
The picks they made were actually pretty good, but unless Jeff Driskel shocks the world, they're still in the toilet from a QB standpoint.
What was the available QB you wanted during the draft that you feel would've been our savior?
-
49ers808
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 16,883
Originally posted by BoldRedandGold:
This.
I dont really see how anyone could say this was a negative draft outside of the 3 wasted corner picks. We got 2 starters that will vastly improve our team in round 1. That alone makes this draft at least a C. We also grabbed more oline help which is the biggest weakness on this team followed by more guys to take the pressure off lynch when hes rushing the passer.
Our wrs are impossible to evaluate because of the piss poor oline play, the piss poor qb play, the lack on any running game after hyde was hurt and the inability of our coaches to force feed anyone other than boldin the ball. Not to knock boldin who was a great player but he needed significantly less targets and we needed to force the ball to faster shiftier playmakers and ditch the veteran first philosophy we have always embraced.
We will improve the oline with these picks. The dline should be better. The slot corner should also be better. The only glaring need on this team now is a partner in crime for bowman and maybe another pass rusher depending on how our guys develop. The qb play should improve just as a factor of chips scheme and improve even more if kap is gone and not limiting the playbook.
Solid B. Would have been an A if we found another diamond like borland who would actually stick it out.
I agree with everything you said except the CB comment. How do you know they are wasted picks already? Two of them were widely viewed as 1st round talent if it weren't for injury and character respectively. The other one tested through the roof and could be a ST ace, what do you expect from a late 7th rounder?
-
49ers808
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 16,883
It's funny reading all the people crying about the CB picks. Brock is our #1 CB, let that sink in. I truly believe that BOTH Redmond and Robinson has the talent to be our #1 and #2 corners by next year, with Redmond potentially claiming the #2 spot this year since nobody we had on the roster did that last year.
-
Jd925
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,286
Disclaimer: This is based on my very limited research and info on these players.
Great overall strategy. Shore up the trenches on DL and OL. Many picks are from top conferences (SEC/Pac12). Improved the secondary. Didn't focus on skill positions because 49ers are pretty solid there. These are grades based on draft position:
A : Buckner. Can't really go wrong at this spot. Will be a force with sacks and QB pressure, will bat down balls and good on edge against run. First-day starter.
A- : Garnett. Top interior lineman. Has some nasty in him. First-day starter.
A- : Redmond. Pros: Natural cover corner. Quick and fast (4.3-4.4 range, top range short shuttle, vertical average). Less than 50% completion rating and only allowed one touchdown in seven games. Cons: May not have been matched with the best receivers. Missed quite a few tackles, but in a tough SEC. Some risk after ACL recovery.
First-day starter at RCB
(Note: I was looking at a trade for MacKenzie Alexander in the 50's, but at this spot Redmond was a great pick)
B+: Robinson: Pros: Natural football player. Fast and tall. Can match up with WR 1's. Held Mike Evans to 50yds. Cons: Limited play. Off-field issues. A lot of unknowns. Had him as a late-round sleeper pick.
He may contend for the backup LCB and may have more natural skills than Dontae Johnson. ( I also liked Juston Burris taken a bit earlier in the 4th.)
B+: Ronald Blair: Pros: Incredible production. Versatile. Great strength. (top reps in Bench) Cons: Small school.
Provides more depth at DL. Had him on my radar because of the great production.
B+: Theus: Pros: Captain. SEC. Started 40+ games and played various positions. Versatile. Cons: Not that athletic? Questionable strength.
Can provide good OL competition and depth.
B: Cooper: Pros: SEC. Two year starter. Good leader. Versatile. Cons. Not that athletic.
Can provide good OL competition and depth.
B: Driskel: Pros: Very athletic. Sub 4.5 40. Played in good competition at SEC. Cons: Avg. Accuracy. Throws at receivers instead of leading. Not great under pressure.
Can provide good QB competition and depth. Can develop into very good QB in this system. (Was hoping OLB Dadi Nicolas would drop here. Would have traded up but KC got him.)
A: Taylor: Pros: Young. Great vision and natural running back instincts. Never fumbled! Has the genes. Faced tough SEC. Broke Emmitt Smith's all-time records in HS in Florida. Cons: Not super explosive like his father and lacks power. Bit small.
Provides good depth. Can work his way to the #2 behind Hyde. (A lot of good running backs in this draft. I like SEC backs that can perform without the best OL. Keith Marshall was there and can fly..can also catch. Barber another young SEC back I like too went undrafted. Taylor was the best pure runner though.)
A-: Burnbridge: Pros: Very productive. Good hands. Wins battles. Cons: Didn't get great separation. More of a possession receiver.
Provides good WR depth in place of Boldin. I give the edge to Smelter to take over Boldin's spot.
B: Prince: Pros: Workout warrior. Super fast. Super strong. Can jump: Cons: Small conference. Avg. production.
Project, but has the tools. Practice Squad.
(Wanted Scooby Wright III here. Some compared him to Zach Thomas. Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year in 2014 and almost went undrafted! Not the best athlete, but a playmaker.)
Overall very good draft: A-/B+
Wished they got an OLB.... (Dadi Nicolas late or somebody.) Otherwise they got three first-year starters, depth in the trenches and corners and took some very good players at the skilled positions in the later rounds. It worked out very well. That's how you build a team.
-
Niners99
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 44,384
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by NinerSickness:

It's gonna be a long decade.
Better pick another team. Theres still time.
Am I only allowed to stick w/ my team if I'm a rose-coloured-glasses homer?
The picks they made were actually pretty good, but unless Jeff Driskel shocks the world, they're still in the toilet from a QB standpoint.
If youre going to be negative, wait for the results, not the perception of the draft class. For all you know there are 4 future pro bowlers in our class this year.
Looking at draft history, if you come away with 1 elite player, and 2 solid starters, you had a nice draft. Buckner is almost a slam dunk, and between our next 4-5 picks, the odds we get a couple solid starters is pretty high. Garnett was thought of as the safest bet to at least be decent among all G. Hes an NFL ready stud run blocker.
We have a new coach, and a young, talented team. Chip Kelly is perfect for leading this type of roster. If we start 3-9, then call them a pile of crap. But right now making that assumption just looks like pouting over the Niners not drafting the guys you wanted.
[ Edited by Niners99 on May 1, 2016 at 2:14 AM ]
-
paulk205
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,080
I don't letter grade. I also find the collective psychosis about "reaching" and "draft steals" bizarre to say the least. We are "grading" what GMs do against what a bunch of draftniks think? Who cares? The proof in the pudding will be when these players hit the field. We all like to repeat that "it takes three years to have an informed opinion about drafted players" and then we get aneurysms because "we picked this chap at #37 when Kiper's board had him as a late third". We got a player - let's hope he produces. What we can do is to like or not the GM's strategy. I mostly roll with it, although I sometimes would like us to try a bit more for immediate help than for future projects. And the whole Baalke ACL strategy always makes me nervous, especially when it involved higher rounders.
Anyway, I mostly like what Baalke tried to do this year. I can't give him credit for taking my personal draft crush and BPA at that moment with Buckner. It was a no-brainer, and I'm happy he also saw it like that. I loved going aggressively to draft his own perceived best interior lineman of the draft. Again: I don't care what draftniks say, we needed help in the interior of the OL for years and we got our player. Hopefully he produces. Then the rest of the draft was all position flooding at CB and OT (like last year at TE). I like this approach too: hopefully one each of those picks will stick in their respective positions.
If the result of this draft is to get two quality starters (Buckner, Garnett) and two more solid players (hopefully starters) at OT and CB, and perhaps some depth, then this will be a great result. I grade that, hm, let's see: a Q++
-
davidboutte
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 923
We used 6 picks for a gaurd and 3 corners? As usual Baalke confuses me. Buckner, Garnett 2 building blocks. Hope they live up to their draft status and 2-3 more come thru
-
pdizo916
- Member
-
- Posts: 38,241
We drafted 3 corners, which we didn't need any of them. 2 of them have MAJOR red flags: one coming off an ACL injury while the other one didn't play at all in 2015 because of behavior issues. (aldon smith) Yet, we spent high draft picks on these players. And on top of that, we didn't address MLB and NT. If we didn't trade up to get Garnett, we would have had the chance to draft Billings. Instead of Kenneth Dixon, we picked the before mentioned CB. Instead of Scooby Wright, we drafted another CB. Baalke deserves to be let go.
However, I will say that I do like the Garnett pick (even though we traded up to get him), Buckner pick, Blair pick, and Burbridge pick. So overall, I give this draft a D+
[ Edited by pdizo916 on May 1, 2016 at 2:53 AM ]
-
PacTiger
- Member
-
- Posts: 30,146
A "B" grade for me. Our o line and d line were collectively bad last year (starters). This draft was a reflection of the overhaul that I felt is necessary. We have too many holes to address in one draft.
We now have a young base of players that will have a chance to shine. kilgore, Silberman, Thomas, Garnett, Trent Brown and the rest of the o line pick ups should push Devey, Martin, and pears away from playing. In my eyes, that's the goal.
-
Judge82Dredd
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,149
I give a D but it was actually a C-.
The 1st round pick was horrendous we picked the bigger boom or bust prospect of the entire draft(Buckner) and got a injured corner in the second.
-
DrGonzo00
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 255
I gave it a C. Bruckner will be a beast who won't be a showy stats guy but is necessary in the 3-4. Nailed that pick. Garnett...some love him and thought he was one of the best, if not the best, OL but of course, there are questions as to whether he'll fit in with the scheme. And while he played RG, I'm sure we'll move him to LT or somewhere completely out of position because we just love doing that when we draft OL.
Redmond and Robinson...I just don't get Baalke's fascination with A) injured players and B) CBs. CB depth is nice, but we've found gems later in the draft and CB is kind of a dime a dozen position. Plus you took a guy who has legit off the field concerns, so the whole "win with class" thing goes out the window. Cooper could be a sleeper, Theus needs to work on his body bigtime but if Boone did it, so can he. I really like the Kelvin Taylor pick and think he'll surprise.