Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 573 users in the forums

Grade The Draft

Browse 49ers books and videos

Grade The Draft

I grade it a Meh.

Buckner was a great pick. Moving up for Garnett was ok. Redmond and Robinson picks in consecutive rounds was a head scratcher. Liked the Blair pickup. The Theus and Cooper picks were solid if unspectacular. I think we waited too late to address the offensive skill positions, but was pleased with the Burbridge pick, the other two are long term projects. And another CB in the 7th, Could have gone in several other directions.

Overall, the draft netted a couple of solid players in position to possibly start immediately. The others have decent potential, but also have a good chance of flopping.
UDFAs Grades

A+
Devon Cajuste
He has signed a 3 year deal with the 49ers. He has the best hands for a TE we have had since Jones. He is fast and tall and runs great routes. Runs block well for a WR, but needs to gain strength to be an in line TE. The only reason why he wasn't a 3rd round pick is he has a concussion history. I think 3 in the past 2 years. He is a goal line target for sure at 6'4" and has the leaping and box out ability to get the ball. I think he will compete with McDonald for the 3rd TE spot. I would wager That McDonald and now TE Bruce Miller are traded to a run first teams and we will go with Celek, Bell, and Cajuste with Anderson on the PS another year. If I had to compare him to a player I would say he is a Witten type TE.

A+
Jay Fanika
He should have been drafted in the 5th and I am surprised he wasn't. He was signed to play OLB and will kick Lemonier out of the rotation and most likely off the team. He needs to lose about 15lbs. I really love his attitude.

B
Lenny Jones
Another OLB who gets to the QB. Perfect size and speed. Just from a smaller school and did not play against elite competition.

C
Kevin Anderson
Another OLB with size and speed but is more of a coverage guy who can sometimes get tot he QB. Also another Stanford graduate who moves just down the road. He will compete for the PS.

B
Bryce Treggs
A smallish WR who runs fast as heck. Maybe a special team guy. I am sure all you Cal fans know him way better than me.

INC
Demetrius Cherry
a 6'6" 300 lb DE. No idea about him at all

INC
Jered Bell
A 6' 210lbs FS/SS who ran a 4.4 at Colorodo's pro day. Can't see much on him and haven't really seen him play. I hope this is someone who is going to be a special teamer and that we trade Bethea. With Reid, Tartt, Ward, and McCray Bethea is redundant and nonathletic.

F
John Lunsford
a Kicker who can kick it far but inaccurate. A camp foot.
[ Edited by Hangman_52 on Apr 30, 2016 at 8:40 PM ]
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Originally posted by TheFunkyChicken:
Originally posted by jrg:
ESPN:

San Francisco 49ers

Thumbs down. A curious draft for a rebuilding team, to be sure. The Niners drafted three cornerbacks but no inside linebackers. They traded up to select a player at a position that was already addressed in free agency. And they fortified the right side of the offensive line with late picks and Anthony Davismaking noise about returning from retirement. Oh, and they drafted a QB in the sixth round. Curious? More like strange. -- Paul Gutierrez



Hard to argue with that assessment....

Eh? Hard to understand that assessment tbh...it is coming from a Raider fan..sooo......

Zane Beadles hardly addresses the G position. He's 30 years old and is coming off a down year. Hope he rebounds and has a good year, but him on the roster doesn't stop you from grabbing the best run blocker in the draft at a position of need. Kelly's run game depends on it.

Outside of the first 2 rounds, there wasn't a ILB I would have taken until late in the draft. The CBs taken were more talented and better value.

The mid-round OL picks were for depth and development, not to replace Anthony Davis. We've already done that with Trent Brown, who was an excellent find in the 7th rd last year.

Driskel was well worth a 6th rd pick based on his Senior performance and athletic traits. Don't see why that's a curious pick, I'm pretty sure everyone here expected us to take a late-round QB to develop if Kap wasn't traded.
Best opinion I have read all day.
[ Edited by Baylor on Apr 30, 2016 at 8:45 PM ]
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Originally posted by niners94:
Originally posted by dj43:
I believe the lack of another ILB will be offset by a very strong DL rotation that may often include 4 down linemen. If Ian comes back close to form, we will have a very good, very deep front 4. In that case, Bowman can roam.

Would be great. Whilhoite can't cover at all and Hodges has potential but I'm not sure he's good enough.

It's possible all we need at LB next to Bowman is someone who can handle 1st and 2nd down. Then on 3rd down bring in Tartt in a hybrid LB/S role.

That would be a very good option, especially if a couple of the new CBs turn out to be as good as their clippings say they are. Tartt playing the Polomalu role would be fun to watch.

The more I think about the moves of defense today the more I like the draft. If you have a very strong front line, you don't have to worry about needing two ILBs because the RB isn't going to get through the LOS. I could easily see us using a 6 or 7 man rotation on the front with 4 down linemen much of the time, especially if Blair turns out to be the pressure rusher he was in college.
Originally posted by fordy9erfan:
A+++ NINERS didn't trade Kaepernick!!
This is my least favorite part of the draft
This draft just reminds me we haven't hit rock bottom yet. We have a lot of getting worse to do before getting better.
For me, it was an A+++ after the 1st round. Going into the draft I wanted just to solidify both sides of our line. I was OK with Redmond at 3rd.I also like the Blair, Taylor and the WR and OT picks. But then I was scratching my head with the Robinson and the Prince picks. I thought our secondary is young and has some promise and just needs to develop. So why add so many? I was hoping to get an ILB where I thought needs some upgrade. I was good with Driskell pick. OVERALL grade for me on paper with all the players available at the time. B-
Originally posted by SleezyT916:
Originally posted by susweel:
Buckner - A, easy pick top 10 pick but probably wanted stanley so had to take the next best option


Garnett - C+, was originally higher on this pick but he is a supbar pass blocker and probably wasn't necessary to trade up. Could have had Whitehair in the 2nd even if Garnett was gone.



ACL CB - F

STICK FIGURE CB - F


Burbury WR - B


the rest of the guys were all F's


Still didn't address OT, RB, WR, ILB with good prospects.


overall grade = F as in F baalke

Dude is all you do talk crap ?

you must be new here.
Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.
Originally posted by NinerSickness:


It's gonna be a long decade.

Better pick another team. Theres still time.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.

Based on what? What you read? If they think Garnett is a Pro Bowl caliber G, it was perfectly fine. We gave up a 4th and a 6th, which are usually stabs in the dark anyways. Low risk move.
No point in "grading" the draft. We have no idea how these college players are going to do in the NFL. We see that year after year.

I like all the picks. My biggest disappointment is that we didn't pick up a higher rated running back. No, it didn't unfold as I expected, not that it matters.

And there could still be trades coming.

I think it's an exciting time. There are so many young players on this team. Hopefully they can get coached up and really make some strides as a group.
  • KID9R
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,131
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.

I don't think he panicked because we was correct in thinking that the Seahawks wanted a guard. But I agree about Ogbah. It's close but I do prefer the combination of Ogbah and Connor McGovern over Garnett and Blair.
Originally posted by KID9R:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.

I don't think he panicked because we was correct in thinking that the Seahawks wanted a guard. But I agree about Ogbah. It's close but I do prefer the combination of Ogbah and Connor McGovern over Garnett and Blair.

Ogbah is better than Garnett at that spot for sure.
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.

Based on what? What you read? If they think Garnett is a Pro Bowl caliber G, it was perfectly fine. We gave up a 4th and a 6th, which are usually stabs in the dark anyways. Low risk move.

Garnett was the 77th player on Mel Kipers board.....
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone