49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 939 users in the forums

Grade The Draft

Browse 49ers books and videos

Grade The Draft

Originally posted by 9moon:
BUCKNER - in my eyeas (all year) isn't a top 10 player, so I would look at this pick as a reach, tho he is a good player = B

GARNETT - I just believe that he woulda been there with our own 37th pick, and if he wasn't then Whitehair coulda been the one = B

the rest are just pure C = CONFUSE!!

A reach? Not a top 10 player? OK enough. You aren't serious.
Originally posted by Lutch57:
And Mel Kiper is the worst analyst out there. He's really bad.

You never know with Guards though. Whitehair was a steal, IMO. Garnett was widely considered a mid-late 2nd rounder.
Originally posted by strickac:
You never know with Guards though. Whitehair was a steal, IMO. Garnett was widely considered a mid-late 2nd rounder.

The Bears got great value with Whitehair in the 2nd. He was probably the most versatile lineman in the draft, projecting well to any of the interior spots. He's more of a finesse blocker than Garnett. I think Kelly/Baalke preferred the guy who was going to be an absolute mauler in the run game. I think his pass pro issues will be mitigated by Kelly's quick strike passing game.
Originally posted by 9moon:
BUCKNER - in my eyeas (all year) isn't a top 10 player, so I would look at this pick as a reach, tho he is a good player = B

A reach???

Overall B-

Round 1: Pick 7 - Oregon DL DeForest Buckner
A+ expected pick, starts day1, fits a need, should be a game changer, knows the system

Round 1: Pick 28 (acquired via trade with the Kansas City Chiefs) - Stanford G Joshua Garnett
B+ expected pick, starts day1, fits a need, possible slight reach, can he switch to the right side

Round 3: Pick 5 (68th overall) - Mississippi State CB Will Redmond
B- should start at nickel (if Ward does move back), fits a need, good value if healthy, must work on tackling

Round 4: Pick 35 (133rd overall) – compensatory - LSU CB Rashard Robinson
F mental case, hasn't played in 2 years, overload at position, wasted pick IMO should've been a C or NT (Westerman or Reader)

Round 5: Pick 3 (142nd overall) – from San Diego - Appalachian State DL Ronald Blair
B+ expected need based on rotational talent on roster, should play/rotate day 1, great value if he can match up to NFL talent, don't make him something he's not

Round 5: Pick 6 (145th overall) - Georgia OL John Theus
C pick based on need, should offer emergency security, cheaper and younger compared to Pears, marginal talent

Round 5: Pick 37 (174th overall) – compensatory - Ole Miss OL Fahn Cooper
C+ pick based on need, should offer emergency security, cheaper and younger compared to Pears, better talent compared to Theus, possible starter

Round 6: Pick 32 (207th overall) – from Denver - Louisiana QB Jeff Driskel
C+ 3rd string QB, great athlete, probably not in our long term plans, takes over for Thad or goes to the PS

Round 6: Pick 36 (211th overall) – compensatory - Florida RB Kelvin Taylor
B somewhat expected pick, great bloodlines, above average talent, could push for the #2 RB spot, pushes lesser talent off the roster

Round 6: Pick 38 (213th overall) – compensatory - Michigan State WR Aaron Burbridge
B great value, pushes lesser talent off the roster, solid hands, possibly a poor mans Boldin...?

Round 7: Pick 28 (249th overall) - from Kansas City - Western Kentucky CB Prince Charles Iworah
C+ fantastic athlete, overload at position, what will his position be, probably goes to the PS until we purge more talent


Still have giant question marks at OLB, ILB, NT, backup C, and of course QB. If all goes to plan...the OL, DB, WR, RB, most of the DL shouldn't need to be touched going into next year. I would prefer we leave the major skill positions alone and let the players mature a year, before we go back into looking for replacements. If need be tap into free agency and find some proven vets to fill 1-2 spots.
[ Edited by jreff22 on May 1, 2016 at 2:41 PM ]
Originally posted by jreff22:
Overall B-

Round 1: Pick 7 - Oregon DL DeForest Buckner
A+ expected pick, starts day1, fits a need, should be a game changer, knows the system

Round 1: Pick 28 (acquired via trade with the Kansas City Chiefs) - Stanford G Joshua Garnett
B+ expected pick, starts day1, fits a need, possible slight reach, can he switch to the right side

Round 3: Pick 5 (68th overall) - Mississippi State CB Will Redmond
B- should start at nickel (if Ward does move back), fits a need, good value if healthy, must work on tackling

Round 4: Pick 35 (133rd overall) – compensatory - LSU CB Rashard Robinson
F mental case, hasn't played in 2 years, overload at position, wasted pick IMO should've been a C or NT (Westerman or Reader)

Round 5: Pick 3 (142nd overall) – from San Diego - Appalachian State DL Ronald Blair
B+ expected need based on rotational talent on roster, should play/rotate day 1, great value if he can match up to NFL talent, don't make him something he's not

Round 5: Pick 6 (145th overall) - Georgia OL John Theus
C pick based on need, should offer emergency security, cheaper and younger compared to Pears, marginal talent

Round 5: Pick 37 (174th overall) – compensatory - Ole Miss OL Fahn Cooper
C+ pick based on need, should offer emergency security, cheaper and younger compared to Pears, better talent compared to Theus, possible starter

Round 6: Pick 32 (207th overall) – from Denver - Louisiana QB Jeff Driskel
C+ 3rd string QB, great athlete, probably not in our long term plans, takes over for Thad or goes to the PS

Round 6: Pick 36 (211th overall) – compensatory - Florida RB Kelvin Taylor
B somewhat expected pick, great bloodlines, above average talent, could push for the #2 RB spot, pushes lesser talent off the roster

Round 6: Pick 38 (213th overall) – compensatory - Michigan State WR Aaron Burbridge
B great value, pushes lesser talent off the roster, solid hands, possibly a poor mans Boldin...?

Round 7: Pick 28 (249th overall) - from Kansas City - Western Kentucky CB Prince Charles Iworah
C+ fantastic athlete, overload at position, what will his position be, probably goes to the PS until we purge more talent


Still have giant question marks at OLB, ILB, NT, backup C, and of course QB. If all goes to plan...the OL, DB, WR, RB, most of the DL shouldn't need to be touched going into next year. I would prefer we leave the major skill positions alone and let the players mature a year, before we go back into looking for replacements. If need be tap into free agency and find some proven vets to fill 1-2 spots.

Good break down. As I've said in previous posts, I'm ok with this draft. I guess what bothers me is every pick after Buckner could realistically have been at least 1 round later.

I can say with moderate confidence that Garnett would have been there at the top of the 2nd. So with the 4th they gave away, they could have picked up Joshua Perry. I really think 1st the end of the season, Perry will be considered a steal. He would have been a very promising option at ILB.

Overall all, I LOVE that they built the trenches, I just feel they overpaid a touch.
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by 9moon:
BUCKNER - in my eyeas (all year) isn't a top 10 player, so I would look at this pick as a reach, tho he is a good player = B

A reach???


dafuq
  • Rascal
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,926
Originally posted by English:
Originally posted by 94949er:
Well at least we know Trent is getting fired

No, we don't. Actually the way he drafted, ie still looking long-term, indicates that he has no fears on that count.

Actually, that is not how it works in real life. If the 9ers lose 12 games in this coming season like many have predicted here, trust me there will be a very high chance Baalke will get fired. May I remind you our last HC was a joker by the name of Tomsula and if we can't even win more games than last year, oh yea it will be a big deal. The fans will erupt or let's just say the boo birds will be back out in full force. The first question that will be asked is what has Baalke done to give the 9ers a better season after last year's total disaster? The answer of course is a resounding nothing. With close to $60 mil of cap space, he basically just mailed it in and went fishing. As for the draft, started off well, but it soon turned into the usual train wreck. Again he totally neglected the offensive skilled positions. You know why? Cos he knows full well he is totally incapable of drafting offensive players. Oh yea and Jeff Driskel? So, I guess that's our next franchise QB huh? LOL. So, all in all, just not enough impact players that will be able to make a difference to help the 9ers win more games this year.
  • Nuns
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,301
Really? Easy. A. Arguably the best player in the draft at 7 and a desperately needed offensive line upgrade? Everything else is gravy. Start with the trenches, love it. Our last resurgence was due to offensive line upgrades, so will this one.
Originally posted by English:
Originally posted by 9moon:
BUCKNER - in my eyeas (all year) isn't a top 10 player, so I would look at this pick as a reach, tho he is a good player = B

GARNETT - I just believe that he woulda been there with our own 37th pick, and if he wasn't then Whitehair coulda been the one = B

the rest are just pure C = CONFUSE!!

A reach? Not a top 10 player? OK enough. You aren't serious.

Labeled by most draft experts as the "best overall player in the draft."

Sam Monson
Sam Monson‏ @PFF_Sam

I don't have the biggest hands, but starting from the same spot on L, DeForest Buckner's hands would hit the R mark



81% of the voters graded a C or higher. Better signs of things to come.
Originally posted by strickac:
Nice assessment. The only thing I disagree with is the projection that Taylor beats out Harris. I think Harris was our best RB after Hyde last season and he has enough twitch to excel in Chip's offense.

Gaskins and Draughn are terrible fits and I think they'll get cut. Davis and Hayne have a battle on their hands also. They'll need to play much faster in year two.

If we go with 4 RBs, I project:

Hyde - Harris - Davis - Taylor

Taylor has a shot at moving up later in the year if he can pass protect.

This is exactly what I have too. I don't have Taylor beating Harris but backing him up. Agreed.
Originally posted by SanFranFanfrmVa:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Keeping with the context that this is year 1 or 2 of the rebuild (depending on your perspective) and their plan and execution, I'd say B+. The "flashy" players will come next year. You can't assess the skill positions until the lines are built and the systems are installed. Period.


IMHO, Baalke/Kelly/Gamble did it right.


Overall Assessment: Overall, no doubt the goal and outcome was to rebuild the lines in year 1 or 2 of this rebuild (depending on your perspective) and use that as a barometer to see what we have at the skill positions for next year. We added more depth and specific-skill position players for our systems from the move-TEs, to the slot WR and CB to the 2-down NT and like-skilled QB's.

The average number of starters from every draft class is 2.3 so a GM reaches for 3. We got 2 right out of the gate with DeForrest Buckner and Joshua Garnett. These are your "impact players."

In addition to them, remember, we're expected to run nickel/dime 60-70% of the time (common in the NFL now) with heavy DL rotations. Therefore, other defenders who could play "starter" roles for us include Ronald Blair, Demetrius Cherry & Alex Balducci (DE rotation with AA & Buckner), Rashard Robinson over Dontae Johnson or he beats out Tramaine Brock on the other side and we go "longer" and Will Redmond (if healthy) or Prince Charles Iworah (ST/returner/gunner) beat out Keith Reaser at the slot CB spot and then on offense, Kelvin Taylor beats out DuJuan Harris as the RB2, Devon Cajuste beats out Bruce Miller as the move-TE and Aaron Burbridge beats out Bruce Ellington at the YWR. Next year, I think more fans will be happy as you can expect more targets for the flashy "skill positions."


Also Ncommand it gives Kelly time to see what he has at QB and a year to develop Driskell. We're simply not a playoff team this year with this schedule. I have no expectations for this team outside of learning Kelly's system and developing the young players. Going into the next offseason we'll know our strengths and weakness and plan accordingly. Not to mention a boat load of cap space that could only get bigger if CK,Brooks and Bethea are no longer on the roster. Next years free agent class looks to be really good.

Yes sir!
Originally posted by NCommand:
The worst grade I can find outside of our own haters is...another hater (everything else is at least a B-) and some dude from NY.

Paul Gutierrez of ESPN Thumbs Down A curious draft for a rebuilding team, to be sure. The Niners drafted three cornerbacks but no inside linebackers. They traded up to select a player at a position that was already addressed in free agency. And they fortified the right side of the offensive line with late picks and Anthony Davis making noise about returning from retirement. Oh, and they drafted a QB in the sixth round. Curious? More like strange.

Bart Hubbuch of the New York Post Grade: C+ A Chip Kelly-coached team went for an Oregon player — big shock — with its top pick, though DeForest Buckner looks like a rare Duck defender with staying power. But they traded up for a guard, then loaded up on injury and character concerns. - See more at: http://www.49erswebzone.com/news/93883-draft-grades-san-francisco-49ers-2016/#sthash.NbSEfMax.dpuf

Bart hubbach is the biggest hack out there. Guy is laughable. Almost as bad as Tim k and skip bayless
Originally posted by Rascal:
Originally posted by English:
Originally posted by 94949er:
Well at least we know Trent is getting fired

No, we don't. Actually the way he drafted, ie still looking long-term, indicates that he has no fears on that count.

Actually, that is not how it works in real life. If the 9ers lose 12 games in this coming season like many have predicted here, trust me there will be a very high chance Baalke will get fired. May I remind you our last HC was a joker by the name of Tomsula and if we can't even win more games than last year, oh yea it will be a big deal. The fans will erupt or let's just say the boo birds will be back out in full force. The first question that will be asked is what has Baalke done to give the 9ers a better season after last year's total disaster? The answer of course is a resounding nothing. With close to $60 mil of cap space, he basically just mailed it in and went fishing. As for the draft, started off well, but it soon turned into the usual train wreck. Again he totally neglected the offensive skilled positions. You know why? Cos he knows full well he is totally incapable of drafting offensive players. Oh yea and Jeff Driskel? So, I guess that's our next franchise QB huh? LOL. So, all in all, just not enough impact players that will be able to make a difference to help the 9ers win more games this year.

Nice twist. How about, why did he neglect the offensive skill positions? Answer, In a draft where, aside from the OL taken, in the skill positions we took a QB, a running back and a wide receiver. Only someone still bitter because his man wasn't taken could call that neglect. And the draft was, it is quite clear, correctly intended to restock the two lines which were in dire need of help.

But I agree with you on one point. Whatever happens a part of the support will erupt at some stage or other. Draft all the skill players you want. Without quality lines they will achieve nothing. But as these aren't sexy picks a part of the fanbase will hate it. But that doesn't mean they are right.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone