Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 804 users in the forums

Grade The Draft

Browse 49ers books and videos

Grade The Draft

B

We came away with the top rated 3-4 DE and the top rated run blocking LG. Both are expected to start right away at positions that were weak spots on the roster. That's a huge plus and better than average across the league.

Really like: Blair and Burbridge.
Both are gamers that just produce. They don't blow you away on paper, but both can play at a high level and they shouldn't be overwhelmed moving up to the pros.

Blair pushes TJE of the roster and could add depth at OLB. He's a tweeter and the coaches need to figure out how to use him.

Burbridge reminds me of Jarvis Landry and Boldin. There's no flash to his game, but he is a tough player that seems to make plays consistently. He's a reliable target for a QB.

Great fit: Driskell, Taylor, Cajuste
Driskell played a little zone-read, but he gets the ball out quick, can scramble, and throws on the runs. He fits the system very well.

I wasn't high on Taylor, but he's very quick. His quickness and ability to move laterally should bode well in this offense.

Lastly, Cajuste could come in and surprise. I was waiting for our big-body WR (Wilson or Garrett) to get selected, but it never happened. I'm not sure if he was signed to play outside like Riley Cooper or they'll ask him to bulk up and stretch the field like Brent Celek did so well.

Head scratchers: CB and OT
CB - The plus side is that between Redmon and Robinson we're probably getting a major contributor in the coming years. Prince is a long shot, but between the 3, there's a good chance we hit on a starter. Baalke is gambling that he hit big on one of these talented guys.

OT - Anthony Davis complicates the RT situation, but grabbing Theus, then coming right back with Cooper was odd. Trent stuck gold with Brown in the 7th last season, here's to hoping he can add another quality player to push Pears (a Tomsula guy) off the roster. This was really my least favorite part of the draft.

To finish on a positive...
Buckner is really going to help the defense. With Ian limping into the season, we have Dorsey or Dial sliding inside to play NT. That's a formidable line that'll draw a lot of attention away from Lynch and Brooks/Eli/Tank. In the top-10, you hope for a day 1 starter at a position of need and we got exactly that. No-brainer, A+ pick.

Garnett will step in to fill possibly the biggest hole on our roster. Another day 1 starter. Personal I liked Whitehair as the top LG, but Chip knows what he wants on the Oline and he was effatuated with this big ugly. We only gave up a 4th to secure another starter, so I have no objections there. As an added bonus, I think this nearly pushes Pears off the roster.

These drafts take 3 years to before players' true worth are realized. If Trent hits on Buckner, Garnett, and 1 CB, I think we'll be happy with this draft. If he also hits on Driskell and another guy (Blair or Burbridge), this draft will be huge for us.
Originally posted by SanFranFanfrmVa:
If Jeff Driskel hadn't played in that BS offense for Will Muschamp and played in a pro style offense he would've been a much higher pick. This kid has all the tools to be a NFL QB. I like Driskel in the 6th round much better then Hackenberg 2nd round or Connor Cook 3rd round. I truly believe the 49ers targeted Driskel the entire time.

Chip must've liked him. He said he was calling Driskell 20 minutes before the pick to see if he was getting calls from other teams. Coincidentally, that would've been about 2 picks prior to the Cards, who were expected to take a QB. I'm guessing we liked him enough to trade up a few spots to secure him.

Driskell said he had minimal contact with the team before the draft, so maybe he was our target all along. Trent has been known to do that. Cook mightve been a smoke screen, as we didn't publically meet with the mobile QBs that we all thought we'd covet.
Keeping with the context that this is year 1 or 2 of the rebuild (depending on your perspective) and their plan and execution, I'd say B+. The "flashy" players will come next year. You can't assess the skill positions until the lines are built and the systems are installed. Period.


IMHO, Baalke/Kelly/Gamble did it right.


Overall Assessment: Overall, no doubt the goal and outcome was to rebuild the lines in year 1 or 2 of this rebuild (depending on your perspective) and use that as a barometer to see what we have at the skill positions for next year. We added more depth and specific-skill position players for our systems from the move-TEs, to the slot WR and CB to the 2-down NT and like-skilled QB's.

The average number of starters from every draft class is 2.3 so a GM reaches for 3. We got 2 right out of the gate with DeForrest Buckner and Joshua Garnett. These are your "impact players."

In addition to them, remember, we're expected to run nickel/dime 60-70% of the time (common in the NFL now) with heavy DL rotations. Therefore, other defenders who could play "starter" roles for us include Ronald Blair, Demetrius Cherry & Alex Balducci (DE rotation with AA & Buckner), Rashard Robinson over Dontae Johnson or he beats out Tramaine Brock on the other side and we go "longer" and Will Redmond (if healthy) or Prince Charles Iworah (ST/returner/gunner) beat out Keith Reaser at the slot CB spot and then on offense, Kelvin Taylor beats out DuJuan Harris as the RB2, Devon Cajuste beats out Bruce Miller as the move-TE and Aaron Burbridge beats out Bruce Ellington at the YWR. Next year, I think more fans will be happy as you can expect more targets for the flashy "skill positions."
Originally posted by NCommand:
Keeping with the context that this is year 1 or 2 of the rebuild (depending on your perspective) and their plan and execution, I'd say B+. The "flashy" players will come next year. You can't assess the skill positions until the lines are built and the systems are installed. Period.


IMHO, Baalke/Kelly/Gamble did it right.


Overall Assessment: Overall, no doubt the goal and outcome was to rebuild the lines in year 1 or 2 of this rebuild (depending on your perspective) and use that as a barometer to see what we have at the skill positions for next year. We added more depth and specific-skill position players for our systems from the move-TEs, to the slot WR and CB to the 2-down NT and like-skilled QB's.

The average number of starters from every draft class is 2.3 so a GM reaches for 3. We got 2 right out of the gate with DeForrest Buckner and Joshua Garnett. These are your "impact players."

In addition to them, remember, we're expected to run nickel/dime 60-70% of the time (common in the NFL now) with heavy DL rotations. Therefore, other defenders who could play "starter" roles for us include Ronald Blair, Demetrius Cherry & Alex Balducci (DE rotation with AA & Buckner), Rashard Robinson over Dontae Johnson or he beats out Tramaine Brock on the other side and we go "longer" and Will Redmond (if healthy) or Prince Charles Iworah (ST/returner/gunner) beat out Keith Reaser at the slot CB spot and then on offense, Kelvin Taylor beats out DuJuan Harris as the RB2, Devon Cajuste beats out Bruce Miller as the move-TE and Aaron Burbridge beats out Bruce Ellington at the YWR. Next year, I think more fans will be happy as you can expect more targets for the flashy "skill positions."


Also Ncommand it gives Kelly time to see what he has at QB and a year to develop Driskell. We're simply not a playoff team this year with this schedule. I have no expectations for this team outside of learning Kelly's system and developing the young players. Going into the next offseason we'll know our strengths and weakness and plan accordingly. Not to mention a boat load of cap space that could only get bigger if CK,Brooks and Bethea are no longer on the roster. Next years free agent class looks to be really good.
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
I give a D but it was actually a C-.

The 1st round pick was horrendous we picked the bigger boom or bust prospect of the entire draft(Buckner) and got a injured corner in the second.

LOL at this post. Buckner was a horrendous pick? Really? Most people who know the game think he is one of the safest picks in the draft. Oh.. we didnt have a pick in the 2nd round.
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
I give a D but it was actually a C-.

The 1st round pick was horrendous we picked the bigger boom or bust prospect of the entire draft(Buckner) and got a injured corner in the second.

Lmao I dont know if you are serious but how is buckner horrendous? Who did you have in mind the team draft with #7? dont tell me Myles Jack... anyone after Buckner at that point would be a reach IMO.
Originally posted by 49ersOnMINE:
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
I give a D but it was actually a C-.

The 1st round pick was horrendous we picked the bigger boom or bust prospect of the entire draft(Buckner) and got a injured corner in the second.

Lmao I dont know if you are serious but how is buckner horrendous? Who did you have in mind the team draft with #7? dont tell me Myles Jack... anyone after Buckner at that point would be a reach IMO.

I think Tunsil and maybe Conklin would have been worthy of the pick but thats it. Buckner was an easy choice though given Tunsil's stupidity.
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
I think Tunsil and maybe Conklin would have been worthy of the pick but thats it. Buckner was an easy choice though given Tunsil's stupidity.

that was 3 years ago so not sure if that was an issue

but even then i think were fine at OT we have one proven veteran and a promising RT

the interior is the issue garnett was a good pick

i think Buckner was a good pick i dont see the boom or bust label he could fail to live up to expectations for sure but i dont think he will be anything worse than a solid starter because he does play well against the run and is strong at POA
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
LOL at this post. Buckner was a horrendous pick? Really? Most people who know the game think he is one of the safest picks in the draft. Oh.. we didnt have a pick in the 2nd round.

No way Buckner is a horrendous pick. We've never had two bookends that have the ability to collapse the pocket like we do know with the "Duck Brothers." The opposing offensive lines will be on their heels before they know it. This makes it so much easier for our LBs to get in and make the sack. Our entire defense just took a major leap forward.
Overall I grade it a B-. Im happy with the selections of Buckner and Garnett, build back our fronts. Our Dline of Armstead and Buckner for the future is exciting to say the least. A

I wasnt huge on either of the corners we selected but their upside is undeniable and while Baalke has numerous issues, hes been relatively good at finding mid to late round value with defensive backs. B

Theus and Cooper are both unimpressive to me and would have gone a different direction, both are guards in my opinion and we could have used a true Tackle prospect. D+

Loved what we did in the 6th round and Blair. I expect Blair to pack on some additional weight and be a nice penetrating 3 tech in a year, maybe a RayMac type. The upside to Driskel is incredible and when i watched a few LaTech games last year, accuracy was inconsistent but when he was confident and comfortable in the pocket he was very good. Kelvin Taylor is a good prospect with the ability to make something out of nothing. Now to teach him to just get up field and take whats available. B

Burbridge i watched a ton of in college, impressive concentration and coached well but he will struggle to separate in the NFL. Would have preferred a better athlete at the position (Charone Peake). C
  • Hopper
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 12,489
Originally posted by DrGonzo00:
I gave it a C. Bruckner will be a beast who won't be a showy stats guy but is necessary in the 3-4. Nailed that pick. Garnett...some love him and thought he was one of the best, if not the best, OL but of course, there are questions as to whether he'll fit in with the scheme. And while he played RG, I'm sure we'll move him to LT or somewhere completely out of position because we just love doing that when we draft OL.

Redmond and Robinson...I just don't get Baalke's fascination with A) injured players and B) CBs. CB depth is nice, but we've found gems later in the draft and CB is kind of a dime a dozen position. Plus you took a guy who has legit off the field concerns, so the whole "win with class" thing goes out the window. Cooper could be a sleeper, Theus needs to work on his body bigtime but if Boone did it, so can he. I really like the Kelvin Taylor pick and think he'll surprise.

huh?
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Baalke panicked on the 2nd pick with Garnett. You can get a Guard. We can get a Guard in the 2nd or 3rd round. We could have had Ogbah if he wanted to trade up. I don't like that pick much. I think it was a reach.

Based on what? What you read? If they think Garnett is a Pro Bowl caliber G, it was perfectly fine. We gave up a 4th and a 6th, which are usually stabs in the dark anyways. Low risk move.

Garnett was the 77th player on Mel Kipers board.....

And Mel Kiper is the worst analyst out there. He's really bad.
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,400
BUCKNER - in my eyeas (all year) isn't a top 10 player, so I would look at this pick as a reach, tho he is a good player = B

GARNETT - I just believe that he woulda been there with our own 37th pick, and if he wasn't then Whitehair coulda been the one = B

the rest are just pure C = CONFUSE!!
Originally posted by 9moon:
BUCKNER - in my eyeas (all year) isn't a top 10 player, so I would look at this pick as a reach, tho he is a good player = B

GARNETT - I just believe that he woulda been there with our own 37th pick, and if he wasn't then Whitehair coulda been the one = B

the rest are just pure C = CONFUSE!!

Balke has confused me often with his later picks but then I found this.file:///C:/Users/Jim/Downloads/How%20long%20does%20the%20average%20draft%20pick%20stick%20around_%20-%20Mile%20High%20Report.html
Oh, Ignore the crap about Elway just check out the charts.
Since the draft is a basically a crap shoo,t especially after the fourth round, and most of the players are not going to be on the teams roster starting in the third season after they are drafted, I stopped paying close attention to the later rounds.
Now I just hope a few manage to help or actually become something.
[ Edited by Born49R on May 1, 2016 at 12:42 PM ]
Originally posted by NCommand:
Keeping with the context that this is year 1 or 2 of the rebuild (depending on your perspective) and their plan and execution, I'd say B+. The "flashy" players will come next year. You can't assess the skill positions until the lines are built and the systems are installed. Period.


IMHO, Baalke/Kelly/Gamble did it right.


Overall Assessment: Overall, no doubt the goal and outcome was to rebuild the lines in year 1 or 2 of this rebuild (depending on your perspective) and use that as a barometer to see what we have at the skill positions for next year. We added more depth and specific-skill position players for our systems from the move-TEs, to the slot WR and CB to the 2-down NT and like-skilled QB's.

The average number of starters from every draft class is 2.3 so a GM reaches for 3. We got 2 right out of the gate with DeForrest Buckner and Joshua Garnett. These are your "impact players."

In addition to them, remember, we're expected to run nickel/dime 60-70% of the time (common in the NFL now) with heavy DL rotations. Therefore, other defenders who could play "starter" roles for us include Ronald Blair, Demetrius Cherry & Alex Balducci (DE rotation with AA & Buckner), Rashard Robinson over Dontae Johnson or he beats out Tramaine Brock on the other side and we go "longer" and Will Redmond (if healthy) or Prince Charles Iworah (ST/returner/gunner) beat out Keith Reaser at the slot CB spot and then on offense, Kelvin Taylor beats out DuJuan Harris as the RB2, Devon Cajuste beats out Bruce Miller as the move-TE and Aaron Burbridge beats out Bruce Ellington at the YWR. Next year, I think more fans will be happy as you can expect more targets for the flashy "skill positions."

Nice assessment. The only thing I disagree with is the projection that Taylor beats out Harris. I think Harris was our best RB after Hyde last season and he has enough twitch to excel in Chip's offense.

Gaskins and Draughn are terrible fits and I think they'll get cut. Davis and Hayne have a battle on their hands also. They'll need to play much faster in year two.

If we go with 4 RBs, I project:

Hyde - Harris - Davis - Taylor

Taylor has a shot at moving up later in the year if he can pass protect.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone