Originally posted by SheHateMe:
I get the metric but it doesn't factor in the evolution of the NFL game and the fact that most QB's are essentially 'air raid' quarterbacks now. It also doesn't factor in the fact that 'franchise' quarterbacks need to be drafted into the right system at the right time to evolve into franchise quarterbacks. It's a passing league now and with college football now running 'air raid' systems, it's more of a crap shoot than it was 10 years ago. How many offenses in college actually run a pro style offense? Not many. Is there a huge difference between Mahomes, Rush, and Trubisky? These guys are separated by 4 or 5 rounds and their success at the NFL level is anyone's guess. In other words, it's a crap shoot. That is the direction drafting a QB is going in my opinion with the college game running their offenses.
There actually is quite a difference. Though there will be some misses, going back about 30 years, NFL scouts generally do a good job of picking out who has a shot at the next level and who is most likely lacking in the skills or physical talent to translate over from the college level.
People will point out a few exceptions but generally the guys who go early and the guys who go late all do so for good reason.
Air Raid QBs arent some new invention, the scheme has been in place for almost 30 years now. The only major change is that you do get some more overall talented QBs playing in the scheme such as Goff last year, Mahomes and Falk this year...etc.
Just as spread QBs were destined to fail automatically until some more talented guys like Brees, Big Ben and Phillip Rivers started entering the NFL, having success and suddenly it became less of an issue.
With better Air Raid prospects entering the NFL, these guys will start breaking through and soon it will just be another thing and not some great defining factor of a quarterback.
The whole "pro style" debate is also largely tired, particularly when more and more teams are running spread concepts in their offense, having their QB taking snaps from the pistol or the shotgun as well. We have seen plenty of pro-style QBs fail simply because they couldnt hack it, having run a pro style offense in college wasnt a replacement for vision, awareness, QB aptitude, accuracy and toughness.
It always comes down to the quarterback, a QB with the right aptitude and work ethic will be able to work into pretty much any scheme, regardless of what they ran in college.
Marcus Mariota came out of spread offense in college while Jameis Winston came out of a pro style offense. In his 2nd season Mariota is killing it while Winston has made some progress while having typical young QB ups and downs. Mariota clearly hasnt had much issue adjusting to the NFL.
You analyze the prospect, not the scheme, otherwise you wind up being the guy who passes on Dak Prescott because he came out of the same offense as Tim Tebow.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Dec 3, 2016 at 3:55 PM ]