Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 686 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:
Originally posted by FL9er:
Trubisky or Falk for me.

In the 2nd or 3rd round right? Nowhere but the 49ersforums is Falk considered a first round pick.

If we take a QB at #2, I'd be fine with Trubisky, Kizer, or Watson. Would much rather have Garrett though.

Falk has a real hard time throwing when it's anything other than single coverage. His decision making is very questionable. Trubisky seems to be the clear cut top QB this year. Watson/Kizer are the next tier.
  • FL9er
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,889
I was referring to what QB I want the 49ers to draft, not necessarily @2.
Originally posted by FL9er:
I was referring to what QB I want the 49ers to draft, not necessarily @2.

Been reported he's more than likely staying another yr....he needs time to develop on the bench in the NFL IMO. Seems like a smart qb that is accurate, I don't see the velocity in his passes though.
IF kap continues to progress we might be able to look at a more developmental qb in the mid rounds for chip to groom.

Here's a couple canidates

http://draftwire.usatoday.com/2016/12/02/the-dak-prescott-candidates-in-the-2017-nfl-draft/

Cooper rush-leader got the arm and frame
David Webb-haven't watched much but seems to be pretty raw
Chad Kelly-most talented but a headcase
Brady Gustafson-FCS qb so who knows, my family loves him (they are Griz fans though)

Anyone else that comes to mind that hasn't already been talked about a lot?
Originally posted by NYniner85:
IF kap continues to progress we might be able to look at a more developmental qb in the mid rounds for chip to groom.
As many many times stated before, just ask Phoenix, the probability for picking a future franchise QB on day 2 or even later is VERY low.
I'd rather pick an immediate help like Garrett and try to trade up into round 1 from our 2nd round spot in order to draft an FQB instead.

No need for experiments at QB. Enough. Thank you.
Originally posted by communist:
As many many times stated before, just ask Phoenix, the probability for picking a future franchise QB on day 2 or even later is VERY low.
I'd rather pick an immediate help like Garrett and try to trade up into round 1 from our 2nd round spot in order to draft an FQB instead.

No need for experiments at QB. Enough. Thank you.

The probability for picking ANY franchise QB is very low. It's 30% in round 1 I think. You hardly lose any percentage in the next two rounds.

The probability is weak no matter where you're picking. The trick to increasing probability isn't how high you pick but at what volume. Pick 2 qbs a year and keep Kap.
Originally posted by SheHateMe:
The probability for picking ANY franchise QB is very low. It's 30% in round 1 I think. You hardly lose any percentage in the next two rounds.

Yeah no try again. Your odds are roughly 45% in Round 1, 20% in Round 2, less than 10% in Round 3 and they further fall off a cliff after that.


The probability is weak no matter where you're picking. The trick to increasing probability isn't how high you pick but at what volume. Pick 2 qbs a year and keep Kap.


The earlier you take a QB, the better your odds are. By the time you hit Round 4 you are essentially buying a lottery ticket and hoping to hit the jackpot.


The majority of QBs taken Round 4 and later will never play a single snap for the team that drafted them.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Dec 3, 2016 at 1:42 PM ]
Member Milestone: This is post number 1,800 for harryj.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by SheHateMe:
The probability for picking ANY franchise QB is very low. It's 30% in round 1 I think. You hardly lose any percentage in the next two rounds.

Yeah no try again. Your odds are roughly 45% in Round 1, 20% in Round 2, less than 10% in Round 3 and they further fall off a cliff after that.



The probability is weak no matter where you're picking. The trick to increasing probability isn't how high you pick but at what volume. Pick 2 qbs a year and keep Kap.


The earlier you take a QB, the better your odds are. By the time you hit Round 4 you are essentially buying a lottery ticket and hoping to hit the jackpot.

you also have to take the right prospect and put him in the right circumstances because environment takes a huge part

i was never a fan of kelly because i dont believe his scheme can win a SB but without a doubt he is a brilliant offensive mind and i do have faith he can develop a qb

the key is to not break him
Originally posted by harryj:
you also have to take the right prospect and put him in the right circumstances because environment takes a huge part

i was never a fan of kelly because i dont believe his scheme can win a SB but without a doubt he is a brilliant offensive mind and i do have faith he can develop a qb

the key is to not break him


This is also a key reason why some young QBs fail. David Carr and Tim Couch were both top QB prospects who were utterly demolished behind expansion level OLs.
Here is a link to the QB thread I posted last year.

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/nfl-draft/184003-the-drafting-qb-late-folly/
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Yeah no try again. Your odds are roughly 45% in Round 1, 20% in Round 2, less than 10% in Round 3 and they further fall off a cliff after that.




The earlier you take a QB, the better your odds are. By the time you hit Round 4 you are essentially buying a lottery ticket and hoping to hit the jackpot.


The majority of QBs taken Round 4 and later will never play a single snap for the team that drafted them.

It isn't 45% in round one or 20% in round 2. Numbers and probability is what I do for a living so yeah, no...try again?
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by SheHateMe:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Yeah no try again. Your odds are roughly 45% in Round 1, 20% in Round 2, less than 10% in Round 3 and they further fall off a cliff after that.




The earlier you take a QB, the better your odds are. By the time you hit Round 4 you are essentially buying a lottery ticket and hoping to hit the jackpot.


The majority of QBs taken Round 4 and later will never play a single snap for the team that drafted them.

It isn't 45% in round one or 20% in round 2. Numbers and probability is what I do for a living so yeah, no...try again?

Yah I think we went over this one before and I have to agree with Phoenix. But in the 49ers case, they are in a very good position to take one of the most dominant defensive players since Von Miller IMO in Myles Garrett. I think they should do their best to acquire him then trade back up for a QB, possibly Luke Falk (who NY says is going back to school but I'll believe it when I see it) or Mason Rudolph. If no Garrett, Trubisky would do just fine.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Here is a link to the QB thread I posted last year.

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/nfl-draft/184003-the-drafting-qb-late-folly/

I get the metric but it doesn't factor in the evolution of the NFL game and the fact that most QB's are essentially 'air raid' quarterbacks now. It also doesn't factor in the fact that 'franchise' quarterbacks need to be drafted into the right system at the right time to evolve into franchise quarterbacks. It's a passing league now and with college football now running 'air raid' systems, it's more of a crap shoot than it was 10 years ago. How many offenses in college actually run a pro style offense? Not many. Is there a huge difference between Mahomes, Rush, and Trubisky? These guys are separated by 4 or 5 rounds and their success at the NFL level is anyone's guess. In other words, it's a crap shoot. That is the direction drafting a QB is going in my opinion with the college game running their offenses.
Originally posted by SheHateMe:
It isn't 45% in round one or 20% in round 2. Numbers and probability is what I do for a living so yeah, no...try again?

The numbers are what they are, agreed upon by people who analyze football for a living, anywhere from 40-50% hits on QBs in the 1st round is what a wide variety of sources have concluded upon.


Your own personal opinion on what constitutes a hit and fandom of Kaepernick not withstanding.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Dec 3, 2016 at 3:41 PM ]
Originally posted by SheHateMe:
I get the metric but it doesn't factor in the evolution of the NFL game and the fact that most QB's are essentially 'air raid' quarterbacks now. It also doesn't factor in the fact that 'franchise' quarterbacks need to be drafted into the right system at the right time to evolve into franchise quarterbacks. It's a passing league now and with college football now running 'air raid' systems, it's more of a crap shoot than it was 10 years ago. How many offenses in college actually run a pro style offense? Not many. Is there a huge difference between Mahomes, Rush, and Trubisky? These guys are separated by 4 or 5 rounds and their success at the NFL level is anyone's guess. In other words, it's a crap shoot. That is the direction drafting a QB is going in my opinion with the college game running their offenses.


There actually is quite a difference. Though there will be some misses, going back about 30 years, NFL scouts generally do a good job of picking out who has a shot at the next level and who is most likely lacking in the skills or physical talent to translate over from the college level.


People will point out a few exceptions but generally the guys who go early and the guys who go late all do so for good reason.



Air Raid QBs arent some new invention, the scheme has been in place for almost 30 years now. The only major change is that you do get some more overall talented QBs playing in the scheme such as Goff last year, Mahomes and Falk this year...etc.


Just as spread QBs were destined to fail automatically until some more talented guys like Brees, Big Ben and Phillip Rivers started entering the NFL, having success and suddenly it became less of an issue.

With better Air Raid prospects entering the NFL, these guys will start breaking through and soon it will just be another thing and not some great defining factor of a quarterback.


The whole "pro style" debate is also largely tired, particularly when more and more teams are running spread concepts in their offense, having their QB taking snaps from the pistol or the shotgun as well. We have seen plenty of pro-style QBs fail simply because they couldnt hack it, having run a pro style offense in college wasnt a replacement for vision, awareness, QB aptitude, accuracy and toughness.


It always comes down to the quarterback, a QB with the right aptitude and work ethic will be able to work into pretty much any scheme, regardless of what they ran in college.


Marcus Mariota came out of spread offense in college while Jameis Winston came out of a pro style offense. In his 2nd season Mariota is killing it while Winston has made some progress while having typical young QB ups and downs. Mariota clearly hasnt had much issue adjusting to the NFL.


You analyze the prospect, not the scheme, otherwise you wind up being the guy who passes on Dak Prescott because he came out of the same offense as Tim Tebow.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Dec 3, 2016 at 3:55 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone