49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 706 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
There actually is quite a difference. Though there will be some misses, going back about 30 years, NFL scouts generally do a good job of picking out who has a shot at the next level and who is most likely lacking in the skills or physical talent to translate over from the college level.


People will point out a few exceptions but generally the guys who go early and the guys who go late all do so for good reason.



Air Raid QBs arent some new invention, the scheme has been in place for almost 30 years now. The only major change is that you do get some more overall talented QBs playing in the scheme such as Goff last year, Mahomes and Falk this year...etc.


Just as spread QBs were destined to fail automatically until some more talented guys like Brees, Big Ben and Phillip Rivers started entering the NFL, having success and suddenly it became less of an issue.

With better Air Raid prospects entering the NFL, these guys will start breaking through and soon it will just be another thing and not some great defining factor of a quarterback.


The whole "pro style" debate is also largely tired, particularly when more and more teams are running spread concepts in their offense, having their QB taking snaps from the pistol or the shotgun as well. We have seen plenty of pro-style QBs fail simply because they couldnt hack it, having run a pro style offense in college wasnt a replacement for vision, awareness, QB aptitude, accuracy and toughness.


It always comes down to the quarterback, a QB with the right aptitude and work ethic will be able to work into pretty much any scheme, regardless of what they ran in college.


Marcus Mariota came out of spread offense in college while Jameis Winston came out of a pro style offense. In his 2nd season Mariota is killing it while Winston has made some progress while having typical young QB ups and downs. Mariota clearly hasnt had much issue adjusting to the NFL.


You analyze the prospect, not the scheme, otherwise you wind up being the guy who passes on Dak Prescott because he came out of the same offense as Tim Tebow.

That is very well said. If only scouts could analyze the drive and hunger of prospects teams would be able to hit almost every time factoring in all the rest. Brady and Bree's are classic overachievers with 'over my dead body' attitudes and obsessive probably to a disturbing point about quarterback play.
Whatever percentage you believe correct, 50% (the highest listed) means a logical GM needing a QB will draft more than one if it's at all possible. A fairly high pick with good credentials and a second guy who has fallen for some reason or is just not as accomplished. I really like competition and I don't see it with our current QBs unless Kaepernick decides to stay. Other than our own FAs Cousins is the only FA who has some interest to me...but I would guess he will resign with Snyder...no one outbids the guy.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
There actually is quite a difference. Though there will be some misses, going back about 30 years, NFL scouts generally do a good job of picking out who has a shot at the next level and who is most likely lacking in the skills or physical talent to translate over from the college level.


People will point out a few exceptions but generally the guys who go early and the guys who go late all do so for good reason.



Air Raid QBs arent some new invention, the scheme has been in place for almost 30 years now. The only major change is that you do get some more overall talented QBs playing in the scheme such as Goff last year, Mahomes and Falk this year...etc.


Just as spread QBs were destined to fail automatically until some more talented guys like Brees, Big Ben and Phillip Rivers started entering the NFL, having success and suddenly it became less of an issue.

With better Air Raid prospects entering the NFL, these guys will start breaking through and soon it will just be another thing and not some great defining factor of a quarterback.


The whole "pro style" debate is also largely tired, particularly when more and more teams are running spread concepts in their offense, having their QB taking snaps from the pistol or the shotgun as well. We have seen plenty of pro-style QBs fail simply because they couldnt hack it, having run a pro style offense in college wasnt a replacement for vision, awareness, QB aptitude, accuracy and toughness.


It always comes down to the quarterback, a QB with the right aptitude and work ethic will be able to work into pretty much any scheme, regardless of what they ran in college.


Marcus Mariota came out of spread offense in college while Jameis Winston came out of a pro style offense. In his 2nd season Mariota is killing it while Winston has made some progress while having typical young QB ups and downs. Mariota clearly hasnt had much issue adjusting to the NFL.


You analyze the prospect, not the scheme, otherwise you wind up being the guy who passes on Dak Prescott because he came out of the same offense as Tim Tebow.

Fantastic post Phoenix. You described my feelings on the matter pretty verbatim as well. Well said my man.
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
There actually is quite a difference. Though there will be some misses, going back about 30 years, NFL scouts generally do a good job of picking out who has a shot at the next level and who is most likely lacking in the skills or physical talent to translate over from the college level.


People will point out a few exceptions but generally the guys who go early and the guys who go late all do so for good reason.



Air Raid QBs arent some new invention, the scheme has been in place for almost 30 years now. The only major change is that you do get some more overall talented QBs playing in the scheme such as Goff last year, Mahomes and Falk this year...etc.


Just as spread QBs were destined to fail automatically until some more talented guys like Brees, Big Ben and Phillip Rivers started entering the NFL, having success and suddenly it became less of an issue.

With better Air Raid prospects entering the NFL, these guys will start breaking through and soon it will just be another thing and not some great defining factor of a quarterback.


The whole "pro style" debate is also largely tired, particularly when more and more teams are running spread concepts in their offense, having their QB taking snaps from the pistol or the shotgun as well. We have seen plenty of pro-style QBs fail simply because they couldnt hack it, having run a pro style offense in college wasnt a replacement for vision, awareness, QB aptitude, accuracy and toughness.


It always comes down to the quarterback, a QB with the right aptitude and work ethic will be able to work into pretty much any scheme, regardless of what they ran in college.


Marcus Mariota came out of spread offense in college while Jameis Winston came out of a pro style offense. In his 2nd season Mariota is killing it while Winston has made some progress while having typical young QB ups and downs. Mariota clearly hasnt had much issue adjusting to the NFL.


You analyze the prospect, not the scheme, otherwise you wind up being the guy who passes on Dak Prescott because he came out of the same offense as Tim Tebow.

Fantastic post Phoenix. You described my feelings on the matter pretty verbatim as well. Well said my man.

Agree. Awesome post
Originally posted by tohara3:
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
There actually is quite a difference. Though there will be some misses, going back about 30 years, NFL scouts generally do a good job of picking out who has a shot at the next level and who is most likely lacking in the skills or physical talent to translate over from the college level.


People will point out a few exceptions but generally the guys who go early and the guys who go late all do so for good reason.



Air Raid QBs arent some new invention, the scheme has been in place for almost 30 years now. The only major change is that you do get some more overall talented QBs playing in the scheme such as Goff last year, Mahomes and Falk this year...etc.


Just as spread QBs were destined to fail automatically until some more talented guys like Brees, Big Ben and Phillip Rivers started entering the NFL, having success and suddenly it became less of an issue.

With better Air Raid prospects entering the NFL, these guys will start breaking through and soon it will just be another thing and not some great defining factor of a quarterback.


The whole "pro style" debate is also largely tired, particularly when more and more teams are running spread concepts in their offense, having their QB taking snaps from the pistol or the shotgun as well. We have seen plenty of pro-style QBs fail simply because they couldnt hack it, having run a pro style offense in college wasnt a replacement for vision, awareness, QB aptitude, accuracy and toughness.


It always comes down to the quarterback, a QB with the right aptitude and work ethic will be able to work into pretty much any scheme, regardless of what they ran in college.


Marcus Mariota came out of spread offense in college while Jameis Winston came out of a pro style offense. In his 2nd season Mariota is killing it while Winston has made some progress while having typical young QB ups and downs. Mariota clearly hasnt had much issue adjusting to the NFL.


You analyze the prospect, not the scheme, otherwise you wind up being the guy who passes on Dak Prescott because he came out of the same offense as Tim Tebow.

Fantastic post Phoenix. You described my feelings on the matter pretty verbatim as well. Well said my man.

Agree. Awesome post

  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Love watching Watson play in big games. This is how franchise QBs should look in big moments.
Originally posted by okdkid:
Love watching Watson play in big games. This is how franchise QBs should look in big moments.

5 TDs and something like 370 total yards tonight.
Originally posted by TheBlueHell:
Originally posted by okdkid:
Love watching Watson play in big games. This is how franchise QBs should look in big moments.

5 TDs and something like 370 total yards tonight.

Kid speaks, acts and IS a franchise QB. I still like him more than Trubisky
My draft want in order if we happen to stay at pick 2
Garrett
Trubisky

But if we win a couple of games and end up sliding on those 2, I want Watson. Played well on big games. I also agree he will do well on Chips offense. Falk at the end of first if Watson is gone before our pick.
[ Edited by frankieuc68 on Dec 4, 2016 at 12:54 AM ]
Originally posted by communist:
As many many times stated before, just ask Phoenix, the probability for picking a future franchise QB on day 2 or even later is VERY low.
I'd rather pick an immediate help like Garrett and try to trade up into round 1 from our 2nd round spot in order to draft an FQB instead.

No need for experiments at QB. Enough. Thank you.

I feel ya, who you giving up picks for to move up into the bottom of the 1st though? Kizer? Dude hasn't looked the part for most of the season at all...Watson and Mitch are gonna be top 10 picks end of the day. IF Kap continues his play then I'm fine keeping him and having a 3rd round developmental pick for this year. This class is not even close to the best...I like Mitch and Watson but they aren't close to no brainer QB picks either (they are experiments as well).

Got 5 more games to look over the current QB then make a call after that
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Dec 4, 2016 at 6:12 AM ]
Originally posted by 49ers808:
Originally posted by TheBlueHell:
Originally posted by okdkid:
Love watching Watson play in big games. This is how franchise QBs should look in big moments.

5 TDs and something like 370 total yards tonight.

Kid speaks, acts and IS a franchise QB. I still like him more than Trubisky
As should everyone else, who knew who trubisky was prior to this year unless you're a unc fan? Either way if we don't f**k up and beat the bears today we should have our pick between him or garret. To me that's a win win for this franchise that needs something right for once
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by communist:
As many many times stated before, just ask Phoenix, the probability for picking a future franchise QB on day 2 or even later is VERY low.
I'd rather pick an immediate help like Garrett and try to trade up into round 1 from our 2nd round spot in order to draft an FQB instead.

No need for experiments at QB. Enough. Thank you.

I feel ya, who you giving up picks for to move up into the bottom of the 1st though? Kizer? Dude hasn't looked the part for most of the season at all...Watson and Mitch are gonna be top 10 picks end of the day. IF Kap continues his play then I'm fine keeping him and having a 3rd round developmental pick for this year. This class is not even close to the best...I like Mitch and Watson but they aren't close to no brainer QB picks either (they are experiments as well).

Got 5 more games to look over the current QB then make a call after that

The vast majority of top qbs drafted come with concerns. Phillio Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, and Matthew Stafford to name a few. Then you get those that validate the concerns like Gabbert, Lienart, Vince Young, Ponder, and Sanchez.

I just think the reward is worth the gamble to draft a highly talented qb in the first. I wish we could hit the lottery like Dak, but for every Dak there are 20+ Giovanni Carmazzis.
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
The vast majority of top qbs drafted come with concerns. Phillio Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, and Matthew Stafford to name a few. Then you get those that validate the concerns like Gabbert, Lienart, Vince Young, Ponder, and Sanchez.

I just think the reward is worth the gamble to draft a highly talented qb in the first. I wish we could hit the lottery like Dak, but for every Dak there are 20+ Giovanni Carmazzis.

All those names you just threw out for examples are wayyyyyy better qb prospects then who's currently gonna be in the draft this yr...it's not really close.

I agree there's question marks for most qb prospects if there wasn't we wouldn't be able to draft them unless we were 1 anyway.

I also agree players like Dak, Wilson, cousins, Montana who are 3rd and later picks don't come around every yr BUT the talent at the top just isn't there IMO. I like Watson and Mitch and wouldn't hate it at all if they were the pick. I also wouldn't hate to have kap for another yr or two while a qb grooms for the positon and we get players that are rated much higher than the qbs in this draft with our 1st.
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Dec 4, 2016 at 8:54 AM ]
Blah.
http://smartfootball.com/offense/the-air-raid-offense-history-evolution-weirdness-from-mumme-to-leach-to-franklin-to-holgorsen-and-beyond
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone