Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 559 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
The vast majority of top qbs drafted come with concerns. Phillio Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, and Matthew Stafford to name a few. Then you get those that validate the concerns like Gabbert, Lienart, Vince Young, Ponder, and Sanchez.

I just think the reward is worth the gamble to draft a highly talented qb in the first. I wish we could hit the lottery like Dak, but for every Dak there are 20+ Giovanni Carmazzis.

All those names you just threw out for examples are wayyyyyy better qb prospects then who's currently gonna be in the draft this yr...it's not really close.

I agree there's question marks for most qb prospects if there wasn't we wouldn't be able to draft them unless we were 1 anyway.

I also agree players like Dak, Wilson, cousins, Montana who are 3rd and later picks don't come around every yr BUT the talent at the top just isn't there IMO. I like Watson and Mitch and wouldn't hate it at all if they were the pick. I also wouldn't hate to have kap for another yr or two while a qb grooms for the positon and we get players that are rated much higher than the qbs in this draft with our 1st.

Ryan drafted #3 in the 1st round, Cam #1 1st round, #11 1st round, Rivers #4 1st round, #1 1st round...guess I'd have to ask for a definition of concern. These guys were really well thought of but I suppose any pick can be second guessed or nitpicked. The point being made is the first round picks are decent risks compared to later rounds and there is just no way to argue against that point. Just look at all the starting QBs in the NFL and you will see how few were drafted after the first. Brady is the exception everyone likes to point to but he was similar to Montana in college, having to fight through battles with other QBs and injury to earn a starting role.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Ryan drafted #3 in the 1st round, Cam #1 1st round, #11 1st round, Rivers #4 1st round, #1 1st round...guess I'd have to ask for a definition of concern. These guys were really well thought of but I suppose any pick can be second guessed or nitpicked. The point being made is the first round picks are decent risks compared to later rounds and there is just no way to argue against that point. Just look at all the starting QBs in the NFL and you will see how few were drafted after the first. Brady is the exception everyone likes to point to but he was similar to Montana in college, having to fight through battles with other QBs and injury to earn a starting role.

1st rd picks are also given every opportunity to succeed where qbs drafted pasted the 2nd have to earn anything and ultimately have to have injuries happen before they get a chance... perfect example is Dak and Brady

I'm not saying wait until the mid rds, but a top 5 pick might not be the right move based on the talent there...always can change we are 5 months away from the draft lol.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
1st rd picks are also given every opportunity to succeed where qbs drafted pasted the 2nd have to earn anything and ultimately have to have injuries happen before they get a chance... perfect example is Dak and Brady

I'm not saying wait until the mid rds, but a top 5 pick might not be the right move based on the talent there...always can change we are 5 months away from the draft lol.

Agree...and believe you pick the guy you like at the point he is available and a good value. Dak turned out to be a much higher value than all teams understood...Brady as well. This is why I always want multiple picks at positions of greatest need. If Kelly likes Trubisky and he's available at our spot great! But then let's also take a flier on a Webb, Kelly, Gustafson...a developmental guy.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Agree...and believe you pick the guy you like at the point he is available and a good value. Dak turned out to be a much higher value than all teams understood...Brady as well. This is why I always want multiple picks at positions of greatest need. If Kelly likes Trubisky and he's available at our spot great! But then let's also take a flier on a Webb, Kelly, Gustafson...a developmental guy.

If that's what happens id be fine...I'm also all for Myles at 1 and trade for Jimmy G (or keeping kap) and getting a developmental guy.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
This thread got me more fired up, Kaepernick will become a free agent after the season!!!!

Best of luck to him......IF he doesn't return to the 49ers.

Now back to the QB's, I'd really would love some answers on who is REALLY staying and declaring, that's when we'll get really anxious for the draft.

C'mon Falk, Rudolph and Tribusky!!!!

I'm gonna be pissed if the 49ers draft Chad Kelly or Brad Kayaa.

And although I've stated that I like Kizer more than Watson and Mahomes, I think Kizer NEEDS to return to school to raise his stock again. And if the 49ers came away with Garrett, I wouldn't be mad if they drafted Watson in the 2nd AND Mahomes in the 4th or 5th round. (I threw up in my mouth typing and saying that last sentence to myself)
Originally posted by SheHateMe:
I get the metric but it doesn't factor in the evolution of the NFL game and the fact that most QB's are essentially 'air raid' quarterbacks now. It also doesn't factor in the fact that 'franchise' quarterbacks need to be drafted into the right system at the right time to evolve into franchise quarterbacks. It's a passing league now and with college football now running 'air raid' systems, it's more of a crap shoot than it was 10 years ago. How many offenses in college actually run a pro style offense? Not many. Is there a huge difference between Mahomes, Rush, and Trubisky? These guys are separated by 4 or 5 rounds and their success at the NFL level is anyone's guess. In other words, it's a crap shoot. That is the direction drafting a QB is going in my opinion with the college game running their offenses.
1) there is a reason why player x is drafted in round whereas another fella has to wait until day 3.
2) system here, system there. Of course the conditions around a talent are relevant. However, at the end of the day talent and work ethic determine your success. Talent, at QB in particular, is gone very early.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
The vast majority of top qbs drafted come with concerns. Phillio Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, and Matthew Stafford to name a few. Then you get those that validate the concerns like Gabbert, Lienart, Vince Young, Ponder, and Sanchez.

I just think the reward is worth the gamble to draft a highly talented qb in the first. I wish we could hit the lottery like Dak, but for every Dak there are 20+ Giovanni Carmazzis.

All those names you just threw out for examples are wayyyyyy better qb prospects then who's currently gonna be in the draft this yr...it's not really close.

I agree there's question marks for most qb prospects if there wasn't we wouldn't be able to draft them unless we were 1 anyway.

I also agree players like Dak, Wilson, cousins, Montana who are 3rd and later picks don't come around every yr BUT the talent at the top just isn't there IMO. I like Watson and Mitch and wouldn't hate it at all if they were the pick. I also wouldn't hate to have kap for another yr or two while a qb grooms for the positon and we get players that are rated much higher than the qbs in this draft with our 1st.

Ryan drafted #3 in the 1st round, Cam #1 1st round, #11 1st round, Rivers #4 1st round, #1 1st round...guess I'd have to ask for a definition of concern. These guys were really well thought of but I suppose any pick can be second guessed or nitpicked. The point being made is the first round picks are decent risks compared to later rounds and there is just no way to argue against that point. Just look at all the starting QBs in the NFL and you will see how few were drafted after the first. Brady is the exception everyone likes to point to but he was similar to Montana in college, having to fight through battles with other QBs and injury to earn a starting role.

Cam Newton had concerns over his mechanics and being a pocket passer.

Rivers had concerns of his throwing motion and arm strength. He was taken at #4 but was not considered a top 10 pick that year.

Roethlisberger came from a small school and there were concerns over his level of competition.

Just because the qb is taken top 10 doesn't mean they dont come with concerns. My point is the position is the most important for a franchise long term success, and thus is worth the risk if their talent fits your system.

I will be thrilled to see Trubisky or Watson being the picked. I think Trubisky is legit and that Watson is more refined passer than Cam Newton coming out of college and is being overly criticized even though he has been the best qb in college for the last two seasons
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
Cam Newton had concerns over his mechanics and being a pocket passer.

Rivers had concerns of his throwing motion and arm strength. He was taken at #4 but was not considered a top 10 pick that year.

Roethlisberger came from a small school and there were concerns over his level of competition.

Just because the qb is taken top 10 doesn't mean they dont come with concerns. My point is the position is the most important for a franchise long term success, and thus is worth the risk if their talent fits your system.

I will be thrilled to see Trubisky or Watson being the picked. I think Trubisky is legit and that Watson is more refined passer than Cam Newton coming out of college and is being overly criticized even though he has been the best qb in college for the last two seasons

The most highly rated QB in the last ten years was Luck. How's that looking right now? Rated 16th at the moment. So there is no such thing as a QB coming into the NFL without questions. Many preferred RGIII to Luck because the power run game at Stanford helped himi so much. Just the way it is.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Dec 4, 2016 at 1:22 PM ]
I think we have to strongly consider taking Watson at #2 even over Garrett. It doesn't matter if the qb was rated a 92 by Mayock or a 99 what matters is what he does once he steps into the pros.

As long as Kelly is the coach this team is going to have to win with offense. You can't do it w/o a qb. Kelly has shown that schemes still work with good qb play, and a duel threat qb can ball in it.

I'm leaving Kizer out because I think he stays and if he does Watson will likely be top 10.
[ Edited by tjd808185 on Dec 4, 2016 at 1:35 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
Cam Newton had concerns over his mechanics and being a pocket passer.

Rivers had concerns of his throwing motion and arm strength. He was taken at #4 but was not considered a top 10 pick that year.

Roethlisberger came from a small school and there were concerns over his level of competition.

Just because the qb is taken top 10 doesn't mean they dont come with concerns. My point is the position is the most important for a franchise long term success, and thus is worth the risk if their talent fits your system.

I will be thrilled to see Trubisky or Watson being the picked. I think Trubisky is legit and that Watson is more refined passer than Cam Newton coming out of college and is being overly criticized even though he has been the best qb in college for the last two seasons

The most highly rated QB in the last ten years was Luck. How's that looking right now? Rated 16th at the moment. So there is no such thing as a QB coming into the NFL without questions. Many preferred RGIII to Luck because the power run game at Stanford helped himi so much. Just the way it is.

Luck is rated 14th in passer rating according to ESPN, but is 8th in passing yards per game and 6th in total yards per game (behind Brees, Cousins, Ryan, Brady, and Rodgers). He still looks like a top 10 QB easily. Swap him with Dak Prescott and he'd be MVP of the league. A few people preferred RGIII, but Luck was as close to a consensus #1 pick as it gets. Sadly, there is no Andrew Luck prospect at the QB position this year so there's a decent shot the top QB won't pan out.
Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:
Luck is rated 14th in passer rating according to ESPN, but is 8th in passing yards per game and 6th in total yards per game (behind Brees, Cousins, Ryan, Brady, and Rodgers). He still looks like a top 10 QB easily. Swap him with Dak Prescott and he'd be MVP of the league. A few people preferred RGIII, but Luck was as close to a consensus #1 pick as it gets. Sadly, there is no Andrew Luck prospect at the QB position this year so there's a decent shot the top QB won't pan out.

Exactly, and 16th in yards. I'm not saying Luck isn't a good QB, just saying there were questions about him coming in to the NLF and he was as close to a lock as there is. So trying to find a QB in the draft with no questions is a fools errand.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Exactly, and 16th in yards. I'm not saying Luck isn't a good QB, just saying there were questions about him coming in to the NLF and he was as close to a lock as there is. So trying to find a QB in the draft with no questions is a fools errand.

What were the questions coming out about Luck? I feel like I remember him being a sure thing
Originally posted by illinois9er:
What were the questions coming out about Luck? I feel like I remember him being a sure thing

He was a sure fire prospect but guys like Luck are extremely rare. If teams only drafted QBs when they were in position to draft a guy like Luck or Peyton Manning there would be 2 or 3 teams with QBs in the NFL.


The vast majority of successful QBs were drafted with quite a few questions about their ability to perform at the NFL level.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:
Luck is rated 14th in passer rating according to ESPN, but is 8th in passing yards per game and 6th in total yards per game (behind Brees, Cousins, Ryan, Brady, and Rodgers). He still looks like a top 10 QB easily. Swap him with Dak Prescott and he'd be MVP of the league. A few people preferred RGIII, but Luck was as close to a consensus #1 pick as it gets. Sadly, there is no Andrew Luck prospect at the QB position this year so there's a decent shot the top QB won't pan out.

Exactly, and 16th in yards. I'm not saying Luck isn't a good QB, just saying there were questions about him coming in to the NLF and he was as close to a lock as there is. So trying to find a QB in the draft with no questions is a fools errand.

16th in yards because he's played 10 games while other guys have played 11 or 12. He's actually ahead of Rodgers in total yards per game, so he's 5th not 6th. Definitely not bad numbers considering he's playing behind a pretty bad offensive line and was missing Moncrief for a number of games this year. He was NFL ready in college coming from a pro style offense with no character concerns and all the physical tools you could ask for, so there weren't a lot of questions with him, but he's the exception.

Definitely agree that all the guys coming out this year have questions though. I'd much rather have Garrett at #2 than a QB since I don't think there is a lot of separation between the top 3 QBs. If one of them falls to the 15-20 range, do what it takes to trade up for them. Otherwise, draft a guy like Mahomes, Rudolph, or Webb to develop and possibly pick another QB in the first round in 2018 depending on how they are looking.
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
This class sucks
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone