Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
The vast majority of top qbs drafted come with concerns. Phillio Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, and Matthew Stafford to name a few. Then you get those that validate the concerns like Gabbert, Lienart, Vince Young, Ponder, and Sanchez.
I just think the reward is worth the gamble to draft a highly talented qb in the first. I wish we could hit the lottery like Dak, but for every Dak there are 20+ Giovanni Carmazzis.
All those names you just threw out for examples are wayyyyyy better qb prospects then who's currently gonna be in the draft this yr...it's not really close.
I agree there's question marks for most qb prospects if there wasn't we wouldn't be able to draft them unless we were 1 anyway.
I also agree players like Dak, Wilson, cousins, Montana who are 3rd and later picks don't come around every yr BUT the talent at the top just isn't there IMO. I like Watson and Mitch and wouldn't hate it at all if they were the pick. I also wouldn't hate to have kap for another yr or two while a qb grooms for the positon and we get players that are rated much higher than the qbs in this draft with our 1st.
Ryan drafted #3 in the 1st round, Cam #1 1st round, #11 1st round, Rivers #4 1st round, #1 1st round...guess I'd have to ask for a definition of concern. These guys were really well thought of but I suppose any pick can be second guessed or nitpicked. The point being made is the first round picks are decent risks compared to later rounds and there is just no way to argue against that point. Just look at all the starting QBs in the NFL and you will see how few were drafted after the first. Brady is the exception everyone likes to point to but he was similar to Montana in college, having to fight through battles with other QBs and injury to earn a starting role.