Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 700 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by NYniner85:


Why do 99% of all air raid qbs fail in the NFL?



The vast majority of Air Raid QBs fail in the NFL because they were marginal talents in the first place. The vast majority of QBs that are taken in the 5th, 6th, 7th rounds and that go undrafted fail regardless of the offense they played in.


Tim Couch is pretty much the best Air Raid prospect to come out and he got killed behind an expansion OL, injuries destroyed his career. Bruce Arians who was his OC for a time still speaks fondly of him and blames the Browns for ruining him.



The book is out on Goff. If he thrives, that will help to rewrite the script on Air Raid QBs.


Brandon Weeden is a guy that was way overdrafted, Ron Wolf even questioned what Holmgren saw him, saying that Green Bay Holmgren would never have taken him.


Geno Smith right off the bat came off as immature, teams questioned what he had going on between the ears and his overall work ethic more than anything else.


Beyond those guys, almost every other Air Raid QB in the NFL was a late draft pick or went undrafted.


Ultimately it takes just one guy to thrive for that thought process to change. Just like how it used to be said that spread QBs couldnt be successful in the NFL yet Drew Brees, Big Ben, Phillip Rivers, Cam Newton, Joe Flacco and this year Marcus Mariota and Dak Prescott have successfully made the transition.


To immediately rule out a prospect because of the offense they played in or the head coach they played under doesnt make much sense to me.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 18, 2016 at 4:27 PM ]
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
The vast majority of Air Raid QBs fail in the NFL because they were marginal talents in the first place. The vast majority of QBs that are taken in the 5th, 6th, 7th rounds and that go undrafted fail regardless of the offense they played in.


Tim Couch is pretty much the best Air Raid prospect to come out and he got killed behind an expansion OL, injuries destroyed his career. Bruce Arians who was his OC for a time still speaks fondly of him and blames the Browns for ruining him.



The book is out on Goff. If he thrives, that will help to rewrite the script on Air Raid QBs.


Brandon Weeden is a guy that was way overdrafted, Ron Wolf even questioned what Holmgren saw him, saying that Green Bay Holmgren would never have taken him.


Geno Smith right off the bat came off as immature, teams questioned what he had going on between the ears and his overall work ethic more than anything else.


Beyond those guys, almost every other Air Raid QB was a late draft pick.


Ultimately it takes just one guy to thrive for that thought process to change. Just like how it used to be said that spread QBs couldnt be successful in the NFL yet Drew Brees, Big Ben, Phillip Rivers, Cam Newton, Joe Flacco and this year Marcus Mariota and Dak Prescott have successfully made the transition.


To immediately rule out a prospect because of the offense they played in or the head coach they played under doesnt make much sense to me.

Never said I was ruling him out ever...I've said I'm gonna raise my hand when someone brings up stats when including someone that comes from a offensive scheme like the one he plays in and I think that's fair.

He could very well become a good qb, but I think there is a bigger transition for someone that's played in that offense compared to other prospects and IMO that drops him down. We are a team that doesn't currently have that bridge qb that can play while he learns...I'd rather invest that 2nd rd pick in a possible trade for Jimmy G.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
The vast majority of Air Raid QBs fail in the NFL because they were marginal talents in the first place. The vast majority of QBs that are taken in the 5th, 6th, 7th rounds and that go undrafted fail regardless of the offense they played in.


Tim Couch is pretty much the best Air Raid prospect to come out and he got killed behind an expansion OL, injuries destroyed his career. Bruce Arians who was his OC for a time still speaks fondly of him and blames the Browns for ruining him.



The book is out on Goff. If he thrives, that will help to rewrite the script on Air Raid QBs.


Brandon Weeden is a guy that was way overdrafted, Ron Wolf even questioned what Holmgren saw him, saying that Green Bay Holmgren would never have taken him.


Geno Smith right off the bat came off as immature, teams questioned what he had going on between the ears and his overall work ethic more than anything else.


Beyond those guys, almost every other Air Raid QB in the NFL was a late draft pick or went undrafted.


Ultimately it takes just one guy to thrive for that thought process to change. Just like how it used to be said that spread QBs couldnt be successful in the NFL yet Drew Brees, Big Ben, Phillip Rivers, Cam Newton, Joe Flacco and this year Marcus Mariota and Dak Prescott have successfully made the transition.


To immediately rule out a prospect because of the offense they played in or the head coach they played under doesnt make much sense to me.

My question would be--how do you analyze a Leach QB? Is he that great a coach? He has had very successful college QBs who were marginal or less in the NFL. They set collegiate records yet made no dent as pros.

Next question would be...is Leach's system(s) good enough to make it in the NFL if he were the coach? Or is the scheme college only?

Walsh's offense was considered a gimmick system until he started winning SBs...is Kelly the same? Or was Walsh just a superior coach? I would argue that a great coach can make many systems work with the right personnel, but lesser coaches don't rise to the level because they just don't know how to adjust within the system.

Lastly, if Falk, or any QB, has similar stats to others who failed in the NFL...how do you evaluate him? I guess you can watch his mechanics and try to compare them to others?
  • FL9er
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,889
There's apparently a picture of Chad Kelly rolling a blunt circulating on the internet.
Originally posted by FL9er:
There's apparently a picture of Chad Kelly rolling a blunt circulating on the internet.

Lol what a loser
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Never said I was ruling him out ever...I've said I'm gonna raise my hand when someone brings up stats when including someone that comes from a offensive scheme like the one he plays in and I think that's fair.

He could very well become a good qb, but I think there is a bigger transition for someone that's played in that offense compared to other prospects and IMO that drops him down. We are a team that doesn't currently have that bridge qb that can play while he learns...I'd rather invest that 2nd rd pick in a possible trade for Jimmy G.

Yup. I don't recall anybody in this thread saying Falk was a poor prospect -- certainly not recently. But he has some very major concerns when it comes to projecting him at the NFL level. Some of that will be worked out in the evaluation process, some of it won't. But you're right -- throwing passing stats out there for guys from Air Raid offenses doesn't exactly make a strong case to support the argument that they have what it takes in the NFL. These Air Raid QBs BETTER be completing 70%+ of their passes. 70% completion rate is the starting point for an Air Raid QB, not a point of pride.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
The vast majority of Air Raid QBs fail in the NFL because they were marginal talents in the first place. The vast majority of QBs that are taken in the 5th, 6th, 7th rounds and that go undrafted fail regardless of the offense they played in.


Tim Couch is pretty much the best Air Raid prospect to come out and he got killed behind an expansion OL, injuries destroyed his career. Bruce Arians who was his OC for a time still speaks fondly of him and blames the Browns for ruining him.



The book is out on Goff. If he thrives, that will help to rewrite the script on Air Raid QBs.


Brandon Weeden is a guy that was way overdrafted, Ron Wolf even questioned what Holmgren saw him, saying that Green Bay Holmgren would never have taken him.


Geno Smith right off the bat came off as immature, teams questioned what he had going on between the ears and his overall work ethic more than anything else.


Beyond those guys, almost every other Air Raid QB in the NFL was a late draft pick or went undrafted.


Ultimately it takes just one guy to thrive for that thought process to change. Just like how it used to be said that spread QBs couldnt be successful in the NFL yet Drew Brees, Big Ben, Phillip Rivers, Cam Newton, Joe Flacco and this year Marcus Mariota and Dak Prescott have successfully made the transition.


To immediately rule out a prospect because of the offense they played in or the head coach they played under doesnt make much sense to me.

My question would be--how do you analyze a Leach QB? Is he that great a coach? He has had very successful college QBs who were marginal or less in the NFL. They set collegiate records yet made no dent as pros.

Next question would be...is Leach's system(s) good enough to make it in the NFL if he were the coach? Or is the scheme college only?

Walsh's offense was considered a gimmick system until he started winning SBs...is Kelly the same? Or was Walsh just a superior coach? I would argue that a great coach can make many systems work with the right personnel, but lesser coaches don't rise to the level because they just don't know how to adjust within the system.

Lastly, if Falk, or any QB, has similar stats to others who failed in the NFL...how do you evaluate him? I guess you can watch his mechanics and try to compare them to others?
Very true. It is for this reason that I am really serious as to how Chip Kelly performs with 3 - 4 years and his own QB. The one thing I will say about Walsh is that, he had his QB in Montana, right out of the gate, and was able to make Steve DeBerg look decent in terms of the numbers he was putting up. I wasn't alive to really watch the origins, but from what I have read, stats I see compared to other QBs at the time, and hearing from a few fans at the time that shared stories, this seems to be the case. I believe Chip Kelly has already had his Steve DeBerg's with the QB situations in Philly. I want to see what his offense looks like when he has his own guy.

The other thing that I will say about Bill Walsh is that he had innovative minds and great coaches on BOTH sides of the ball. Bobb McKitrick, Sam Wyche, and George Seifert in the early days. I see some positive things our offense does. I have hopes for more in the future. The defense, not so much. But we will see what happens as the season progresses with Dorsey out there at nose tackle.
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Yah cause okdkid just knows what everyone wants as their QB, even though names like Kizer, Watson and Trubisky an next years draft Jake Browning, Josh Rosen have been thrown around numerous times.


Hey sir. I enjoy your posts. But I didn't comment on what every other team wants as their QB. Nor did I say Falk was a bad prospect. Falk may be the dream prospect some claim he is, or he may not. We'll see one way or the other.

I said he has some big concerns that need to be addressed. Also, I said he is getting some Goff-like treatment around here. That's fine -- people are free to have their opinions. Though, when the hype gets ramped up (as it has in recent weeks) I think it's more than fair to evaluate him as judiciously.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
My question would be--how do you analyze a Leach QB?

How do you analyze any QB? You look at their whole body of work, their game tape, you put them through their paces during workouts, you analyze closely how they responded to adversity, how they performed under pressure, when face with a relentless pass rush, did they wilt or did they consistently step up and perform? How did they do accuracy wise when required to throw into tight windows? How are their mechanics? Physically how well are they suited for the NFL?

Did they show consistent improvement throughout college? This to me has always been a huge factor. If you're not progressively improving against college competition, is it reasonable to expect that the lights will suddenly turn on in the NFL? Its a big reason why I liked Dak Prescott so much last year, the improvement he had made reflected a tremendous amount of hard work on his part.


I don't think it requires any special approach, you treat them like any other QB and you see how they stack up to their peers. The vast majority of Air Raid QB's didn't stack up, largely for physical reasons, you had guys that were too small or lacked even the bare minimum for NFL caliber arm strength, guys who simply couldn't handle any type of advanced passing concepts and proved it quickly in offseason whiteboard work and workouts.


The Air Raid is a fantastic offense for guys who will lack the talent to perform at the NFL level but it doesn't mean that every QB that plays in the Air Raid lacks the talent to play in the NFL.




Is he that great a coach? He has had very successful college QBs who were marginal or less in the NFL. They set collegiate records yet made no dent as pros.


Leach is a pretty good, not great coach but its not like he was ever at QB U. He mostly had marginal QB's, lightly recruited guys that came in and fit with the system and never really showed the aptitude to perform at the NFL level, which isn't that uncommon.

Leach values accuracy and footwork over everything else, disregarding size, arm strength and so on. The result ends up being guys that may have been overlooked by other programs, who are fantastic college QB's but possess too many limitations to translate to the NFL.

Great college player doesn't mean great NFL player. Michael Sam was a fantastic college DE, played in a top conference but playing in college was pretty much his ceiling. He lacked the measurables and athleticism to be anything more than a rotational player at best. However that didn't say anything about other DE's coming out of Missouri and their NFL suitability.



Next question would be...is Leach's system(s) good enough to make it in the NFL if he were the coach? Or is the scheme college only?


The scheme as he runs at WSU would need some modifications for the NFL level but portions of the Air Raid have been incorporated into many NFL offenses, the original basis for the offense was the WCO and the more "college-ized" version that LaVell Edwards ran at BYU with Steve Young as quarterback. I don't know what sort of NFL coach Leach would be, my guess, based on the success record of college coaches, not great.





Walsh's offense was considered a gimmick system until he started winning SBs...is Kelly the same? Or was Walsh just a superior coach? I would argue that a great coach can make many systems work with the right personnel, but lesser coaches don't rise to the level because they just don't know how to adjust within the system.


I don't think we'll really know until Kelly gets better talent on the roster, especially at QB. He has never really had HIS QB, a guy who can run his offense at a high level. The QB is especially crucial in Kelly's offense because of the many RPO plays that get called where the QB has to make the quick decision post-snap to pass, hand off or run....etc. It requires quick-thinking, quick feet and outstanding accuracy on the part of the quarterback and Kelly hasn't had that guy.




Lastly, if Falk, or any QB, has similar stats to others who failed in the NFL...how do you evaluate him? I guess you can watch his mechanics and try to compare them to others?


You evaluate each prospect on their own merits, when you try to lump them in with other players, I think that is when teams screw up. Teams evaluated Derek Carr in comparison to his brother, they evaluated Dak Prescott in comparison to Tim Tebow, when Aaron Rodgers game out there were countless stories about how Tedford QB's can never get it done in the NFL.


I think its irrelevant what any other QB before Falk has done, you go through his game tape, you look for the intangibles, the leadership on and off the field, the consistent accuracy, you look at the mechanics, how they respond after they take a hard shot, do they get up and keep fighting or do they wilt? How do they react after they turn the ball over, does their performance drop off for the rest of the game or do they have a short memory and come back firing again? How consistent is their footwork, do they get happy feet in the pocket, do they drop their eyes when pressured and as a result miss wide open receivers down the field?

There are universal things that apply to every single QB regardless of offense.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 18, 2016 at 6:36 PM ]
Originally posted by okdkid:
Yup. I don't recall anybody in this thread saying Falk was a poor prospect -- certainly not recently. But he has some very major concerns when it comes to projecting him at the NFL level. Some of that will be worked out in the evaluation process, some of it won't. But you're right -- throwing passing stats out there for guys from Air Raid offenses doesn't exactly make a strong case to support the argument that they have what it takes in the NFL. These Air Raid QBs BETTER be completing 70%+ of their passes. 70% completion rate is the starting point for an Air Raid QB, not a point of pride.

That's all I'm saying
Originally posted by FL9er:
There's apparently a picture of Chad Kelly rolling a blunt circulating on the internet.

He'll be a nice undrafted free agent for someone down the road.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
My question would be--how do you analyze a Leach QB?

How do you analyze any QB? You look at their whole body of work, their game tape, you put them through their paces during workouts, you analyze closely how they responded to adversity, how they performed under pressure, when face with a relentless pass rush, did they wilt or did they consistently step up and perform? How did they do accuracy wise when required to throw into tight windows? How are their mechanics? Physically how well are they suited for the NFL?

Did they show consistent improvement throughout college? This to me has always been a huge factor. If you're not progressively improving against college competition, is it reasonable to expect that the lights will suddenly turn on in the NFL? Its a big reason why I liked Dak Prescott so much last year, the improvement he had made reflected a tremendous amount of hard work on his part.


I don't think it requires any special approach, you treat them like any other QB and you see how they stack up to their peers. The vast majority of Air Raid QB's didn't stack up, largely for physical reasons, you had guys that were too small or lacked even the bare minimum for NFL caliber arm strength, guys who simply couldn't handle any type of advanced passing concepts and proved it quickly in offseason whiteboard work and workouts.


The Air Raid is a fantastic offense for guys who will lack the talent to perform at the NFL level but it doesn't mean that every QB that plays in the Air Raid lacks the talent to play in the NFL.




Is he that great a coach? He has had very successful college QBs who were marginal or less in the NFL. They set collegiate records yet made no dent as pros.


Leach is a pretty good, not great coach but its not like he was ever at QB U. He mostly had marginal QB's, lightly recruited guys that came in and fit with the system and never really showed the aptitude to perform at the NFL level, which isn't that uncommon.

Leach values accuracy and footwork over everything else, disregarding size, arm strength and so on. The result ends up being guys that may have been overlooked by other programs, who are fantastic college QB's but possess too many limitations to translate to the NFL.

Great college player doesn't mean great NFL player. Michael Sam was a fantastic college DE, played in a top conference but playing in college was pretty much his ceiling. He lacked the measurables and athleticism to be anything more than a rotational player at best. However that didn't say anything about other DE's coming out of Missouri and their NFL suitability.



Next question would be...is Leach's system(s) good enough to make it in the NFL if he were the coach? Or is the scheme college only?


The scheme as he runs at WSU would need some modifications for the NFL level but portions of the Air Raid have been incorporated into many NFL offenses, the original basis for the offense was the WCO and the more "college-ized" version that LaVell Edwards ran at BYU with Steve Young as quarterback. I don't know what sort of NFL coach Leach would be, my guess, based on the success record of college coaches, not great.





Walsh's offense was considered a gimmick system until he started winning SBs...is Kelly the same? Or was Walsh just a superior coach? I would argue that a great coach can make many systems work with the right personnel, but lesser coaches don't rise to the level because they just don't know how to adjust within the system.


I don't think we'll really know until Kelly gets better talent on the roster, especially at QB. He has never really had HIS QB, a guy who can run his offense at a high level. The QB is especially crucial in Kelly's offense because of the many RPO plays that get called where the QB has to make the quick decision post-snap to pass, hand off or run....etc. It requires quick-thinking, quick feet and outstanding accuracy on the part of the quarterback and Kelly hasn't had that guy.




Lastly, if Falk, or any QB, has similar stats to others who failed in the NFL...how do you evaluate him? I guess you can watch his mechanics and try to compare them to others?


You evaluate each prospect on their own merits, when you try to lump them in with other players, I think that is when teams screw up. Teams evaluated Derek Carr in comparison to his brother, they evaluated Dak Prescott in comparison to Tim Tebow, when Aaron Rodgers game out there were countless stories about how Tedford QB's can never get it done in the NFL.


I think its irrelevant what any other QB before Falk has done, you go through his game tape, you look for the intangibles, the leadership on and off the field, the consistent accuracy, you look at the mechanics, how they respond after they take a hard shot, do they get up and keep fighting or do they wilt? How do they react after they turn the ball over, does their performance drop off for the rest of the game or do they have a short memory and come back firing again? How consistent is their footwork, do they get happy feet in the pocket, do they drop their eyes when pressured and as a result miss wide open receivers down the field?

There are universal things that apply to every single QB regardless of offense.

Thanks for the response Phoenix! I'm not an expert evaluating QBs but it seems difficult to do unless you have access to more than game day info. When I watch Trubisky, for instance, I see a guy who has great potential and seems to make intelligent decisions, but then...is he athletic enough? Does he have the arm strength? A lot of guys can throw long but not from varying angles, posture.

Anyway...I see "experts" listing Kizer, Watson and Trubisky as the best QB in the draft. All three can't be. But I guess that's why we contribute and share thoughts on here...trying to figure out what's best for the team.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Nov 18, 2016 at 7:12 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Thanks for the response Phoenix! I'm not an expert evaluating QBs but it seems difficult to do unless you have access to more than game day info. When I watch Trubisky, for instance, I see a guy who has great potential and seems to make intelligent decisions, but then...is he athletic enough? Does he have the arm strength? A lot of guys can throw long but not from varying angles, posture.

Anyway...I see "experts" listing Kizer, Watson and Trubisky as the best QB in the draft. All three can't be. But I guess that's why we contribute and share thoughts on here...trying to figure out what's best for the team.


They get a whole lot of info during the offseason process when they can sit down and interview the player, work them out, watch them perform at offseason events and the Combine, it allows them to determine if what is on tape matches up with what they see right there in front of them, also allows them to directly compare how these guys stack up to their peers.

Teams will screw around with prospects during the interviews in particular, put them on the spot, see how they respond to difficult questions, throw some really challenging whiteboard work at them to observe not necessarily if the QB does everything correctly but how their though process goes, are they quick to quit, how is their capacity for problem solving, that kind of thing.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 18, 2016 at 7:23 PM ]
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
They get a whole lot of info during the offseason process when they can sit down and interview the player, work them out, watch them perform at offseason events and the Combine, it allows them to determine if what is on tape matches up with what they see right there in front of them, also allows them to directly compare how these guys stack up to their peers.

Teams will screw around with prospects during the interviews in particular, put them on the spot, see how they respond to difficult questions, throw some really challenging whiteboard work at them to observe not necessarily if the QB does everything correctly but how their though process goes, are they quick to quit, how is their capacity for problem solving, that kind of thing.

Yes, good points. I've always wanted to be a fly on the wall for these interviews and the war room discussions. Montana had some questions to answer and Walsh waited until the 3rd round to pull the trigger. At ND he showed an ability to come from behind and elevate his play in Bowl games, had some great physical tools but size and durability were issues. Sometimes it's luck...and coaching after the draft.
Good game today between (10)Colorado vs (22)Washington state at 1230 pacific time at Fox. KNBR Tolbert and Lund had Phil Steele as guest the other day going over this game. He was again asked about Falk regarding the draft. He said Gil Brandt and other NFL evaluators have a first round grade on him and is in the conversation for the first 2 QB taken. He was saying they see all the traits that Phoenix was talking about. Falk will be facing a very good defense today.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone