Originally posted by nannite:
Would Clausen be a upgrade over Smith? Would Clausen be a long term answer at QB?
Most of us would say no, but you obviously would say yes. Theres not much to argue about.
Considering what Smith has done to date in the league, and that Clausen has yet to play a snap but has a ton of untapped potential and upside, the move should be welcomed by 49er fans. Again Smith has not proven to be the answer so a QB with 1st round potential that could come in and sit for the year and learn the system would be a good thing. If Smith falls this year then you are back to square 1, looking to the draft and there is no guarantee you will be in a position to get a QB 1st round potential.
Originally posted by nannite:
As for Nate Davis, he has many advantages over Clausen:
-no pressure from being drafted high, will have time to learn the position as a backup
-does not have a debilitating personality disorder (ie douchebaggery)
-was as successful, if not more successful, in college
-has as good of, if not better, tools
Its not a black and white argument. I'm not saying Nate Davis will be successful and Clausen won't be successful. But based on their situations, personalities, physical tools and past success, I would give Nate Davis higher odds of succeeding in the NFL.
He also has drawbacks....
-a 5th round developmental QB project, how often do those guys turn out to be franchise QB's ? Chances are he will be nothing more than a career backup at best, could be wrong but chances are not in Davis' favor.
-He has a learning disability, like it or not it is just another obstacle to overcome in developing said QB and likely means more time needed to develop him.
-Clausen's numbers from his junior season are far more impressive than Peyton Manning, Eli Manning, Matt Stafford and Mark Sanchez to name a few, Davis is not even close to being in the same class.
- Phillip Rivers is a QB known for being cocky and brash like Clausen, so this attitude that so many love to hate is not necc. a bad thing. It's just something the Clausen haters love to try and use against him. I'd take Rivers and his attitude in a heartbeat on this team.
And no Nate Davis does not have higher odds of succeeding, if he did he would have been drafted higher, that's been cut and dry.