Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 485 users in the forums

Why do the Niners sit and watch the league get better?

  • seanh
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 41
Originally posted by Gavintech:
Originally posted by StOnEy333:
Originally posted by boast:
Originally posted by Dshearn:
Originally posted by ads_2006:
^^^There arent any qb's like Brees or Warner available right now

Warner was last season and we went after him.

Trading for Mcnabb now, with only 1 year left on his contract would not help the 49ers... unless he signs an extension.

Mcnabb will probably play out the year and then leave to the Vikings


i would put mcnabb in the class or warner.

He never had the weapons Warner has had OTHER then his year with TO and he has allways performed.



Mcnabb would sign I bet... OR franchise him...

ahahahahaha!

Warner is a HoF QB.



Is he? He's only had about 6 good seasons. Many, many elite players don't think that's enough to be a HoFer. No matter how good those 6 season were.

His numbers make him a HOF'er. Not to mention the MVPs and super-bowl MVP.

Agreed, and his 3rd SB appearance pretty much made him a lock.
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
I may be the only person on the board with this opinion, but I really don't think McNabb would even be interested in signing a contract extension with us.

Why not? The only potential issue between us and him is offensive coordinator and scheme and we all know Jimmy Raye is replaceable. If McNabb struggles Raye's gone and back comes the WCO.

Yes, because everything is that black and white when you live in Maddenland.

You guys are the ones living in Madden land. Artificially boosting Alex Smith's ratings to a 75 that way he looks like a presentable QB in this league. He's got 99 speed what a beast!!!

This is common sense. Jimmy Raye is a stop gap coordinator who barely got a vote confidence this offseason. To think that we're committed to him and his system is laughable. BTW. This is a make or break for Singletary too. New GM plus failed expectations equals new coaching staff.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
I may be the only person on the board with this opinion, but I really don't think McNabb would even be interested in signing a contract extension with us.

Why not? The only potential issue between us and him is offensive coordinator and scheme and we all know Jimmy Raye is replaceable. If McNabb struggles Raye's gone and back comes the WCO.

Yes, because everything is that black and white when you live in Maddenland.

You guys are the ones living in Madden land. Artificially boosting Alex Smith's ratings to a 75 that way he looks like a presentable QB in this league. He's got 99 speed what a beast!!!

This is common sense. Jimmy Raye is a stop gap coordinator who barely got a vote confidence this offseason. To think that we're committed to him and his system is laughable. BTW. This is a make or break for Singletary too. New GM plus failed expectations equals new coaching staff.

1) Do I really go around this forum pumping up Alex Smith? No, but I am willing to give him this season to see if he can improve and step up his game. If he doesn't he's gone, plain and simple.

2) I never said Jimmy Raye was the solution, obviously he isn't. Mike Johnson seems to me to be the logical successor to Jimmy Raye, and I believe he will probably be moving up after this season if all goes well.

I still don't think McNabb would want to sign an extension to come here, and nothing you can say will convince me otherwise. If it happens it happens, I'll believe it when I see it.

Originally posted by momoney925:
i was thinking the same.
but i always try to make myself feel better and think that we'll do just fine without the big names.

Yeah this makes a lot of sense moron925. briliantly stupid!!
Originally posted by ninerprophet:
Originally posted by momoney925:
i was thinking the same.
but i always try to make myself feel better and think that we'll do just fine without the big names.

Yeah this makes a lot of sense moron925. briliantly stupid!!

who would you have got this year?
Originally posted by ninerprophet:
Originally posted by momoney925:
i was thinking the same.
but i always try to make myself feel better and think that we'll do just fine without the big names.

Yeah this makes a lot of sense moron925. briliantly stupid!!
Originally posted by Dominate:
Look at the 2 superbowl teams from this year N.O. and IND. All of their BIG NAME players were drafted except for Brees. And Brees wasnt considered a big time player when he signed with NO. Pay attention to the rest of the league, we arent doing anything different.


I am fine with what we have done or not done in FA, but last time I checked Darren Sharper was not drafted by the Saints. I don't believe their top linebacker was either.
He was drafted by the Jets.

Thank God we don't have Dan Snyder as our owner. I'd be p****d if the York's spent money like he did with no dividends yielded.

As for the Lions and Bears, that's a different story. How many games has Detroit won in the past two or three years? At least they now have a coach and GM who understand the building of football teams.

Chicago, well they have no draft choices so they have to do what they can do.

We have two first round draft choices and at least one in every other round. This
is one of the deepest drafts in years. Let's build the team from the draft.

Why would you want to sign a OT that the Ravens don't want and who probably has injury problems as well. How much b***hing did we hear about Glassman and Marvel Smith.

Oh, let's sign McNabb. He took his team to the SB once. He's 33 years old and about to be beaten out by a drafted QB or a convicted felon. Let's sell the franchise for the next three years to pick up an aging QB who plays a completely different offense than we are set up to do. That makes a lot of sense.

Some of this drivel on here is pathetic.
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by m_brockalexander:
Originally posted by bracus:
Originally posted by valrod33:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by bracus:
Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
With some of the mediocre players that got ridiculously overpaid this offseason, you should be thanking your lucky f**king stars that we didn't spend a crapload of money in free agency.

Apparently you guys don't understand. Did you guys misinterpret the whole thing? Not once did I say make Antrelle Rolle the highest paid safety in league history. This was a weak@$$ free agency. If your saying we can only have McNabb by overpaying, then I ask you this. What draft pick would you give to feel like you have a really damn good chance to get to the NFC Championship or possibly superbowl?
Because as I see it know it seems like we have a 50/50 chance to make the playoffs.

look, you mentioned something about having another QB as our starter, other than Alex....that is enough to have some go crazy over here ....and basically disregard any point you are trying to make with the rest of your post.

What point is he trying to make? The name of the thread is "why do the niners sit and watch the league get better" then when he is asked what teams have gotten better he has no answer and responds with even more gibberish

JETS VIKES PATRIOTS CHARGERS that enough for ya?

Jets - Besides signing an over the hill LT, what did they do in free agency? Signed a PK (Nick Folk), someone let go by the Browns (Brodney Pool), a no name LB (Lance Laury), and Rodrigue Wright who wasn't even playing football last year.

Wow! I'm stunned. What a great offseason!

Do you want me to continue with the rest of the analysis?

how can you leave out, them trading for Antonio Cromartie.....having him play opposite of Revis....heck he might even look better with his new coaching staff.

and although it was not this offseason, but they traded for Braylon Edwards during the season.....they traded up to get Sanchez last offseason.

look although most of these moves might not have happened this offseason.....atleast they were making moves....while we are still trying Oh So hard for Alex to prove everyone in the FO right.

Trading for which Cromartie? The one who was a Pro Bowl performer a couple of years ago or the one who struggled the last two years? He had 10 INT's in 2007 and he only had 5 INT's the last two years combined. Hell, he fathered just as many kids in the last two years with different women. Don't confuse activity with success just yet........
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone