Source Carr asking for: 2-3 Million per year!

f**k NO

I wouldnt pay a dime over vet minimum.

2 Mil a year is average for a backup QB.

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
2 Mil a year is average for a backup QB.

I believe it's how much Smith gets paid.

But if that is the case, I would rather have Hill over Carr.

-9fA

Pass, that is not realistic for a back up. He would be making more than our starters last year!

Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
2 Mil a year is average for a backup QB.

I believe it's how much Smith gets paid.

But in this case, I would still rather have Hill over Carr.

-9fA

Smith was 3 Million a year if I recall after he restructured. He would have made a s**tload more than that if he hadn't (but obviously we wouldn't have kept him at that salary).

seems reasonable to me. i wouldn't want to sign him with nate still on the team.

Stop f**king around and just trade for McNabb.

Originally posted by susweel:
Stop f**king around and just trade for McNabb.

It's not gonna happen, get the f**k over it.

Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
2 Mil a year is average for a backup QB.

I believe it's how much Smith gets paid.

But in this case, I would still rather have Hill over Carr.

-9fA

why??

Carr has actual talent. he was a former number 1 overall pick for a reason. Hill is a lifelong backup with a noodle arm, and hes getting old. Carr also has alot more starting experience.

like Smith, Carr never really had a real chance to succeed. he kind of bounced around the league. Smith is lucky his career didnt take the Carr route, and his comeback after injuries was successful.

i think Carr would be a very solid backup. it keeps Smith on his toes for his job, and provides a guy with starting experience, and natural talent, if Smith goes down. Hill skipping 30 yard passes off peoples feet isnt acceptable, especially in the spread offense the niners are installing.

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:

Originally posted by susweel:
Stop f**king around and just trade for McNabb.

It's not gonna happen, get the f**k over it.

Dont cuss at me.

get the f**k outta here!
no body wanted ur backup ass anyway

f**kin david carr lmao

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:

Originally posted by susweel:
Stop f**king around and just trade for McNabb.

It's not gonna happen, get the f**k over it.

Dont cuss at me.

Originally posted by Niners99:

Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
2 Mil a year is average for a backup QB.

I believe it's how much Smith gets paid.

But in this case, I would still rather have Hill over Carr.

-9fA

why??

Carr has actual talent. he was a former number 1 overall pick for a reason. Hill is a lifelong backup with a noodle arm, and hes getting old. Carr also has alot more starting experience.

like Smith, Carr never really had a real chance to succeed. he kind of bounced around the league. Smith is lucky his career didnt take the Carr route, and his comeback after injuries was successful.

i think Carr would be a very solid backup. it keeps Smith on his toes for his job, and provides a guy with starting experience, and natural talent, if Smith goes down. Hill skipping 30 yard passes off peoples feet isnt acceptable, especially in the spread offense the niners are installing.

We're not really installing a spread offense. According to what Sing said in a KNBR interview a couple weeks back, he wants to continue running the ball to open up the field more. So I think we're gonna have a more balanced offense.

Originally posted by Niners99:

Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:

Originally posted by PA9erFaithful:
2 Mil a year is average for a backup QB.

I believe it's how much Smith gets paid.

But in this case, I would still rather have Hill over Carr.

-9fA

why??

Carr has actual talent. he was a former number 1 overall pick for a reason. Hill is a lifelong backup with a noodle arm, and hes getting old. Carr also has alot more starting experience.

like Smith, Carr never really had a real chance to succeed. he kind of bounced around the league. Smith is lucky his career didnt take the Carr route, and his comeback after injuries was successful.

i think Carr would be a very solid backup. it keeps Smith on his toes for his job, and provides a guy with starting experience, and natural talent, if Smith goes down. Hill skipping 30 yard passes off peoples feet isnt acceptable, especially in the spread offense the niners are installing.

Shaun Hill made 1.5 Million last year! Alex Smith made 3 million last year.

it looks like Carr will sign a 2 or 2.5 mill annually! their is no way they will pay him more than Alex Smith.

My source says it would be a 3 yr deal worth officially 6-7.5 Million! ill tell you when its 100%