Should the niners trade for or sign a FA QB next year?

How about Michael Vick He got chance On doing great here at SF....

Originally posted by fanmusclecars:

Originally posted by King49er:
Should have signed Warner

God told Warner don't go to San Fran.

lol

We got our future QB on the roster......and his name is Nate Davis. There is not alot of good QB´s out there, lest stick with our current QB´s and give Davis time. Remember, if he had a better Bowl game last january, he would have been drafted much, much higher. But im biased, he was my favourite QB in college football last year.

Originally posted by Dino:
Alex Smith for Peyton Manning

Manning is too old, and he has already peaked.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Trade for Brady Quinn or draft Sam Bradford, Dan Lefevour or Greg McElroy (if he comes out).

Brady Quinn = Shaun Hill East



With you on Bradford

Nah, I just think Quinn needs to be on a different team. No one is gonna succeed with Mangini there. Quinn has a pretty good arm, footwork and poise in the pocket, worked in a Pro offense in college, he just needs a different team.

Quinn just isn't a good QB.

Sign Chad Pennington to a 2 years contract at the end of the season (guy is a winner when he is healthy) and draft a young QB to actually sit behind the guy and learn. Pennington is deadly accurate and would be able to carve up defenses with Davis and Crabtree running routes for him.

Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
i think next years draft class is not very storng with Bradford being injured and McCoy just doesn't impress me and i don't even think Tebow will go in the 1st round...anyways i think the niners should sign a FA QB now i don't know the list of 2010 FA QB's but if there isn't any good one's i think we should trade for one we could use one of our 1st round picks if that's what it would take.

I would rather have a proven veteran QB than a rookie QB. That way in the draft we could focus on our OL and a pass rusher.

Teebow will go in the 1st round, Jacksonville has already come out and pretty much guaranteed it. They NEED to put fans in the stands now, and think the local guy like Teebow is the one to do it.

My ideal 1st round would be to get Eric Berry and CJ Spiller, and hopefully grab Iupati in the 2nd. I know that everyone thinks he will be a 1st rounder, but look at draft history. Most guards just do not go that high. There were a couple last year with a 1st round grade, and the first one taken was in the 3rd or 4th round I believe.

So if that were to play out for us, there's no way we could draft a QB early. I'd go after Brady Quinn. I don't think the Browns asking price will be that high. I think they are just ready to dump their whole QB situation and start over. I think Quinn is a good player on a bad team. At the very least, he's be an improvement over Hill.

Originally posted by rxrunner:

Originally posted by WheresWaldo:

Originally posted by valrod33:
TOM BRADY

dude i would give up all our draft picks for 2010 for brady

You guys are crazy...Tom Brady with this o-line? He is one of the least mobile qb's in the league.

FAIL.

Yeah Brady's gonna leave an o-line that gives him all day for one that gives him s**t. For his own sake it's a good thing he's not dumb enough to come here.

Fixing our line should be a priority before we talk about ruining another quarterback.

[ Edited by AXEGRINDER on Nov 11, 2009 at 09:12:41 ]

Originally posted by BobS:

Originally posted by Dino:
Alex Smith for Peyton Manning

Manning is too old, and he has already peaked.

Originally posted by lamontb:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Trade for Brady Quinn or draft Sam Bradford, Dan Lefevour or Greg McElroy (if he comes out).

Brady Quinn = Shaun Hill East



With you on Bradford

Nah, I just think Quinn needs to be on a different team. No one is gonna succeed with Mangini there. Quinn has a pretty good arm, footwork and poise in the pocket, worked in a Pro offense in college, he just needs a different team.

Quinn just isn't a good QB.

What QB can succeed in Cleveland??

Please no Rookie QB. I am unwilling to wait another 3+ years for this team to do something on Offense.

In FA:

Chad Pennington
Mike Vick

Trade:

Brady Quinn

Originally posted by LarryT1974:
Sign Chad Pennington to a 2 years contract at the end of the season (guy is a winner when he is healthy) and draft a young QB to actually sit behind the guy and learn. Pennington is deadly accurate and would be able to carve up defenses with Davis and Crabtree running routes for him.

With our O-Line? He'll get hurt again, Larry.

You only trade for or sign a top tier FA QB if you're already a top tier team that is just one player away from being a legit Super Bowl contender (like the Vikings with Favre). There's no reason we should do something like that in the next offseason.

Originally posted by ObePwnD:

Originally posted by LarryT1974:
Sign Chad Pennington to a 2 years contract at the end of the season (guy is a winner when he is healthy) and draft a young QB to actually sit behind the guy and learn. Pennington is deadly accurate and would be able to carve up defenses with Davis and Crabtree running routes for him.

With our O-Line? He'll get hurt again, Larry.

yep correct

Originally posted by JR80Forever:
Please no Rookie QB. I am unwilling to wait another 3+ years for this team to do something on Offense.

In FA:

Chad Pennington
Mike Vick hell yeah he still got his game...

Trade:

Brady Quinn