Originally posted by J49er:
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Originally posted by J49er:
Baalke's BIGGEST mistake is actually deciding to give Dashon Goldson money to a 30yr old cornerback coming off a his first probowl in a contract year: Carlos Rogers. He paid this over the hill player 7 mill per year and decided to franchise Goldson. The correct move should have been locking up the hawk and franchising Rogers or letting him walk, then we probably would have drafted Janoris Jenkins, not AJ Jenkins (another Baalke flop) ...hindsight is a b!#%^
Carlos' deal really has no bearing on Dashon. We offered Goldson 5 yr, $25 mil and he rejected it. Baalke didn't make a mistake. Even now, we're not going to give Dashon $8 mil per year. That's not going to happen. Carlos accepted our offer, Dashon didn't. Simple as that.
Not as simple. Baalke lowballed Goldson and decided Rogers was more valuable thus getting a larger contract. Baalke was wrong there is no debating that when you compare who deserved the higher deal.
Carlos was the better player in 2011. Not to mention CB's are generally more valued than FS's. Carlos was our #1 corner and slot cover man. It made sense to offer him the bigger deal. Baalke was never going to give Dashon the 5 yr, $40 mil deal that he wants. Dashon is a very good player, but he's not that far superior to what we can get at a fraction of the cost. It's business.