There are 97 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Mario Manningham has a Torn ACL and PCL

career possibly over.
Originally posted by Grifter420:
Trade Smith and Staley and a fourth round pick for Fitz.

This ain't Madden.
Originally posted by Garcia:
fool dove right at the back of his knees


Agreed it was an attempt to injure Mario are the 49ers asking the NFL to look at it or not
Originally posted by SkyGod:
Originally posted by Garcia:
fool dove right at the back of his knees


Agreed it was an attempt to injure Mario are the 49ers asking the NFL to look at it or not

Not to mention the guy diving in and slamming his head into the ground when he was already on the ground. The ball may have been loose, but there was no attempt to even go for the ball. He made a clear cut move to pound his head into the turf.
Originally posted by StOnEy333:
Pretty much just a fail on Keg's part. You can't be a bust if you haven't had a chance to play. Lack of talent wasn't his issue. The depth at the position was the reason he sat. Just like LMJ.

That's silly

A) We aren't 15-0. A legit #3 or hell #2 WR would have been helpful in some of our loses
B) Coaches don't hold practices each day to evaluate players?

Your logic argues Harbaugh is saving Jenkins for the playoffs as some super secret weapon this league has never seen before OR that the play of WR's have been so good that he couldn't break the roster. But Randy Moss has started games for us this season.
Originally posted by SkyGod:
Originally posted by Garcia:
fool dove right at the back of his knees


Agreed it was an attempt to injure Mario are the 49ers asking the NFL to look at it or not

classic high/low scummy hit.

These guys will do anything for a win. Time to return the favor, Hope we draw them in the playoff.s
Originally posted by KEGster:
Originally posted by StOnEy333:
Pretty much just a fail on Keg's part. You can't be a bust if you haven't had a chance to play. Lack of talent wasn't his issue. The depth at the position was the reason he sat. Just like LMJ.

That's silly

A) We aren't 15-0. A legit #3 or hell #2 WR would have been helpful in some of our loses
B) Coaches don't hold practices each day to evaluate players?

Your logic argues Harbaugh is saving Jenkins for the playoffs as some super secret weapon this league has never seen before OR that the play of WR's have been so good that he couldn't break the roster. But Randy Moss has started games for us this season.


Your logic argues that LMJ is a bust because he couldn't break the active roster before guys got hurt. So clearly you feel LMJ is a bust and has no business in the NFL.


See, it's easy to put words/ideas in people's mouths.
  • Chico
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,155
surprised no one said this yet...

"Next man up!" - it's time to earn your money Jenkins! Better be good because we expect the best! We have been spoiled for 30 years with stud WR's...
This really sucks. My sports ortho colleagues tell me ACL+PCL is generally MUCH worse than ACL+MCL (e.g. Adrian Peterson). ACL+PCL can be career threatening. Such a bad mood especially after being at the game yesterday...
Originally posted by StOnEy333:
Your logic argues that LMJ is a bust because he couldn't break the active roster before guys got hurt. So clearly you feel LMJ is a bust and has no business in the NFL.


See, it's easy to put words/ideas in people's mouths.

I already illustrated the difference in positions. But okay

James was sitting behind Hunter (Future #1 ?)
Jenkins is behind Kyle Williams & Ted Ginn Jr (Interchangeable parts)




Anyhow, we seem to view our WR's production this season differently. IMO, the Giants fans were right about Manningham and especially Jacobs. Manningham is not a long term answer at the #2 WR spot. Randy has been about what I hoped for. 40 catches and 400 yards receiving
[ Edited by KEGster on Dec 24, 2012 at 6:31 PM ]
Yah it looked pretty bad so it's not a shock.
Terell Owens at age 39 is better than any Street FA that they can bring in and AJ JENKINS is a bust. Unless he miracouloisly transforms. The reason AJ aint playing is because he aint good enough. WR is and was a position of need and yet he still cant get PT?? Whats up with that?
[ Edited by ElephantHaley on Dec 24, 2012 at 6:33 PM ]
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:
Terell Owens at afe 39 is better than any Street FA that they can bring in and AJ JENKINS is a bust. Unless he miracouloisly transforms. The reason AJ aint playing is because he aint good enough. WR is and was a position of need and yet he still cant get PT?? Whats up with that?

lol
Yeah, I'm done in here.
This thread is going stupid with some of the comments. Really??

The ACL/PCL combo of a knee injury is the worst possible...it is career threatening and much worse than Adrian Peterson had last year. It would be a minor miracle if Manningham sees the field next year.

As far as the bust BS about Jenkins and all the other crap maybe it should go into another thread.