Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
Originally posted by verb1der:
Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
If it is so easy to dink and dunk for 18-19 and 3 TDs, why doesn't every journeyman QB do it? And often?
No one seems to have an answer for these questions.
Because they don't have WR's like Moss and Crabtree that can get major YAC?
Check their YAC stats in recent years.
And are you really comparing them to all time greats? Heck...are you really comparing them to, for example, Julio Jones and Roddy White?
And - wait a minute - I though Smith was unable to put the ball in a place to generate YAC?
No matter how you slice it or diminish it, 18-19 is a historic accomplishment. Give dude some respect.
I was just referring to your original question
"if it is so easy dinking and dunking for 18 of 19, 3 Tds". Moss and Crabs made great plays after their catches which lead to 2 TDs and a lot of YAC. That is the reason why not every journeyman QB can't do that, not all of them have that kind of play from their WRs.
And I absolutely give Alex some respect for that game, but personally, I judge him based on how he does against teams that take away Frank Gore (like the Giants did). If Alex can carry the team without the help of a run game, then I will give highest respect! And the 49ers will win a Superbowl!!