Originally posted by DirtyP:
Originally posted by sacniner:
No, he got benched because we couldn't get a first down against Houston. You probalby forgot. Hill is a solid backup. Can win a few games, but not throughout a season. He couldn't have done with Smith did last year.
If you think Dilfer is better than Smith, that says a lot. The memories I have of Dilfer on SF are bad. Really bad.
You're showing your blind bias.
They seem pretty comparable to me
Dilfer 1 superbowl ring
Alex 0 superbowl rings
Dilfers best game with the 49ers, against the eventual NFC champion Cardinals of 2007
25 of 39, 256 yards, 2 TDs, No interceptions
Alex Smiths best game, against the NFC South Champ Saints of 2011
24 of 42, 299 yards 3 touchdowns and no interceptions
The difference? It took Alex Smith 8 years to play his best game as a pro
Never mind the fact one was sidelined due to injury, another season wiped out due to injury and the stellar HC's and play callers this team has had over the past eight years...