Originally posted by Young2Rice:
He analizes the coaches tape. You don't have to agree that Smithy cost us the game or that he didn't help us win.
But you got to admit he missed on three TD opportunities. THe one to KW was obvious. The one to Crabs i didn't see. But the one to walker was obvious as well.
No pressure, no throw - ust checkdowns
Why value one guy's (who never played football) opinion over others'? For all of his (perceived or actual) faults, Smith threw for two TDs in the game. Without the costly fumbles of you-know-who, the 49ers would have won that game. Smith's plays definitely didn't cost the 49ers the game. He might not have done enough, but to say he cost the team the win is biased.