Decided to post this in the WR thread instead of the QB thread.
I don't agree that it should have been a catch but it was a perfect throw. It should have been a catch if it were a stronger receiver such as Crabtree but even Crabs' p***y effort on that wheel route is making me think otherwise.Manningham is what I will use, a "light" runner. The slightest contact will vear him off his desireable path. That little hand check got him off his path but what actually slowed him down was when he looked up to find the ball AFTER the handcheck. Then he found it and burst forward but it was a hair to late.Ginn is also a "light" runner. Kyle Williams is not a light runner. Dude runs choppy but strong and isn't as easily affected from a little normal bumping. (see his TD last year from Alex...was it about 25 yards or so?)Crabtree is the one pissing me off. Dude has all the ability but something just isn't there. I know he can fight for a ball...I've seen it. It could have been just an isolated instance but that wheel route he did not try to jump cradle over Cromartie was very disappointing. Maybe it was because Cromartie and who knows how tight he may have grabbed Crabs arm or whatever but it was not a good attempt.