There are 109 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Do you think Manningham is an upgrade over Morgan ?

Do you think Manningham is an upgrade over Morgan ?

Yes, more skill & explosion..For Less $$...we'll see how good he blocks.
[ Edited by highway49 on Mar 24, 2012 at 11:45 AM ]
wow i thought the voting would be closer than this, i know a lot of people here liked morgan and thought he was our best wr.
Josh Morgan:

2008 Rec: 20 Yrds: 319 TD: 3 GP: 12
2009 Rec: 52 Yrds: 527 TD: 3 GP: 16
2010 Rec: 44 Yrds: 698 TD: 2 GP: 16
2011 Rec: 15 Yrds: 220 TD: 1 GP: 5

Mario Manningham

2008 Rec: 4 Yrds: 24 TD 0 GP 7
2009 Rec:57 Yrds: 822 TD 5 GP 14
2010 Rec: 60 Yrds: 944 TD 9 GP 16
2011 Rec: 39 Yrds: 523 TD 4 GP 12
Originally posted by Hitman49:
Josh Morgan:

2008 Rec: 20 Yrds: 319 TD: 3 GP: 12
2009 Rec: 52 Yrds: 527 TD: 3 GP: 16
2010 Rec: 44 Yrds: 698 TD: 2 GP: 16
2011 Rec: 15 Yrds: 220 TD: 1 GP: 5

Mario Manningham

2008 Rec: 4 Yrds: 24 TD 0 GP 7
2009 Rec:57 Yrds: 822 TD 5 GP 14
2010 Rec: 60 Yrds: 944 TD 9 GP 16
2011 Rec: 39 Yrds: 523 TD 4 GP 12

Josh Morgan had stats nearly identical to Arnaz Battle in his prime years with the 49ers.
Josh Morgan is a great dude, teammate and hard worker,

Mario Manningham physically is way more talented than Morgan.

I think we value Morgan higher than most would due to our respect a lot of us have of him as a person. Would have loved to have kept him around here, but if I had to choose between the two, it's a no brainer, Manningham can make special catches and his career will continue to peak. We got him for a great price and we will see it come September.

This is going to be a great year to get Madden and revel in the roster. Can anyone remember a time when you could pick the Niners in franchise and pretty much play with as is?