Originally posted by SofaKing:
I guess I just have a higher opinion of Manningham than others. He is much better at creating seperation than any of our WR's, he possesses big play ability downfield, and can create after the catch. He is a better player than Morgan. Morgan is 1 inch taller and about 30 lbs heavier so they are not the same size, speed. Injuries hurt his production this year, but in 2010 he had 60 catches for 900+ yards. He hasn't hit his ceiling yet. He is a talented young player.
See-Product of the system.
Manningham is going to get overpaid, go somewhere else, be mediocre, people are going to realize he's really not that good. Steve Smith was a 1000 yard receiver with the Giants, he went to the Eagles and even when he was healthy he did jack s**t. Not buying it, sorry. How many WR's and RB's have walked away from the Giants over the past few years and looked like garbage elsewhere?