When I ask this, I mean do you think it is reasonably catchable. Is it within reason to think he could make that catch? I am interested in knowing this for a purpose. Everyone's arguing about this catch, if we can establish a HEAVY majority that says one of the other, it'll be clearer what the truth of the matter is.
If we held a poll saying, "Did Alex play bad today?" The vote would be close to 100% .. So let's put the vote to the test on the play. Do you think it is within reason to say this is a catch that another player possibly could have made?
Cast your vote.