Lite Niner Convo (If Troy performs)

Originally posted by ninertico:

Originally posted by valrod33:
Eric_Branch

RT @NinerNation07: Say Niners lose next two games ... why bring Alex back after 3 weeks? >> If he's healthy, to see if they want him in '11.

Already have enough tape on Alex for 2010 to warrant a HELL NO!!!!!

Actually, Smith was playing pretty well, and improving each week under Mike Johnson. It was becoming apparent that Raye was holding back the Offense a great deal.

Originally posted by binary2nd:

Originally posted by ninertico:

Originally posted by valrod33:
Eric_Branch

RT @NinerNation07: Say Niners lose next two games ... why bring Alex back after 3 weeks? >> If he's healthy, to see if they want him in '11.

Already have enough tape on Alex for 2010 to warrant a HELL NO!!!!!

Actually, Smith was playing pretty well, and improving each week under Mike Johnson. It was becoming apparent that Raye was holding back the Offense a great deal.

Thats highly debatable.

Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:

Originally posted by ninertico:

Originally posted by valrod33:
Eric_Branch

RT @NinerNation07: Say Niners lose next two games ... why bring Alex back after 3 weeks? >> If he's healthy, to see if they want him in '11.

Already have enough tape on Alex for 2010 to warrant a HELL NO!!!!!

What more do we have to see? Coaches, QB's are judged by Wins and Losses. Singletary and Smith don't have enough wins to keep bringing them back. Cut ties and move on.

Unless of course your name is Shaun Hill and you play for the Niners....

Andy Reid says no.

Alex Smith
Troy Smith
David Carr
Mike Singletary

ALL gone next year

Originally posted by WestCoast:
Alex Smith
Troy Smith
David Carr
Mike Singletary

ALL gone next year

Originally posted by susweel:
Smith should not be allowed back on the field even if Troy doesn't play good.

Use the rest of the season to evaluate Nate Davis and Troy. No point in playing Smith because he is not part of the future.

LOL Nate Davis will not see the playing field

Originally posted by WestCoast:
Alex Smith
Troy Smith
David Carr
Mike Singletary

ALL gone next year

Why troy Smith??? What the hell did he do to be on this list

Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:

Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:

Originally posted by ninertico:

Originally posted by valrod33:
Eric_Branch

RT @NinerNation07: Say Niners lose next two games ... why bring Alex back after 3 weeks? >> If he's healthy, to see if they want him in '11.

Already have enough tape on Alex for 2010 to warrant a HELL NO!!!!!

What more do we have to see? Coaches, QB's are judged by Wins and Losses. Singletary and Smith don't have enough wins to keep bringing them back. Cut ties and move on.

Unless of course your name is Shaun Hill and you play for the Niners....

Let me ask this, who would you rather have starting this week, Shaun Hill, Troy Smith or David Carr?

Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
If Troy plays solid/average and we win the next 3 to 4 games with him at the helm, would you put Alex back in the line up when he's healthy?

ABSOLUTELY NOT.

Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:

Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:

Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:

Originally posted by ninertico:

Originally posted by valrod33:
Eric_Branch

RT @NinerNation07: Say Niners lose next two games ... why bring Alex back after 3 weeks? >> If he's healthy, to see if they want him in '11.

Already have enough tape on Alex for 2010 to warrant a HELL NO!!!!!

What more do we have to see? Coaches, QB's are judged by Wins and Losses. Singletary and Smith don't have enough wins to keep bringing them back. Cut ties and move on.

Unless of course your name is Shaun Hill and you play for the Niners....

Let me ask this, who would you rather have starting this week, Shaun Hill, Troy Smith or David Carr?

Hill

Originally posted by binary2nd:

Originally posted by ninertico:

Originally posted by valrod33:
Eric_Branch

RT @NinerNation07: Say Niners lose next two games ... why bring Alex back after 3 weeks? >> If he's healthy, to see if they want him in '11.

Already have enough tape on Alex for 2010 to warrant a HELL NO!!!!!

Actually, Smith was playing pretty well, and improving each week under Mike Johnson. It was becoming apparent that Raye was holding back the Offense a great deal.

Alex played well on the first drive of each week under Mike Johnson. After that, same old Alex.

Originally posted by wailers15:

Originally posted by susweel:
Smith should not be allowed back on the field even if Troy doesn't play good.

Use the rest of the season to evaluate Nate Davis and Troy. No point in playing Smith because he is not part of the future.

LOL Nate Davis will not see the playing field

LOL Nate Davis sucks. LOL Nate Davis won't see the playing field. LOL Nate Davis only knows 3 plays.

Give it a rest. Alex Smith sucks. So does David Carr. If Troy Smith stinks it up, we WILL see Nate Davis on the playing field.

The same people that whine about people hating on Alex Smith are the ones hating on Nate Davis. The only difference is the people that realize Smith sucks have actually SEEN him stink it up on a weekly basis. The people hating on Nate Davis have no evidence outside of ONE preseason game. Please.

Stop hating on the kid. He hasn't done anything to you.

Originally posted by wailers15:

Originally posted by WestCoast:
Alex Smith
Troy Smith
David Carr
Mike Singletary

ALL gone next year

Why troy Smith??? What the hell did he do to be on this list

What the hell did Nate Davis do for you to hate on him?????

LMAO

Originally posted by 49erRider:

Originally posted by wailers15:

Originally posted by WestCoast:
Alex Smith
Troy Smith
David Carr
Mike Singletary

ALL gone next year

Why troy Smith??? What the hell did he do to be on this list

What the hell did Nate Davis do for you to hate on him?????

LMAO

Why do we have to hate any of the QBs? I don't get it. I just want to see them play well. If it's Troy Smith then leave him as the starter. If he doesn't get it done replace him back with Alex. If he plays bad some more then give Nate Davis a shot. The only one who really has no shot to play well at all is David Carr.