Benching the starting QB during a game sends a message

global_nomad · 2010-10-04T19:45:27-07:00

Fitzpatrick for Edwards Vick for Kolb Collins for Young Clausen for Moore Gradkowski for Campbell Hall for Anderson Thigpen for Henne let me know if I forgot anyone else... Doesn't it make sense to bench a starter for at least a quarter or a half, like Tenneesee did with Vince Young. They gave Vince his starting position back the next week, but it also sent the message that you need to preform at a certain level. This is the NFL. Campbell got benched and even the Raiders went with a QB that helps them move the ball. Whinenhunt had the balls to pull Anderson from the game to put in a nobody at QB, but he did it to send a message. I'm tired of the excuse, do you really think Carr is better than Smith? He doesn't have to be physically better, he just has to make less mistakes. I'm still hoping we can run off 4 or 5 of the next six against less talented opponets, but we can't if we keep killing ourselves. We were 10 seconds away from being 2-2 with less than average QB play, I wonder what we can be with just average QB play. Lastly in the words of one Michael Singletary, "Don't Tell me, Show Me" I know Carr might not be as good, but as soon Alex throws 2 more INTs in a game i would like to see him benched to send the message, you can't turn the ball over 2+ times a game week in and week out. Let Carr play a quarter just so Alex sees what it looks like to take care of the ball.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:48 PM

zeppfan1
Veteran
Posts: 9,778

good point, but Singletary is foolishly and blindly behind Smith. Someone please stop the horror.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:48 PM

fly15
Veteran
Posts: 5,790

Alex is next

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:49 PM

BodhiPaddlesOut
Veteran
Posts: 9,850

Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:50 PM

highwayone
Veteran
Posts: 2,185

Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:51 PM

smithgdwg
Veteran
Posts: 20,473

Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Season already over with Smith in there, so I don't see the difference.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:54 PM

Joecool
Veteran
Posts: 70,984

To the original poster: did you actually mention making a change during a game?

You know better than this. We could be running a dive play for 40 plays throughout the entire game and a change won't happen until after the game is over. Then, in the next game, we will pass 40 times and another change won't happen until the third game. And in the third game, we will be balanced on offense but blitz every play and get torched for 40 points. Then in the 4th game...

...need anymore explanation?

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:55 PM

global_nomad
Veteran
Posts: 14,827

Originally posted by highwayone:
Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

I'm not saying bench him before the game. I'm saying if he keeps making poor game decisions. Then but Carr in (during the game) to see if he can salvage the situation.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:55 PM

BodhiPaddlesOut
Veteran
Posts: 9,850

Originally posted by smithgdwg:
Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Season already over with Smith in there, so I don't see the difference.

That's my point.

No QB on this team offers any better chance to win than Alex. At least he's got experience with the system and has more talent.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:57 PM

ninerfan818
Veteran
Posts: 6,400

Originally posted by smithgdwg:
Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Season already over with Smith in there, so I don't see the difference.

For real. Does anyone really believe the playoffs are within reach?? I cannot guarantee a win against anybody with this lackluster offence led by a terrible QB. Change might be just the spark the team needs.

I think it is time to see what Nate has. He should be elevated from the PS and put Smith onto the PS. See if someone snatches him up, LOL. Nobody would take Smith from the PS, He is worthless.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:58 PM

#10

global_nomad
Veteran
Posts: 14,827

Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Originally posted by smithgdwg:
Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Season already over with Smith in there, so I don't see the difference.

That's my point.

No QB on this team offers any better chance to win than Alex. At least he's got experience with the system and has more talent.

I'd rather see what Carr can do mid-game, instead of penciling in Alex's 2 INTs a game. If Alex has 2 ints, i'll pull him right there just to send a message, you can't make those kind of decisions/high throws week in and week out. You are our starter but protect the damn ball and give us a chance to win.

Oct 4, 2010 at 7:59 PM

#11

smithgdwg
Veteran
Posts: 20,473

I say trade Alex Smith for anything.

Of course the only way someone will take him is if we offer something in addition.

Oct 4, 2010 at 8:01 PM

#12

global_nomad
Veteran
Posts: 14,827

Originally posted by smithgdwg:
I say trade Alex Smith for anything.

Of course the only way someone will take him is if we offer something in addition.

the bills released their 3rd round QB, they have no value if you don't win.

Oct 4, 2010 at 8:02 PM

#13

chico49erfan
Veteran
Posts: 13,961

Didn't Kolb go down with injury? Without that injury Vick still hasn't seen the field.

Oct 4, 2010 at 8:02 PM

#14

sacniner
Member
Posts: 31,684

Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Originally posted by smithgdwg:
Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
Alex Smith being benched = season is completely over. You don't know football if you don't realize this.

At least wait for a loss to the Eagles.

Season already over with Smith in there, so I don't see the difference.

That's my point.

No QB on this team offers any better chance to win than Alex. At least he's got experience with the system and has more talent.