Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by buck:
Originally posted by vrabbit:
RG3, my god this board has lost all objectivity whatsoever
The question asked is fundamentally irrational.
Why? It's a legit question. I think RG3 might be more talented overall than Kap, but I'd rather have Kap as my QB for the simple fact that RG3 is very injury prone and has a history.
How is he more talented? Kaep is taller, bigger, stronger, with a stronger arm (yes even stronger than RG3). Just as fast. Less injury history.
What are you basing "more talented" on? Higher draft pick? Sometimes people miss in the draft. Montana was in the 3rd round. Brady in the 6th. You don't think they would go higher if they did those drafts over?
Kaep would go higher for sure if they did that draft over. And RG3 maybe lower since he can't even get through 1 season without tearing up his knee and buckling it over and over despite a brace. To go along with his other ripped up knee from college. RG3 was drafted too high IMO for long term health prospects. Giving up 3 first rounders for him was crazy. The argument is closer than you guys think. Based on everything we know now I'd say Kaep.