If they were both making 24 million for 3 years I would probably take Peyton. Alex with this team and at 24 mil compared to 96 I go with Alex. Still winning a SB with Alex will feel 1000 times better than with Manning. It will be more earned... if we would have won it with Peyton people would have said we only won because of him.
Peyton (5) = 96 million
Alex (3), Carlos (4), Ahmad (5), Manningham (2), Cox (2), Moss (1), Jacobs (1) = 110 million
[ Edited by Gore_21 on Sep 18, 2012 at 9:19 AM ]