Originally posted by Evilgenius:
Originally posted by andes14:
My other issues with the list are that Bowman is tragically low. 85??? For a dude that was a 1st team All Pro as a 23 year old and the clear-cut 2nd best ILB in the NFL?? AND the list is for 2012 so as a 24 year old 2nd year starter he should be even better. Mind-boggling. Probably deserves to be top-30. And you're telling me guys like Tim Tebow and John Kuhn deserve to be on this list over guys like Dashon Goldson and Aldon Smith?? Strong arguments can be made for guys like RayMac, Sope (NT is the key and the central cog to a 3-4's run D and ours was legendary), and Iupati over Chris Johnson, Finnegan, Flacco, Lynch
Finnegan was easily one of the best corners in the league last year. Iupati has no business on the list. Too inconsistent. Kuhn definitely doesn't belong. Ray Mac does. Aldon does. Goldson, not so much.
Chris Johnson definitely doesn't belong.
If it was my list, which I'm thinking of doing one, Aldon would be on it, and Patrick Peterson would be off it. And no Tebow.
I would have the following 49ers on the list.
I would be debating Ray McDonald and Mike Iupati. Goldson would NOT be on my top 100 list.